fatih: yer, but the three releases, except for the title are the same. When I put my CD in the disc IDs identifies the discs as part of the other compilations (with the same tracks etc). So what do you do... add the disc id to two different releases - just for the title? Can you clone a release for that?
2010-05-01 12109, 2010
Leftmost
I think the accepted policy is to leave identical releases as the same release.
2010-05-01 12137, 2010
fatih
Industrial Armageddon is a 2 disc release.
2010-05-01 12157, 2010
fatih
Industrial Virus has 3 discs.
2010-05-01 12141, 2010
fatih
But Industrial Virus and Industrial Hazard are identical.
2010-05-01 12105, 2010
ekes
jep, just googled, Industrial Armageddon despite having one of the discids (and same tracks) just has one less disc. So the challenge is how do you merge Industrial Virus and Industrial Hazard?
2010-05-01 12101, 2010
fatih
Discs 2&3 of I.V. are in MB but disc 1 is not. You can either add disc 1 too, and add "later release of" relationships, or merge discs 2 and 3 into corresponding Industrial Hazard discs.
2010-05-01 12142, 2010
fatih
But I don't see a problem with duplicate releases with different titles, because in NGS each release event will be a separate release anyway.
2010-05-01 12149, 2010
ekes googles NGS - ok...
2010-05-01 12109, 2010
ekes
I do think in this case it's just a one off release with a different title. 'Diseased by Total/BMG'
2010-05-01 12140, 2010
ekes
Also I dunno how NGS will work - but you want to syncronise any cleanup on the titles etc.
2010-05-01 12137, 2010
ekes
any cleanup or annotations I guess..
2010-05-01 12158, 2010
dinog1 joined the channel
2010-05-01 12100, 2010
dinog joined the channel
2010-05-01 12101, 2010
dinog1 joined the channel
2010-05-01 12139, 2010
neothe0ne joined the channel
2010-05-01 12103, 2010
neothe0ne
anyone want to discuss rewriting / removing Extra Title Information Style
2010-05-01 12117, 2010
neothe0ne
brianfreud?
2010-05-01 12129, 2010
brianfreud
yes?
2010-05-01 12102, 2010
brianfreud
I've been leaving ETI style alone for now, until after NGS and Warp's title proposal.
2010-05-01 12107, 2010
neothe0ne
would you agree with my view that ETI is written PURELY from an English/latin point of view.
2010-05-01 12138, 2010
neothe0ne
both important sentences in the guideilne talk about requiring parentheses (not used in all languages as the standard) and case (many dont, obviously pictograpohic languages)
2010-05-01 12147, 2010
dinog joined the channel
2010-05-01 12150, 2010
neothe0ne
(and what is warp's title proposal)
2010-05-01 12118, 2010
nikki
hi neo
2010-05-01 12137, 2010
neothe0ne
hi nikki
2010-05-01 12140, 2010
neothe0ne
hi nikki
2010-05-01 12122, 2010
nikki
if you read the extra title stuff literally, it even messes up german
2010-05-01 12118, 2010
nikki
so I do agree that it's written from an english point of view :P
