#musicbrainz

/

      • supersandro2000 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30511, 2020

      • supersandro2000 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30513, 2020

      • cheezmo2 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30526, 2020

      • d4rkie has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30545, 2020

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30536, 2020

      • lorenzuru50 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30532, 2020

      • cheezmo2 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30548, 2020

      • cheezmo2 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30500, 2020

      • cheezmo2 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30558, 2020

      • cheezmo2 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30546, 2020

      • Glassjoe joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30533, 2020

      • livingsilver94 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30510, 2020

      • livingsilver94 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30518, 2020

      • calcmandan has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30530, 2020

      • calcmandan joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30521, 2020

      • calcmandan has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30543, 2020

      • calcmandan joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30556, 2020

      • iliekcomputers joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30500, 2020

      • cheezmo2 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30518, 2020

      • cheezmo2 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30525, 2020

      • Glassjoe has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30546, 2020

      • f1reflyylmao joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30513, 2020

      • f1refly has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30505, 2020

      • Vacuity_ joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30528, 2020

      • Vacuity has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30535, 2020

      • SothoTalKer has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30504, 2020

      • SothoTalKer joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30544, 2020

      • supersandro2000 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30503, 2020

      • supersandro2000 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30556, 2020

      • livingsilver94_ joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30504, 2020

      • livingsilver94 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30502, 2020

      • d4rkie joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30526, 2020

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30538, 2020

      • d4rkie has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30524, 2020

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30553, 2020

      • aereaux has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30501, 2020

      • Gazooo79494 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30545, 2020

      • Gazooo79494 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30508, 2020

      • cheezmo2_ joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30524, 2020

      • cheezmo2 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30514, 2020

      • darwin
      • 2020-10-31 30535, 2020

      • jesus2099 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30516, 2020

      • Case_Of has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30533, 2020

      • Case_Of joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30535, 2020

      • Case_Of has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30551, 2020

      • Case_Of joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30517, 2020

      • Case_Of has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30511, 2020

      • Glassjoe joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30502, 2020

      • Glassjoe has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30536, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        Hi! How to deal with an album of band that contains the same songs as a different album, but are new (and different) recordings of the same song? Its about https://musicbrainz.org/release/7749ac16-82a5-42d… . The band has released the album "Same, same ... but different" https://thecosmictripadvisors.bandcamp.com/album/… (of which I own the CD, so I would like
      • 2020-10-31 30542, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        to enter that release to MB)
      • 2020-10-31 30522, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        Would I just create a new release-group and add the songs again, with the same name? Should I somehow mark them as being different from the other release?
      • 2020-10-31 30519, 2020

      • reosarevok
        Hi Vacuity_ !
      • 2020-10-31 30530, 2020

      • reosarevok
        Yes, re-add, but do not reuse the recordings
      • 2020-10-31 30537, 2020

      • reosarevok
        And new release group
      • 2020-10-31 30513, 2020

      • reosarevok
        And ideally add works and link both performances of each song to the same work
      • 2020-10-31 30537, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        ah. "works". didn't know about that :)
      • 2020-10-31 30544, 2020

      • reosarevok
        I guess there's no info of when this version was recorded? :)
      • 2020-10-31 30557, 2020

      • reosarevok
        (if we had it we could indicate it too in the recording-work links)
      • 2020-10-31 30559, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        only when it was released
      • 2020-10-31 30506, 2020

      • reosarevok
        Yeah, then probs not :)
      • 2020-10-31 30512, 2020

      • reosarevok
        Still, the other things do apply
      • 2020-10-31 30508, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        ok, great. I'll try it when I come to it someday today. I also noticed the existing release group of "Wrong again, Albert" has no CD release yet. I own that CD too, so I'll add the CD release incl DiscId
      • 2020-10-31 30501, 2020

      • reosarevok
        Thanks! :)
      • 2020-10-31 30525, 2020

      • reosarevok
        If you get stuck with anything just ask here :)
      • 2020-10-31 30533, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        more questions :) The release name is "Same, same…but different" according to bandcamp (and as can be seen on the coverart). Q1) According to English styleguide, that should capitalized as "Same, Same...but Different", correct? Q2) What about the ... in the title. They use "…". Should I keep that or replace it with "..." ?
      • 2020-10-31 30534, 2020

      • reosarevok
        (since you said you've never used works before)
      • 2020-10-31 30554, 2020

      • reosarevok
        Hmm
      • 2020-10-31 30556, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        I added a few releases already, but never with existing recordings (or works)
      • 2020-10-31 30517, 2020

      • reosarevok
        Well the recordings should be different here so that should be like a usual new release in that sense :)
      • 2020-10-31 30531, 2020

      • reosarevok
        If they consistently use lowercase then I would too
      • 2020-10-31 30531, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        yes
      • 2020-10-31 30559, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        worse. the song titles are all uppercase. everything inclusing "Is" and "It"
      • 2020-10-31 30512, 2020

      • reosarevok
        That is probably not that intentional, I'd correct those :)
      • 2020-10-31 30524, 2020

      • reosarevok
        … is probably more correct than three dots anyway, so you might as well keep it
      • 2020-10-31 30556, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        ok. then I'll capizalize according to styleguide, discarding the idea of "artist intent", but keep the …
      • 2020-10-31 30545, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        (and I'll try to produce less typos than in the current conversation :) )
      • 2020-10-31 30526, 2020

      • Vacuity_
        reosarevok: thank you for helping out!
      • 2020-10-31 30527, 2020

      • calcmandan has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30505, 2020

      • calcmandan joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30530, 2020

      • livingsilver94_ has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30506, 2020

      • livingsilver94 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30516, 2020

      • aereaux joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30517, 2020

      • f1refly joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30533, 2020

      • f1reflyylmao has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30501, 2020

      • milkii
        so i'm trying to merge https://musicbrainz.org/release/456d72a1-6f4d-40f… to https://musicbrainz.org/release/c297a2c5-c85c-451… but while the cat is the same, the release dates and exact label details are different. sounds like a rerelease? what merge strategy would be best?
      • 2020-10-31 30549, 2020

      • KingJ joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30518, 2020

      • reosarevok
        milkii: none, if it's a rerelease
      • 2020-10-31 30540, 2020

      • reosarevok
        The releases should then be separate. But the release groups should be merged
      • 2020-10-31 30506, 2020

      • reosarevok
        And probably the recordings too
      • 2020-10-31 30548, 2020

      • reosarevok
        That said, the label should probably be the same, but if there's a 2005 re-release then they should still be separate releases
      • 2020-10-31 30515, 2020

      • reosarevok
        Disc 3 track 10 has a very different duration (over 1 minute) between the releases
      • 2020-10-31 30528, 2020

      • reosarevok
        Can you confirm your version is 2:30 rather than 3:30
      • 2020-10-31 30529, 2020

      • reosarevok
        ?
      • 2020-10-31 30511, 2020

      • SothoTalKer
        reosarevok: there was something not MB related i wanted to ask you
      • 2020-10-31 30537, 2020

      • reosarevok
        What is it?
      • 2020-10-31 30547, 2020

      • SothoTalKer
        reosarevok: you proposed the ELNET ID like 2 years ago on WD. Do you still have contact to the people or can reach them? I am interested in the format they use, but I could not find any info about it.
      • 2020-10-31 30507, 2020

      • SothoTalKer
        well well. :)
      • 2020-10-31 30559, 2020

      • CatQuest
        reosarevok & Lotheric: for me it's pink floyd https://listenbrainz.org/recommended/tracks/CatCa… :D
      • 2020-10-31 30527, 2020

      • CatQuest
        darwin: i tikn the recording sohudl be renamed witha a dot yea, but the individual records as on coverp robably
      • 2020-10-31 30500, 2020

      • CatQuest
        reosarevok: https://beta.musicbrainz.org/edit/74319055 :D *check* it out?
      • 2020-10-31 30515, 2020

      • chaban
        Decoda always looked pretty shady to me (i.e. it's one of many SEO sites by the same(?) folks). I could create a ticket for it.
      • 2020-10-31 30539, 2020

      • CatQuest
        seo?
      • 2020-10-31 30543, 2020

      • CatQuest
        but yea please do that
      • 2020-10-31 30543, 2020

      • livingsilver94_ joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30522, 2020

      • livingsilver94 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30516, 2020

      • jesus2100 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30502, 2020

      • jesus2099 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30502, 2020

      • jesus2100 is now known as jesus2099
      • 2020-10-31 30505, 2020

      • CatQuest
        Happy hallowe'en!
      • 2020-10-31 30507, 2020

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30522, 2020

      • d4rkie joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30505, 2020

      • livingsilver94_ has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30501, 2020

      • livingsilver94 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30540, 2020

      • hibiscuskazeneko joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30500, 2020

      • hibiscuskazeneko
      • 2020-10-31 30506, 2020

      • hibiscuskazeneko
        Every time I try, I get a 504
      • 2020-10-31 30515, 2020

      • hibiscuskazeneko
        (it's a bootleg and needs to be removed)
      • 2020-10-31 30503, 2020

      • evelyn
        why would a bootleg need to be removed?
      • 2020-10-31 30551, 2020

      • hibiscuskazeneko
        It's one of those fan-compiled torrent-type releases.
      • 2020-10-31 30501, 2020

      • evelyn
        eww, OK
      • 2020-10-31 30511, 2020

      • hibiscuskazeneko
        You're probably thinking of something like a concert bootleg. Those are a whole 'nother story.
      • 2020-10-31 30559, 2020

      • evelyn
        I can't actually open the URI either
      • 2020-10-31 30528, 2020

      • evelyn
        it just hangs, no 504
      • 2020-10-31 30521, 2020

      • Glassjoe joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30506, 2020

      • rdswift
        Same here.
      • 2020-10-31 30538, 2020

      • livingsilver94 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30547, 2020

      • Case_Of joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30506, 2020

      • livingsilver94 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30523, 2020

      • chaban
      • 2020-10-31 30559, 2020

      • sublim21 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30509, 2020

      • sublim22 joined the channel
      • 2020-10-31 30526, 2020

      • sublim20 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30558, 2020

      • sublim21 has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30538, 2020

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30549, 2020

      • d4rkie has quit
      • 2020-10-31 30538, 2020

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel