#musicbrainz

/

      • andreypopp joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03254, 2013

      • voiceinsideyou joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03229, 2013

      • andreypopp joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03240, 2013

      • skd5aner joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03200, 2013

      • voiceinsideyou joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03237, 2013

      • dwg joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03205, 2013

      • andreypopp joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03211, 2013

      • skd5aner joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03227, 2013

      • DarkerAudit joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03246, 2013

      • andreypopp joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03240, 2013

      • TheLastProject joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03231, 2013

      • gmk1 joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03243, 2013

      • andreypopp joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03214, 2013

      • Leftmost joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03220, 2013

      • ijabz joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03240, 2013

      • MJ joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03239, 2013

      • andreypopp joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03213, 2013

      • ehrgeiz_ joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03206, 2013

      • jesus2099 joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03252, 2013

      • jesus2099
        hi Freso. Ah ok, you meant I add two releases from DiscID then merge them. Because of technical constraints, yes indeed, that’s what I do. :)
      • 2013-02-01 03212, 2013

      • gmk1 joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03212, 2013

      • uptown joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03241, 2013

      • Freso
        jesus2099: No, that's not at all what I was talking about.
      • 2013-02-01 03259, 2013

      • jesus2099
        argh, then what, Freso ? :D
      • 2013-02-01 03224, 2013

      • Freso
        jesus2099: Read the log leading up to the message where I mentioned you. It's in the ~2-3 messages leading up to it.
      • 2013-02-01 03252, 2013

      • jesus2099
        I did before first asking… I didn’t understand, really.
      • 2013-02-01 03208, 2013

      • jesus2099
        btw I added a ticket that is following one of your fixes ! http://userscripts.org/scripts/fans/81127
      • 2013-02-01 03215, 2013

      • jesus2099
      • 2013-02-01 03253, 2013

      • jesus2099
        (yes indeed, it has connexion with INLINE STUFF of course, wrong link paste grrr)
      • 2013-02-01 03227, 2013

      • Freso
      • 2013-02-01 03208, 2013

      • jesus2099
        « [peoepl should] stop asking questions and then leaving before I can answer » ha ha ha
      • 2013-02-01 03215, 2013

      • jesus2099
        but
      • 2013-02-01 03237, 2013

      • jesus2099 says « people stop being logged in but not there » in IRC, it’s worse :)
      • 2013-02-01 03211, 2013

      • jesus2099
        anyway I always get read the answers to my questions and thank afterwards
      • 2013-02-01 03237, 2013

      • jesus2099
        do we really have to create TWO tickets in JIRA for on RFC ?
      • 2013-02-01 03246, 2013

      • jesus2099
        a STYLE ticket and an MBS ticket ?
      • 2013-02-01 03201, 2013

      • jesus2099
        couldn’t we just transform the STYLE ticket into MBS after votes ?
      • 2013-02-01 03232, 2013

      • reosarevok joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03203, 2013

      • nikki joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03249, 2013

      • nikki joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03205, 2013

      • thomasvs
        question - how do people expect a cd ripper to handle ripping multiple singles with the same name ?
      • 2013-02-01 03226, 2013

      • thomasvs
        (imagine musicbrainz doesn't know much about the difference except that there are multiple releases in that release group with the same name)
      • 2013-02-01 03217, 2013

      • Leftmost
        I generally rename between rips.
      • 2013-02-01 03226, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Or do you mean tracklist?
      • 2013-02-01 03234, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Err, I asked that poorly.
      • 2013-02-01 03246, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Do you mean how to select which release is the correct one?
      • 2013-02-01 03256, 2013

      • thomasvs
        no, that part's fine
      • 2013-02-01 03200, 2013

      • thomasvs
        I mean naming the output directory
      • 2013-02-01 03210, 2013

      • thomasvs
        right now, morituri assumes it should overwrite or continue the rip
      • 2013-02-01 03224, 2013

      • thomasvs
        I'm adding smth to detect that it's about to overwrite a successful rip of another version
      • 2013-02-01 03235, 2013

      • thomasvs
        so I want to come up with a new name somehow for the second release
      • 2013-02-01 03203, 2013

      • Leftmost
        You could just do the general (1) sort of thing.
      • 2013-02-01 03213, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Unless there's a disambig comment.
      • 2013-02-01 03229, 2013

      • thomasvs
        hm, yeah
      • 2013-02-01 03244, 2013

      • thomasvs
        is for example 'green' a valid disambiguation comment ?
      • 2013-02-01 03254, 2013

      • thomasvs
        to indicate that this is commonly known as the green single ?
      • 2013-02-01 03221, 2013

      • reosarevok
        yep
      • 2013-02-01 03235, 2013

      • thomasvs
        ok, I guess that could work
      • 2013-02-01 03253, 2013

      • thomasvs
        and the common case of two editions of singles sold separately but meant to be collected together ?
      • 2013-02-01 03201, 2013

      • thomasvs
        are we supposed to treat that as a two disc single release ?
      • 2013-02-01 03213, 2013

      • Leftmost
        I would usually put something a bit clearer if I could (see Weezer), but yeah.
      • 2013-02-01 03218, 2013

      • Leftmost
        thomasvs, multiple releases, I think.
      • 2013-02-01 03224, 2013

      • reosarevok
        You mean the silly UK thing with CD 1 and CD 2?
      • 2013-02-01 03227, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Do you mean the UK CD 1/UK CD 2?
      • 2013-02-01 03228, 2013

      • reosarevok
        Multiple releases, yep
      • 2013-02-01 03233, 2013

      • Leftmost fights reosarevok.
      • 2013-02-01 03256, 2013

      • thomasvs
        oh, really, separate ? even if they made a jewelcase that contains CD1 and you're supposed to add CD2 to that after buying it ?
      • 2013-02-01 03205, 2013

      • thomasvs
        ok
      • 2013-02-01 03213, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Yeah.
      • 2013-02-01 03217, 2013

      • thomasvs
        so in the UK case, do you actually put disc 1 and disc 2 in the title ? or in the disambiguation ?
      • 2013-02-01 03241, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Disambig, unless the cover specifies.
      • 2013-02-01 03202, 2013

      • thomasvs
        cover specifies? you mean, if the cover says, part 2 of a two cd set, you put it in the title?
      • 2013-02-01 03229, 2013

      • Leftmost
        If the cover says something like "Milk (CD 1)" or the like, though it usually would just say "Milk".
      • 2013-02-01 03254, 2013

      • Leftmost
      • 2013-02-01 03256, 2013

      • thomasvs
        ok, so basically, disambiguation is for anything you can't tell from the title but you can tell from the rest of the disc
      • 2013-02-01 03202, 2013

      • Leftmost
        The two UK releases are a CD 1 and CD 2.
      • 2013-02-01 03205, 2013

      • Leftmost
        I should probably add disambig.
      • 2013-02-01 03208, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Right.
      • 2013-02-01 03205, 2013

      • thomasvs
        yeah, and the first one says 'medium' not CD
      • 2013-02-01 03213, 2013

      • thomasvs
        wow, joe strummer co-wrote stupid girl? I had no idea
      • 2013-02-01 03220, 2013

      • reosarevok
        thomasvs: well, mostly for something you can't tell from the standard data we have
      • 2013-02-01 03230, 2013

      • thomasvs
        ok, thanks for the explanation, let's see what I can do with that this weekend
      • 2013-02-01 03235, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Well, the first is the German release. Someone just left out some info.
      • 2013-02-01 03258, 2013

      • thomasvs
        pretty sure I already do disambiguation, to get past the Weezer case. But I also want to handle this when it's missing that field.
      • 2013-02-01 03203, 2013

      • reosarevok
        I mean, at a release group level, it's generally just "not the same name"
      • 2013-02-01 03217, 2013

      • reosarevok
        At a release level, since barcodes and such already help, it's much less common
      • 2013-02-01 03252, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Probably just a generic (1) or something.
      • 2013-02-01 03219, 2013

      • thomasvs
        yeah, works for me. Plus morituri almost has a retag/rename option, so people can fix disambiguation then trigger rename
      • 2013-02-01 03223, 2013

      • Leftmost
        I still have yet to try morituri, though I'm interested in the project.
      • 2013-02-01 03211, 2013

      • thomasvs
        it rips cds, makes you dinner, and does the dishes afterwards.
      • 2013-02-01 03213, 2013

      • thomasvs
        you should try it
      • 2013-02-01 03233, 2013

      • reosarevok
        huh, I don't use CDs but if it still makes me dinner maybe I should :p
      • 2013-02-01 03215, 2013

      • Leftmost
        Will it make dinner for two, or just for one?
      • 2013-02-01 03227, 2013

      • thomasvs
        depends on the quality of the cd you're ripping
      • 2013-02-01 03255, 2013

      • Leftmost
        I have excellent taste.
      • 2013-02-01 03201, 2013

      • thomasvs
        then two it is
      • 2013-02-01 03223, 2013

      • thomasvs
        hm, using track count may make sense too if there's no disambiguation. or mbid.
      • 2013-02-01 03237, 2013

      • nikki puts CD 1 and CD 2 in the disambiguation comment for uk singles
      • 2013-02-01 03206, 2013

      • nikki
        some people want to copy the wording used on the cover, but I want to be able to detect particular types of disambiguation comments :/
      • 2013-02-01 03237, 2013

      • reosarevok
        "Legend of the Knightwasher – which is, in fact, about a washing machine who’s also a medieval knight" go go go crazy games
      • 2013-02-01 03253, 2013

      • Freso
        reosarevok: Sounds like a point'n'click adventure! :D
      • 2013-02-01 03203, 2013

      • reosarevok
        It looks like a diablo-ish arpg
      • 2013-02-01 03210, 2013

      • reosarevok
        But, you know, with dishwashers
      • 2013-02-01 03221, 2013

      • Freso
        Aw.
      • 2013-02-01 03232, 2013

      • jesus2099
        thomasvs: include the catalogue number and/or barcode at the end of your folder name, for instance
      • 2013-02-01 03209, 2013

      • Freso
        There can be multiple cat. no.'s and both cat. no. and barcode can be the same between releases.
      • 2013-02-01 03228, 2013

      • reosarevok
        hey, now he quit *after* you replied! :p
      • 2013-02-01 03237, 2013

      • reosarevok
        (technically at least :p)
      • 2013-02-01 03246, 2013

      • Freso
        :p
      • 2013-02-01 03202, 2013

      • jesus2099 joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03208, 2013

      • jesus2099
        Freso: I use foobar for my (temp.) reips, it concatenate all catnos, and they are different for different releases, hopefully :)
      • 2013-02-01 03239, 2013

      • jesus2099
        hey Freso maybe you might know that : I’ve noticed I don’t receive emails any more when someone says somethingin a JIRA that I voted or commented in…
      • 2013-02-01 03255, 2013

      • jesus2099
        I have to vote+WATCH now, right ?
      • 2013-02-01 03209, 2013

      • reosarevok
        jesus2099: I think you always had to...
      • 2013-02-01 03212, 2013

      • jesus2099
        but do I have to also watch my own JIRA ?
      • 2013-02-01 03213, 2013

      • Freso
        jesus2099: Voting has never triggered sending e-mails.
      • 2013-02-01 03222, 2013

      • Freso
        jesus2099: Depends on your own settings, I think.
      • 2013-02-01 03239, 2013

      • Freso
        jesus2099: I just subscribe to -bugs, so I don't really watch my own ticket flow. :p
      • 2013-02-01 03245, 2013

      • Freso
        *watch just my own
      • 2013-02-01 03254, 2013

      • jesus2099
        where are the settings ?
      • 2013-02-01 03258, 2013

      • Freso shrugs
      • 2013-02-01 03203, 2013

      • jesus2099
      • 2013-02-01 03203, 2013

      • Freso
        Look around.
      • 2013-02-01 03215, 2013

      • jesus2099
        I know I know but the settings of JIRA are so few…
      • 2013-02-01 03227, 2013

      • jesus2099
        As I thought there is near nothing in there
      • 2013-02-01 03249, 2013

      • jesus2099
        The only setting is « Email me when I make changes » but this is not what I’m talking abouts
      • 2013-02-01 03231, 2013

      • jesus2099
        Freso: how do you watch your own for instacne ?
      • 2013-02-01 03244, 2013

      • jesus2099
        you mean you have to click WATCH each time afterxards you create your ticket ?
      • 2013-02-01 03201, 2013

      • nikki
        you should get emails for things you reported
      • 2013-02-01 03207, 2013

      • jesus2099
        ah,; great
      • 2013-02-01 03216, 2013

      • jesus2099
        :)
      • 2013-02-01 03217, 2013

      • jesus2099
        ouf
      • 2013-02-01 03234, 2013

      • nikki
        there doesn't seem to be a way to add voters to the list of people who are sent emails, it's just the reporter, the assignee and all watchers
      • 2013-02-01 03201, 2013

      • jesus2099
        ok nikki, I just needed to know how it worked, thanks for this :)
      • 2013-02-01 03217, 2013

      • jesus2099
        btw the WATCH button on own ticket shouldn’t be there, then
      • 2013-02-01 03231, 2013

      • jesus2099
        just like the VOTE button is disabled
      • 2013-02-01 03202, 2013

      • jesus2099
        Voting: You cannot vote or change your vote on resolved issues. BUT Watching: You are not watching this issue. Watch it to be notified of changes
      • 2013-02-01 03209, 2013

      • derr84 joined the channel
      • 2013-02-01 03224, 2013

      • nikki
        that's different. the configuration stuff is configurable, so it's possible to have emails sent to watchers which aren't sent to the reporter (why? who knows)
      • 2013-02-01 03208, 2013

      • jesus2099
        so the WATCH button and explanation on own tickets’s sidebar is not consistent with our configuration, it’s LYING. :)
      • 2013-02-01 03210, 2013

      • nikki
        but since we have reporter and watchers for all notifications, you *can* if you want, but you don't need to
      • 2013-02-01 03245, 2013

      • jesus2099
        it says « [I] won’t be notified » ☜ LIE LIE LIE
      • 2013-02-01 03252, 2013

      • Freso
        jesus2099 | Freso: how do you watch your own for instacne ?
      • 2013-02-01 03259, 2013

      • nikki
        it's entirely possible it's been altered in a newer version of jira. it's not like we're using a recent version :P
      • 2013-02-01 03205, 2013

      • Freso
        I follow yjr musicbrainz-bugs mailing list.
      • 2013-02-01 03207, 2013

      • Freso
        *the
      • 2013-02-01 03238, 2013

      • jesus2099
        another mailing list again ? /(°o° )/
      • 2013-02-01 03246, 2013

      • Freso
        It's an old mailing list.
      • 2013-02-01 03257, 2013

      • Freso
        (As can be seen by it being -bugs and not, say, -tickets.)
      • 2013-02-01 03217, 2013

      • Freso
        I wouldn't be surprised if there's an RSS feed as well.