#metabrainz

I wonder if we should have a smaller group takes this on and come up with some candiates.

yeah sure ruaok

xBrainz is generally the "source" projects, and BrainzX is derivatives (e.g., BrainzBot)

doing this in a large group is likely going to take foreever and yield poor results.

we can dsicuss it outside the meeting

FWIW, there was a discussion about it a few weeks/months ago with candidates.

_lucifer: pick 3-5 people as a team and then start there.

👍

we can this for the meeting, Freso

*end

Alright.

Thank you all for your time! Stay safe out there!

</BANG>

Thanks !

I suggest we come with a list and put it on community forums for voting and finalize it by next week

Mr_Monkey: can you come with an icon ? it need not be immediate whenever you ahve the time

take care everybody!

I would like if forums have a poll feature

Perhaps after we have a name chosen might be better

Lol I have an idea just now

For brainzdroid

Yeah, sure only makes sense after that :)

So is BrainzDroid Books in the plans eventually? ;-)

rdswift: once BrainzDroid Music is stable and has a sufficient feature set, I'd say why not?

👍

_lucifer: agreed ! apart from a name to the app, the webservices in the app are not android device portable. The websites open in the browser in a desktop view

few changes in the meta tags,if can be done would be really supportive to the current responsive design

yeah sure. we can work on that.

you know my vote is for "Data" something becasue it's android

CritiqueBrainz integration in the app shall also arrive but I don not have a timeline on that

_lucifer: found previously proposed names, it started with https://chatlogs.metabrainz.org/brainzbot/metab...

i remember that CatQuest ;)

good :>

thanks yvanzo for the link

I see in the previous discussion as well BrainzDroid was proposed :)

bitmap, yvanzo, CatQuest: for Add Instrument edits, should we use l_instrument_descriptions (so, should the description be shown translated if we have a translation), or for edit display is it better to show the English original instead even if using an MB translation?

(was going to change it to use the translated version, but then wondered since it might be weird for ones that, for example, got changed since and are no longer translated in that original version)

uh I'd say use the translation if there is one?

reosarevok: why would you not localize it? How would you know it was not translated at the time of the edit?

yvanzo: because this is Add Instrument, so the description didn't exist when the edit gets entered

oh

that's adifferent indeed

So there's no translation at first for sure

I'd say don't mess with "add instrument"

Everywhere else I'd show translations (and we already do), but not sure about edit history since it kinda makes it look like the instrument edit added it in French or whatever

infact it shoudl show the description that was given it (in english) always for those (I sometimes even look at these to compare with what I wrote later)

(would be weird to get a note like "this is wrong in French")

yea

reosarevok: I'd show it as entered by the edit in english

Ok

for add and edit instrument there shoudl not be the tranlsated descriptions i'd say

what bitmap said :D

+1

[musicbrainz-server] reosarevok opened pull request #1602 (master…MBS-10972): MBS-10972: Convert Add Instrument edit to React https://github.com/metabrainz/musicbrainz-serve...

MBS-10972: Convert Add Instrument edit to React https://tickets.metabrainz.org/browse/MBS-10972

From the current and earlier discussion, I was able to gather BrainzDroid, BrainzDroid Music and Data. I have put these in the post.

Feel free to suggest your own name or support one of these :)

I have suggested PicardDroid. Capitalises on the Picard brand.

ARG

this is why i want Data though :(

_lucifer: i cant vote ?

BrainzDroid doesn't do this - and if it will have to be BrainzDroid Music in case we ever want e.g. a BookBrainz android app.

CatQuest: you can

Problem with Data is that it is is too generic.

nope I see no ticketboxes or voting buttons

How about Archer? Or Janeway? Or Riker?

Sophist-UK: i know that wich is why it needs some more stuff (like "ltn. comander" attaced)

Yuk!

riker is kepstins of sorts player

Sophist-UK: so is you

I don't like PicardDroid either.

CatQuest: you should now

How about "Lucutus" as the app name - he was Picard as a sort of Droid?

bitmap, yvanzo: what about add_relationship_attribute? https://musicbrainz.org/edit/62342371

Same general issue

I'm thinking translate parent name but not sure about attribute name

for edit data entered by the user I think I'd always show it how it was entered

but translating parent name seems fine

Ok

[musicbrainz-server] reosarevok opened pull request #1603 (master…MBS-10973): MBS-10973: Convert Add Relationship Attribute edit to React https://github.com/metabrainz/musicbrainz-serve...

MBS-10973: Convert Add Relationship Attribute edit to React https://tickets.metabrainz.org/browse/MBS-10973

Sorry, I missed the meeting. Nothing much to report, usual sysadmin stuff (trying to prevent kids to put the house on fire mainly), plus working on Picard next release (another beta soon), plus summer.

summer! \o/

[musicbrainz-server] reosarevok opened pull request #1604 (master…MBS-10974): MBS-10974: Convert Remove ISRC edit to React https://github.com/metabrainz/musicbrainz-serve...

MBS-10974: Convert Remove ISRC edit to React https://tickets.metabrainz.org/browse/MBS-10974

[musicbrainz-server] reosarevok opened pull request #1605 (master…MBS-10975): MBS-10975: Convert Remove ISWC edit to React https://github.com/metabrainz/musicbrainz-serve...

MBS-10975: Convert Remove ISWC edit to React https://tickets.metabrainz.org/browse/MBS-10975