So I'm trying to add a release from a Patreon post. Is "purchase for download" the correct relationship to use for a post that you need to be a patron to see?
2019-11-19 32302, 2019
dseomn
That seems like the closest of the existing relationships, but it's not quite accurate either. Maybe I should file a ticket for a "download with a paid subscription" relationship or something?
2019-11-19 32337, 2019
Joah joined the channel
2019-11-19 32306, 2019
mzfr joined the channel
2019-11-19 32316, 2019
mzfr_ joined the channel
2019-11-19 32333, 2019
mzfr has quit
2019-11-19 32334, 2019
mzfr_ is now known as mzfr
2019-11-19 32304, 2019
Vacuity joined the channel
2019-11-19 32313, 2019
Vacuity_ has quit
2019-11-19 32348, 2019
xplt has quit
2019-11-19 32343, 2019
regakakobigman has quit
2019-11-19 32336, 2019
JoeLlama joined the channel
2019-11-19 32346, 2019
Joah has quit
2019-11-19 32352, 2019
c1e0_ joined the channel
2019-11-19 32314, 2019
JoeLlama has quit
2019-11-19 32321, 2019
kepstin
hmm, and "crowdfunding page" isn't quite right either, that's for something like kickstarter where you have a fix-length funding drive for production/release
2019-11-19 32318, 2019
kepstin
purchase for download is probably the least bad of the options we have right now, but it does seem like we should have a better option
2019-11-19 32326, 2019
_c1e0 joined the channel
2019-11-19 32353, 2019
c1e0_ has quit
2019-11-19 32313, 2019
Lotheric_ joined the channel
2019-11-19 32302, 2019
Lotheric has quit
2019-11-19 32354, 2019
_c1e0 has quit
2019-11-19 32309, 2019
antlarr
Hi, in 1987 there was a tv show hosted by "Miguel Ríos" (a famous singer in Spain) that had other artists as guests. Miguel Ríos recorded two albums with songs from the show and one of those two albums has "Miguel Ríos con La banda del año" (with the band of the year) as "album artist". That's the "band" of the show, and afaik, never played by itself nor recorded anything else. When creating the musicbrainz artist for the
I wouldn't call a show band an orchestra, unless it's actually orchestra-like
2019-11-19 32307, 2019
reosarevok
(many shows have bands which are more like a jazz band of sorts, I think?)
2019-11-19 32324, 2019
reosarevok
I'm too young to have ever seen that program though, so not sure how this one is :D
2019-11-19 32302, 2019
Gazooo has quit
2019-11-19 32350, 2019
Gazooo joined the channel
2019-11-19 32304, 2019
CatQuest
dseomn: Maybe I should file a ticket for a "download with a paid subscription" relationship or something?
2019-11-19 32304, 2019
CatQuest
👍 from me, that sounds like a great idea
2019-11-19 32306, 2019
CatQuest
antlarr: if this was a singular one of type thing I'd use artist credits on Miguel Ríos and then relationsip the memebers to the release/recordings
2019-11-19 32306, 2019
CatQuest
but that's me
2019-11-19 32347, 2019
CatQuest
i guess it's fine if it's added as a "Miguel Ríos's band" and linked with him in an artist credit as "and band"
2019-11-19 32327, 2019
antlarr
reosarevok: it's definitely not an orchestra, and I don't think it's Miguel Rios's but more like RTVE's band
2019-11-19 32313, 2019
antlarr
CatQuest: There's also one track in that album that is credited to "Las chicas del año" which seems to refer to the chorus from the same band, so in that case I credited it like this: https://musicbrainz.org/recording/6de844a2-2cde-4…
2019-11-19 32334, 2019
antlarr
(I checked that Miguel Rios doesn't sing in that track)
2019-11-19 32331, 2019
antlarr
So I used "La banda del año" but credited as "Las chicas del año", which I think is exactly what's happening there
I wonder if it would make more sense to unify the subscription and download relationships into a single one each, with paid/subscription/free/etc as attributes
2019-11-19 32335, 2019
colbydray joined the channel
2019-11-19 32351, 2019
colbydray has quit
2019-11-19 32317, 2019
_c1e0 joined the channel
2019-11-19 32300, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
2019-11-19 32300, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
2019-11-19 32307, 2019
D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
2019-11-19 32353, 2019
CatQuest
antlarr: jup, that looks great and probably how i'd do it :D
2019-11-19 32307, 2019
antlarr
CatQuest: cool :)
2019-11-19 32348, 2019
CatQuest
not that I'm the be-all and end-all of ways of doing things ^__^
2019-11-19 32323, 2019
regakakobigman joined the channel
2019-11-19 32326, 2019
Etua joined the channel
2019-11-19 32340, 2019
Joah joined the channel
2019-11-19 32327, 2019
xplt joined the channel
2019-11-19 32359, 2019
Joah has quit
2019-11-19 32353, 2019
antlarr
I have a recording and its related work, and then I have another recording which is an acoustic version of the first one. Should I relate it to the same work? or should I create a new work?
2019-11-19 32328, 2019
antlarr
(both recordings and work by the same artist)
2019-11-19 32336, 2019
antlarr
I think apart from "cover", "live", "instrumental" ... there should be an "acoustic" attribute
