#musicbrainz

/

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18207, 2018

      • maiz has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18230, 2018

      • maiz joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18233, 2018

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18257, 2018

      • maiz has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18223, 2018

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18239, 2018

      • xplt has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18202, 2018

      • Jinx has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18236, 2018

      • Jinx joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18214, 2018

      • balrog has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18232, 2018

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18251, 2018

      • sparklyballs has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18226, 2018

      • sparklyballs joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18204, 2018

      • dice joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18229, 2018

      • dice has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18249, 2018

      • balrog joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18202, 2018

      • Vonter joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18213, 2018

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18232, 2018

      • Zastai joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18221, 2018

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18236, 2018

      • Jybz joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18217, 2018

      • rgggn joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18254, 2018

      • rgggn has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18234, 2018

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18235, 2018

      • Zastai has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18257, 2018

      • simukis joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18255, 2018

      • timbl joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18201, 2018

      • timbl has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18252, 2018

      • maiz joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18227, 2018

      • outsidecontext joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18237, 2018

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18253, 2018

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18205, 2018

      • xplt joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18233, 2018

      • outsidecontext_ joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18221, 2018

      • outsidecontext has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18223, 2018

      • outsidecontext_ is now known as outsidecontext
      • 2018-07-01 18235, 2018

      • Vonter has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18258, 2018

      • outsidecontext has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18240, 2018

      • rsh7 joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18250, 2018

      • noobie
        good morning :) I have a digital release which includes a video (mp4), does the guideline say anything about this? Should this be included somehow?
      • 2018-07-01 18204, 2018

      • reosarevok
        noobie: I'd add it at the end of it and mark it as video
      • 2018-07-01 18234, 2018

      • reosarevok
        You need to add it normally, then go to the recording and edit it to set it as video :)
      • 2018-07-01 18254, 2018

      • noobie
        cool, thanks :)
      • 2018-07-01 18211, 2018

      • noobie
        one last question: should I include the (Official Video) in the title?
      • 2018-07-01 18225, 2018

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18227, 2018

      • reosarevok
        I wouldn't
      • 2018-07-01 18221, 2018

      • noobie
        thanks. Now the master question: should an remixed album (every track a remix of the original album) go to the same release group ? :D
      • 2018-07-01 18230, 2018

      • noobie
        s/an/a
      • 2018-07-01 18256, 2018

      • SothoTalKer
        yes
      • 2018-07-01 18241, 2018

      • noobie
        Thanks, the tracklist has (remix) in the title name for each track, feels clunky to keep this because the album subtitle is ":The Remixes" already, should I ommit them?
      • 2018-07-01 18204, 2018

      • SothoTalKer
        no
      • 2018-07-01 18203, 2018

      • noobie
        cool, thanks :)
      • 2018-07-01 18234, 2018

      • SothoTalKer
        :-)
      • 2018-07-01 18247, 2018

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18233, 2018

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18217, 2018

      • reosarevok
        Wait. Should it, SothoTalKer?
      • 2018-07-01 18225, 2018

      • reosarevok
        IMO it should not...
      • 2018-07-01 18251, 2018

      • reosarevok
        Oh :D
      • 2018-07-01 18251, 2018

      • SothoTalKer
        why not?
      • 2018-07-01 18253, 2018

      • reosarevok
      • 2018-07-01 18204, 2018

      • reosarevok
        Well, because if I have a remix album, I don't have the album
      • 2018-07-01 18210, 2018

      • reosarevok
        I have something else
      • 2018-07-01 18236, 2018

      • reosarevok
        RGs are supposed to be mostly equivalent, and a remix album to me does not feel equivalent at all
      • 2018-07-01 18246, 2018

      • reosarevok
        Seems both options are "correct", anyway
      • 2018-07-01 18254, 2018

      • reosarevok
        Or rather, we don't have a correct one :D
      • 2018-07-01 18208, 2018

      • SothoTalKer
        you should open up a discussion in the forums :)
      • 2018-07-01 18225, 2018

      • SothoTalKer
        the style guide is not clear, but it would be nice, if it was :-p
      • 2018-07-01 18234, 2018

      • noobie
        According to reosarevok 's link there has been more than one discussion about this :D
      • 2018-07-01 18247, 2018

      • reosarevok
        Yeah, it's just people don't agree :p
      • 2018-07-01 18228, 2018

      • reosarevok
        IMO it's obviously different RGs for albums, but trickier for singles
      • 2018-07-01 18240, 2018

      • SothoTalKer
        well, for me it does not really matter. you can make it a separate RG, if you wish :p
      • 2018-07-01 18255, 2018

      • noobie
        reosarevok: : well, you are auto editor, right, feel like fixing it ? :P ;)
      • 2018-07-01 18204, 2018

      • reosarevok
        haha
      • 2018-07-01 18208, 2018

      • reosarevok
        Happy to, if you give me a link
      • 2018-07-01 18221, 2018

      • reosarevok
        (although "fixing" is just "making it follow my liking", here :p )
      • 2018-07-01 18233, 2018

      • noobie
      • 2018-07-01 18254, 2018

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18247, 2018

      • reosarevok
      • 2018-07-01 18232, 2018

      • noobie
        thanks (also for adding the RS) :)
      • 2018-07-01 18208, 2018

      • noobie
        Alright, now the instrumental version, is there a secondary type for that (obviously there's none called "instrumental") ?
      • 2018-07-01 18211, 2018

      • reosarevok
        Nope, not currently at least
      • 2018-07-01 18229, 2018

      • Wizzup has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18244, 2018

      • Wizzup joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18248, 2018

      • Vonter joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18225, 2018

      • Freso
        noobie: You can add a tag, "instrumental", to the release group (and/or release and/or individual recordings), but no proper type as of now.
      • 2018-07-01 18241, 2018

      • noobie
        Since the release has an ": The Instrumentals" subtitle and each recording "(instrumental)" in the title I'll take the lazy approach and leave it as is :)
      • 2018-07-01 18206, 2018

      • light2yellow joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18237, 2018

      • maiz has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18227, 2018

      • timbl joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18205, 2018

      • Vonter has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18246, 2018

      • maiz joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18246, 2018

      • light2yellow has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18238, 2018

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18252, 2018

      • maiz has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18247, 2018

      • timbl has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18246, 2018

      • timbl joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18209, 2018

      • Toast joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18201, 2018

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18203, 2018

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18227, 2018

      • albertus1 joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18225, 2018

      • CatCat joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18244, 2018

      • CatCat has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18244, 2018

      • CatCat joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18243, 2018

      • Jybz has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18243, 2018

      • Jybz joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18243, 2018

      • albertus1 has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18201, 2018

      • Jybz has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18202, 2018

      • Jybz joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18231, 2018

      • Toast has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18237, 2018

      • simukis has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18222, 2018

      • rsh7 has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18231, 2018

      • xplt has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18210, 2018

      • balrog has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18211, 2018

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18225, 2018

      • Priapus_ has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18210, 2018

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18240, 2018

      • jwf
        Hmmm.
      • 2018-07-01 18252, 2018

      • jwf
        When does it make sense to add another medium to an existing release versus adding another release?
      • 2018-07-01 18222, 2018

      • jwf
        I've never understood the difference, since it seems widely established that different mediums (digital, CD, vinyl, etc.) are added as new releases
      • 2018-07-01 18230, 2018

      • jwf
        But I wonder what the purpose of adding a new medium is…?
      • 2018-07-01 18211, 2018

      • Gazooo has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18250, 2018

      • Gazooo joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18201, 2018

      • CatCat has quit
      • 2018-07-01 18203, 2018

      • BabyJesus666 joined the channel
      • 2018-07-01 18206, 2018

      • jwf
        Never mind… I read the docs. https://beta.musicbrainz.org/doc/Medium :P
      • 2018-07-01 18208, 2018

      • jwf
        As I understand it, mediums would be for when you have multiple pieces of a single release, like two discs for a double album
      • 2018-07-01 18211, 2018

      • jwf
        Makes so much sense now
      • 2018-07-01 18225, 2018

      • jwf
        Didn't know it also applied for digital releases. I'll probably go back and make some edits now…