Nothing wrong with Canada. Quebec on the other hand...
2019-08-01 21347, 2019
Jinx joined the channel
2019-08-01 21351, 2019
lovesegfault joined the channel
2019-08-01 21347, 2019
hatesec joined the channel
2019-08-01 21332, 2019
d4rkie joined the channel
2019-08-01 21302, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
2019-08-01 21328, 2019
Wizzup joined the channel
2019-08-01 21331, 2019
Wizzup has quit
2019-08-01 21341, 2019
Wizzup joined the channel
2019-08-01 21315, 2019
d4rkie has quit
2019-08-01 21354, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
2019-08-01 21332, 2019
lovesegfault has quit
2019-08-01 21349, 2019
nav2002_ joined the channel
2019-08-01 21335, 2019
lovesegfault joined the channel
2019-08-01 21346, 2019
albertus11 joined the channel
2019-08-01 21316, 2019
albertus1 has quit
2019-08-01 21320, 2019
AJ_Z0 has quit
2019-08-01 21306, 2019
AJ_Z0 joined the channel
2019-08-01 21307, 2019
AJ_Z0 has quit
2019-08-01 21307, 2019
AJ_Z0 joined the channel
2019-08-01 21309, 2019
nav2002_ has quit
2019-08-01 21318, 2019
JoeLlama joined the channel
2019-08-01 21309, 2019
Vacuity_ joined the channel
2019-08-01 21335, 2019
Vacuity has quit
2019-08-01 21338, 2019
d3daim has quit
2019-08-01 21327, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
2019-08-01 21303, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
2019-08-01 21355, 2019
lovesegfault has quit
2019-08-01 21320, 2019
JoeLlama has quit
2019-08-01 21352, 2019
leeijaw has quit
2019-08-01 21333, 2019
lidel` joined the channel
2019-08-01 21331, 2019
lidel has quit
2019-08-01 21333, 2019
lidel` is now known as lidel
2019-08-01 21339, 2019
leeijaw joined the channel
2019-08-01 21320, 2019
hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
2019-08-01 21301, 2019
trae32566[w] has quit
2019-08-01 21340, 2019
trae32566[w] joined the channel
2019-08-01 21350, 2019
d3daim joined the channel
2019-08-01 21302, 2019
JoeLlama joined the channel
2019-08-01 21324, 2019
leeijaw has quit
2019-08-01 21304, 2019
leeijaw joined the channel
2019-08-01 21313, 2019
albertus11 has quit
2019-08-01 21324, 2019
JoeLlama has quit
2019-08-01 21355, 2019
elomatreb[m]
Do we have an established standard about how to deal with artist credits of the form "<PersonA> of <unrelated group PersonA is a member of>"?
2019-08-01 21339, 2019
elomatreb[m]
Putting the group into the artist credit feels weird because they didn't actually contribute anything, but putting it into the join phrase also doesn't feel right.
om what *is* this "it fels wrong to put $thing in the joinphrase" attitude thats going wrong?
2019-08-01 21341, 2019
CatQuest
er going on
2019-08-01 21313, 2019
elomatreb[m]
CatQuest: It feels like a hack, because it's clearly not a "join" phrase
2019-08-01 21332, 2019
elomatreb[m]
I take it you're saying I should put it into the join phrase?
2019-08-01 21347, 2019
CatQuest
nah I'mwell I've done both myself so I really don't have an opinion. probably the *correct* is to pu it in the "join" phrase
2019-08-01 21305, 2019
CatQuest
it's worth noteing that we added the ability to have a trailing "join" phrase exactly *so* various things like & friends and other "not artists" parts of artist credits could be added proerøy
2019-08-01 21313, 2019
CatQuest
erh properly*
2019-08-01 21336, 2019
elomatreb[m]
I just remembered this edit (https://musicbrainz.org/edit/60004173) we both entered the same release and I put the credit on track 21 into the artist credit (not the join phrase though), but you're properly crediting the group
2019-08-01 21325, 2019
CatQuest
yea i probably shouldn't have done that (can't open the linklink because it's blanked by () :D )
I remember that, I had that in the "to make" (in an open tab) for too long after. that's why I made a dupe :D
2019-08-01 21348, 2019
CatQuest
are you merging them? probably merge into yours
2019-08-01 21335, 2019
CatQuest
wait are you the user "#"
2019-08-01 21341, 2019
CatQuest
no you have the same name
2019-08-01 21342, 2019
elomatreb[m]
They already are merged :)
2019-08-01 21347, 2019
CatQuest
yeps oops
2019-08-01 21329, 2019
elomatreb[m]
But yeah that open edit on the release is another thing I'm not too sure about
2019-08-01 21356, 2019
CatQuest
i'm voting no actualy. i want more reason than "don't do this" by an user called "#" :P
2019-08-01 21303, 2019
elomatreb[m]
I recall having a conversation about these compilation "label artists" before, but if we're going to have them it should probably at least be consistent
2019-08-01 21306, 2019
CatQuest
it shoudl be a consensus at the very least
2019-08-01 21345, 2019
CatQuest
I think it should be according if the "compilation lable artist" sees themselves as a "compilation artist group thing" or not
2019-08-01 21351, 2019
CatQuest
chiptunes = win certanly do
2019-08-01 21301, 2019
CatQuest
(also, hype! only 2 days and new release!)
2019-08-01 21325, 2019
CatQuest
elomatreb[m]: you can comment your "I recall having a conversation about.." on the edit yourself actually.
2019-08-01 21356, 2019
elomatreb[m]
I'm currently looking up the edits where I talked about it
2019-08-01 21318, 2019
CatQuest
👍
2019-08-01 21356, 2019
CatQuest
I'm going to go eat breakfast and put a dough of bread ecasue it is lammas and breadmass \o/ 🍞
Like, do you mean generic chiptunes compilations, or ones put out by Chiptunes = WIN, or something else?
2019-08-01 21325, 2019
CatQuest
it's fine if we decide this but I thikn we should come to an agreement first :)
2019-08-01 21349, 2019
antlarr
I guess I'm late for the conversation, but I don't think "Jon Greco of Weird at Last" is crediting two artists, but only one (named "Jon Greco of Weird at Last")
2019-08-01 21344, 2019
antlarr
IMO, "of Weird at Last" is being used as a kind of disambiguation text in the eyes of whoever wrote that
2019-08-01 21304, 2019
antlarr
elomatreb[m]: ^
2019-08-01 21335, 2019
elomatreb[m]
Yeah, or maybe a promotional thing (i.e. to say this isn't just Some Rando)
2019-08-01 21319, 2019
antlarr
right
2019-08-01 21357, 2019
elomatreb[m]
This was the track/recording that prompted me to ask initially, fwiw: https://musicbrainz.org/recording/25af875d-c66c-4… - I added the group as a join phrase, especially since it applies to both of the credited artists
2019-08-01 21306, 2019
nav2002____ joined the channel
2019-08-01 21307, 2019
finalsummer
CatQuest: there's thousands of bandcamp releases using the label name instead of various artists.
2019-08-01 21338, 2019
finalsummer
this one has some individual recordings credited to it
2019-08-01 21301, 2019
Gazooo has quit
2019-08-01 21339, 2019
antlarr
the official homepage of an artist is already gone but it's still in the web archive. Is it ok if I add the link to the web archive and set it to "official homepage" ?
finalsummer, CatQuest: they call themselves a "dynamic international chiptune collective". Whether that's an artist or just a label is a good question, but
