#musicbrainz

I am still having the same issues I told you about

reosarevok: Thanks for the feedback!

jwf: made some extra fixes. Thanks for adding obscure classical music, love getting new composers in! :)

🤔 so it's obscure new classical composers that's reo's fetish now 🤔

hmmm.. 🤔

CatQuest: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1cWXamGZmM

albums on C64 cartridges, shjould be right up your alley

:)

reosarevok: Thanks again. I made some new edits this morning. I guess I am not clear on what constitutes a work as a song-cycle though.

Oh, and I also added an event related to this work but I've never added an event before. A peer review on this would be nice too: https://beta.musicbrainz.org/event/288d6eae-a5d...

jwf: well, it usually consists of songs :p

The event looks fine. On the setlist, this is how I've often done it: https://beta.musicbrainz.org/event/43bf76c4-10e...

I had assumed the different movements as part of a single composition met that requirement?

(composer for each track as an artist line, then the work, both linked with MBIDs)

How are those songs? Where's the singing? :)

For events, I usually link only the main work, not each movement (assuming it was played in ful)

*full

Although neither way is wrong, we don't have specific setlist guidelines :)

Oh, I see. Looking back on the style docs, I see the example mentioned in the first bullet: https://beta.musicbrainz.org/doc/Style/Work

Yeah. A song cycle is a very specific thing

Classical pieces aren't usually called "songs", unless they specifically involve a vocalist (and even then, many are something else)

TIL!

And thanks for the event example, that is super helpful

Maybe a future GSoC project could be for easier tagging of artists/recordings/works in the Events UI/UX :)

reosarevok: Something that struck me while working on this, curious what you (and others) think: https://community.metabrainz.org/t/who-deserves...

Hello! Could anyone with experience in adding DJ mixes look at my contribution? I created added a Series, added the Relationship for the label, and then added the podcasts as release groups along with the Relationship to the Series. I just want to make sure I got it right before I move to the next mix series. The series in question: https://musicbr

Lotheric: no

mastering seems credited per track on this, should I add the 2 mastering engineers and credit them for the album ?

dascyan: If you don't get an answer here, you can also ask for peer review on the community forums: https://community.metabrainz.org/c/musicbrainz/...

jwf: Thank you, I will try that as well

dascyan: You can drop a link here too when you post :)

There it is https://community.metabrainz.org/t/did-i-enter-...

dascyan: I'd actually make a nother series for the "new Eara" podcast, but other thna that it starts well i think?

"New Era"*

the podcast (ie title and tracknumber and such) should probably be a release though? one track each is fine.. I think? I'm not super-knowledgable about podcasts :(

CatQuest: I have already created a new series for that. the voting is open to remove that one track that I wrongly put into the first series

right now the episodes are release groups. do you mean that they should be releases instead?

"episodes" in the broadest sense. it is not a podcast in the sense of a moderated radio show but just a continuous mix of tracks

yea

you're pretty new to mb right?

ok so: release groups are only containers for releases

the series can easily be for release groups, that's fine

but release-groups should *contain* releases

I see. as discogs does it

hmm CallerNo6 knows a little about podcasts I think. he listens to some atleast

so the next step would be to add a release to each of the release groups. and in the future just add a release

well yes. actully if yo uad a release the release group is(can be) added automatically too. if the release gorup isn't linked in the release page a new one is created whne adding a release :)

whne it coems to the series. it cna only link either release groups or releases. not a mix of both, sadly

that's fine anyway. so just go a head and continue ot link release groups (all releases have a release group)

I will try that. Thank you!

hey no prob :D

dascyan: left a note on one of your edits

alsoi appoved that moving to aonther series of that one

also also, sorry for typoes everywhere. can i blame that it's late here? :D long day :D

also !

you're only 3 days old!

🎉 Welcome to MusicBrainz! 🎊

thanks :D