#musicbrainz

/

      • xplt has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26047, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26003, 2019

      • duh is now known as legoktm
      • 2019-09-17 26054, 2019

      • warmsweater joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26059, 2019

      • Jinx joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26023, 2019

      • Nyanko-sensei joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26052, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26020, 2019

      • Nyanko-sensei has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26054, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26046, 2019

      • darvon has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26001, 2019

      • darvon joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26055, 2019

      • anomie[m] has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26058, 2019

      • sfunk1x[m] has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26002, 2019

      • heyarne[m] has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26007, 2019

      • anolir has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26009, 2019

      • KodiakIT[m] has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26014, 2019

      • elomatreb[m] has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26015, 2019

      • reg[m] has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26039, 2019

      • anolir joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26022, 2019

      • chaban has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26031, 2019

      • chaban joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26016, 2019

      • Vacuity joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26014, 2019

      • Vacuity_ has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26005, 2019

      • elomatreb[m] joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26005, 2019

      • heyarne[m] joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26005, 2019

      • reg[m] joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26005, 2019

      • KodiakIT[m] joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26005, 2019

      • sfunk1x[m] joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26005, 2019

      • anomie[m] joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26038, 2019

      • Jybz joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26052, 2019

      • crism joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26014, 2019

      • crism
        Folk songs are so damned messy… I’m on the verge of going down a rathole at https://beta.musicbrainz.org/work/d87c25f9-4a9c-4…
      • 2019-09-17 26015, 2019

      • crism
        If you follow the link to the WP page on the Roud index and thence to № 216, you will find that the article is about folk legend A.B. Stormalong, not about a song at all. That article describes the *multiple* chanteys about Old Stormy, including (but not limited to) “General Taylor.”
      • 2019-09-17 26015, 2019

      • crism
        By contrast, the link to Mainly Norfolk *only* describes the “General Taylor” variant. I would propose that the recordings generally titled “General Taylor” are of one song, and other recordings about Stormy are *different* (though related) works.
      • 2019-09-17 26015, 2019

      • crism
        Any thoughts?
      • 2019-09-17 26057, 2019

      • davic has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26045, 2019

      • crism
        Lyrical samples: “Oh, General Taylor gained the day! Walk him along, John, carry him along.” vs. “Stormy’s gone, that good old man! Way, Stormalong John.” as just two of the (at least four) distinct variants.
      • 2019-09-17 26008, 2019

      • crism has left the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26052, 2019

      • rektide has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26036, 2019

      • Jybz has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26025, 2019

      • nav2002 joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26027, 2019

      • echarlie has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26055, 2019

      • outsidecontext_ joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26015, 2019

      • outsidecontext_ has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26039, 2019

      • nav2002 has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26041, 2019

      • chaban has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26028, 2019

      • legoktm has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26050, 2019

      • chaban joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26059, 2019

      • legoktm joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26027, 2019

      • echarlie joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26020, 2019

      • Nyanko-sensei joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26002, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26002, 2019

      • Gazooo has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26046, 2019

      • Gazooo joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26017, 2019

      • Nyanko-sensei has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26052, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26019, 2019

      • lidel` joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26050, 2019

      • lidel has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26052, 2019

      • lidel` is now known as lidel
      • 2019-09-17 26005, 2019

      • BCMM joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26027, 2019

      • Etua joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26000, 2019

      • warmsweater has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26052, 2019

      • warmsweater joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26029, 2019

      • warmswea1er joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26044, 2019

      • warmsweater has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26003, 2019

      • warmsweater joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26015, 2019

      • warmsweater has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26036, 2019

      • warmsweater joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26035, 2019

      • warmswea1er has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26019, 2019

      • warmswea1er joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26018, 2019

      • warmswea1er has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26034, 2019

      • warmswea1er joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26002, 2019

      • warmsweater has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26028, 2019

      • treeshateorcs has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26009, 2019

      • warmswea1er has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26002, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26007, 2019

      • warmsweater joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26054, 2019

      • tho joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26029, 2019

      • warmsweater has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26019, 2019

      • warmsweater joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26047, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26033, 2019

      • warmswea1er joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26020, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26021, 2019

      • warmswea1er has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26038, 2019

      • warmsweater has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26042, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26027, 2019

      • warmsweater joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26023, 2019

      • warmsweater has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26009, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26001, 2019

      • Lotheric has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26042, 2019

      • crism joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26051, 2019

      • crism has left the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26034, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26059, 2019

      • Lotheric joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26050, 2019

      • Jinx has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26048, 2019

      • Jinx joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26046, 2019

      • Etua has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26008, 2019

      • Etua joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26008, 2019

      • davic joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26017, 2019

      • Etua has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26000, 2019

      • blabber has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26012, 2019

      • blabber joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26039, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26045, 2019

      • Etua joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26037, 2019

      • Etua has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26039, 2019

      • Etua_ joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26051, 2019

      • Etua_ is now known as Etua
      • 2019-09-17 26016, 2019

      • xplt joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26028, 2019

      • Jybz joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26047, 2019

      • xplt has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26012, 2019

      • trae32566[w] has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26028, 2019

      • trae32566[w] joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26022, 2019

      • tho is now known as treeshateorcs
      • 2019-09-17 26042, 2019

      • xplt joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26000, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26021, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26033, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26043, 2019

      • ZaphodBeeblebrox joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26043, 2019

      • ZaphodBeeblebrox has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26043, 2019

      • ZaphodBeeblebrox joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26025, 2019

      • CatQuest has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26001, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26052, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26034, 2019

      • fto_berlin joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26045, 2019

      • fto_berlin has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26001, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26008, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26038, 2019

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26000, 2019

      • Jybz has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26047, 2019

      • Etua has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26059, 2019

      • BCMM has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26028, 2019

      • rubdos has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26027, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26008, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2019-09-17 26022, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2019-09-17 26021, 2019

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel