Hey, question about linking recordings and works. Is there a standard when a recording is part of larger work. For example, should one just link movement 2 of a symphony to that movement, or should one also link it to the symphony as a partial recording? Both ways seem reasonable, but the former seems more DRY.
2019-04-01 09137, 2019
toddobryan
Also, what do you do if there is no smaller work? For example, all 1509 tracks in the audiobook of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix are linked as partial works of the novel. There are no partial works (chapters or whatever), so I guess this is the best one can do.
2019-04-01 09152, 2019
AfroThundr|main joined the channel
2019-04-01 09142, 2019
CallerNo6
toddobryan, correct, linking to the sub-work is preferred and DRY is preferred.
2019-04-01 09129, 2019
aliamo joined the channel
2019-04-01 09138, 2019
aliamo has quit
2019-04-01 09127, 2019
Nyanko-sensei joined the channel
2019-04-01 09148, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
2019-04-01 09154, 2019
CallerNo6
Of course, there are always exceptions. I trust the editors who worked on HP&tOotF who decided chapters wouldn't improve the data.
hi rid. for dev question, use #metabrainz . if you can stay in the channel long enough, somebody should be able to help eventually . (timezones, amirite?)
2019-04-01 09142, 2019
rid
CallerNo6: thanks, will do
2019-04-01 09149, 2019
CallerNo6
if you *can't* stick around to get an answer, check back at chatlogs.metabrainz.org or consider posting your question in the forums.
2019-04-01 09152, 2019
rid
are most of the active folks in a non US timezone?
MBS-10094: Barcode should be right justified on release group page
2019-04-01 09138, 2019
Lotheric is on fire
2019-04-01 09104, 2019
aliamo joined the channel
2019-04-01 09132, 2019
aliamo has quit
2019-04-01 09105, 2019
JoeLlama has quit
2019-04-01 09138, 2019
quasinahi joined the channel
2019-04-01 09157, 2019
quasinahi has quit
2019-04-01 09139, 2019
aliamo joined the channel
2019-04-01 09158, 2019
aliamo has quit
2019-04-01 09141, 2019
aliamo joined the channel
2019-04-01 09157, 2019
aliamo has quit
2019-04-01 09132, 2019
aliamo joined the channel
2019-04-01 09150, 2019
aliamo has quit
2019-04-01 09107, 2019
gnu_andrew has quit
2019-04-01 09103, 2019
aliamo joined the channel
2019-04-01 09118, 2019
gnu_andrew joined the channel
2019-04-01 09118, 2019
gnu_andrew has quit
2019-04-01 09118, 2019
gnu_andrew joined the channel
2019-04-01 09145, 2019
aliamo has quit
2019-04-01 09149, 2019
bemeurer_ joined the channel
2019-04-01 09115, 2019
bemeurer has quit
2019-04-01 09101, 2019
bemeurer_ has quit
2019-04-01 09112, 2019
bemeurer_ joined the channel
2019-04-01 09106, 2019
Sigyn has left the channel
2019-04-01 09111, 2019
aliamo joined the channel
2019-04-01 09144, 2019
aliamo has quit
2019-04-01 09154, 2019
AfroThundr|main has quit
2019-04-01 09144, 2019
HorusHorrendus joined the channel
2019-04-01 09152, 2019
CatQuest
[02:37] <toddobryan> Hey, question about linking recordings and works. Is there a standard when a recording is part of larger work. For example, should one just link movement 2 of a symphony to that movement, or should one also link it to the symphony as a partial recording? Both ways seem reasonable, but the former seems more DRY.
2019-04-01 09152, 2019
CatQuest
eh..
2019-04-01 09152, 2019
CatQuest
fry?
2019-04-01 09157, 2019
CatQuest
dry?
2019-04-01 09123, 2019
CatQuest
anyway link the movement to the recording of the movement
2019-04-01 09148, 2019
CatQuest
partial of the whole symphony is only for when it isn't known which movement it is
2019-04-01 09103, 2019
CatQuest
CallerNo6: wth is "DRY" ???
2019-04-01 09134, 2019
CatQuest
i thoght first "the right methord" de righ.. but that's all wrong
