#musicbrainz

hmm... I was wrong. Not even 3rd did work. Now I got "Caught exception in MusicBrainz::Server::Controller::ReleaseEditor::Add->add "Can't use an undefined value as a HASH reference at lib/MusicBrainz/Server/Wizard.pm line 268." on last page when adding a note

added all full errors to this: http://tickets.musicbrainz.org/browse/MBS-5806

warp: ^

How does one reliably find the release date for something? If the copyright date isn’t reliable, what else is there?

hawke_1: Notices on web sites.

?

nikki: Lucky. :-p

:D

hawke_1: If the release is from when MySpace was big, you can often find something there.

Freso: I’m mostly thinking about pre-1995 releases. :-D

sometimes you can find release dates on label websites

hawke_1: A lot of more recent ones have Facebook events for release parties etc., so you can dig through Facebook pages' events.

hawke_1: Yes, Facebook probably doesn't work for that. :D

or artist websites

hawke_1: Hint, if the site says 1700 or earlier, it's most likely wrong.

I actually usually use copyright date unless it’s obviously wrong.

Just saying.

or discogs, ’cos they’re trustworthy.

I use it if there's no better data or contradicting data available.

But I have no idea where they get their info from, or if it’s just a guess like I am doing. :-)

a lot of them seem awfully precise for being just a guess, but still.

Okay, this release is from 1972 at the earlist and 1979 at the latest.

A D8 will do.

1976 it is.

September.

>_>

:-D

Freso: Are you a D&D player ? :P

Lotheric: No.

Lotheric: I never really liked (A)D&D.

you know your dice!

Lotheric: Too fighting focused, not enough RP.

Lotheric: Sure. There are RPGs besides (A)D&D.

Freso: I like 2nd edition

Lotheric: WFRP was my first and true RPG system love.

But I quite like FUDGE as well.

Freso: Is this Warhammer fantasy ? I have the rulebook but never played

Lotheric: It is, yeah. :)

hawke_1: I wouldn't complain about a copyright date if someone actually mentions it in the edit note (so that anyone checking later can be like "ah, so that's why it's not quite right"), if you're pretty sure you've got the original release, that is

Lotheric: I have the 2nd and 3rd ed. Never got around trying 3rd ed. :(

Freso: I have an old edition from the 80's, with Gotrek & Felix on the cover

Lotheric: And except for a few extremely hardcore ones, no one's done 1st ed. :p

Lotheric: That might actually be 1st ed. :p Though 1st and 2nd are very similar.

2nd to 3rd are a much bigger leap.

Lotheric: If you still play, you should check FUDGE. It's a nifty and small system, freely available.

Lotheric: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fudge_%28role-pla...

Freso: I wanted to start DMing a campaign with Myth & Magic (it's like AD&D 2.5 sort of)

Freso: but the books are so slow to get out and I don't want PDFs

"Just fudge it" haha

seems a bit simplistic for my taste though

Lotheric: That's one of the things I like about it. :)

Lotheric: I really think the roleplaying should be about roleplaying, not rollplaying.

Freso: I need a good mix of both

And the more rules and system you put on top, the less role and the more roll it becomes.

You guys support the discnumber tag, correct?

"You guys"?

wjtaylor_: Please be more specific.

Picard I assume :p

If I have a multidisc set, there is a field in your db that tells what disc # the track belongs to

Yes.

anyone good with foobar2000 titleformatting ?

I'm trying to improve this : '['b']'%tracknumber%.'[''/'b']' '['i']'%artist%'[''/'i']' - %title% '('%length%')''[''/'size']'

so it can add [size=1] before the first ( in the %title%

woot

got it

anyone here know gianluca?

hi Freso. Ah ok, you meant I add two releases from DiscID then merge them. Because of technical constraints, yes indeed, that’s what I do. :)

jesus2099: No, that's not at all what I was talking about.

argh, then what, Freso ? :D

jesus2099: Read the log leading up to the message where I mentioned you. It's in the ~2-3 messages leading up to it.

I did before first asking… I didn’t understand, really.

no, sorry, http://tickets.musicbrainz.org/browse/MBS-5808

(yes indeed, it has connexion with INLINE STUFF of course, wrong link paste grrr)

jesus2099: http://chatlogs.musicbrainz.org/musicbrainz/201...

« [peoepl should] stop asking questions and then leaving before I can answer » ha ha ha

but

anyway I always get read the answers to my questions and thank afterwards

do we really have to create TWO tickets in JIRA for on RFC ?

a STYLE ticket and an MBS ticket ?

couldn’t we just transform the STYLE ticket into MBS after votes ?

question - how do people expect a cd ripper to handle ripping multiple singles with the same name ?

(imagine musicbrainz doesn't know much about the difference except that there are multiple releases in that release group with the same name)

I generally rename between rips.

Or do you mean tracklist?

Err, I asked that poorly.

Do you mean how to select which release is the correct one?

no, that part's fine

I mean naming the output directory

right now, morituri assumes it should overwrite or continue the rip

I'm adding smth to detect that it's about to overwrite a successful rip of another version

so I want to come up with a new name somehow for the second release

You could just do the general (1) sort of thing.

Unless there's a disambig comment.

hm, yeah

is for example 'green' a valid disambiguation comment ?

to indicate that this is commonly known as the green single ?