#musicbrainz

/

      • Erin
        Does anyone know, if spotify has a release on it, and every detail matches the other published one, is it generally the same thing, or is it distinct
      • 2021-02-28 05940, 2021

      • xplt has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05949, 2021

      • Erin
        and if it's distinct, how do we handle filling in things like the labels
      • 2021-02-28 05940, 2021

      • Rotab
        what's "the other published one"?
      • 2021-02-28 05914, 2021

      • Erin
        it also appears to be a digital release
      • 2021-02-28 05923, 2021

      • Erin
        but its the official, original one i htink
      • 2021-02-28 05938, 2021

      • Erin
        oh its itunes
      • 2021-02-28 05937, 2021

      • Rotab
        same release, yes
      • 2021-02-28 05942, 2021

      • Rotab
        if every detail matches
      • 2021-02-28 05914, 2021

      • Erin
        i did see a different barcode
      • 2021-02-28 05922, 2021

      • Erin
        but i am having trouble verifying it
      • 2021-02-28 05944, 2021

      • Erin
        anyway, this is what i was looking at https://musicbrainz.org/release-group/d30a6a9b-ba…
      • 2021-02-28 05931, 2021

      • Erin
        im fairly sure its the same songs in the same order at a minimum, though
      • 2021-02-28 05957, 2021

      • Erin
        it seems like it was built as two releases, but it's the same album twice, so i really dont know whats up
      • 2021-02-28 05910, 2021

      • Glassjoe joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05904, 2021

      • Lotheric
        4534530114167 Aniplex Inc. in Japan
      • 2021-02-28 05904, 2021

      • Lotheric
        & 886447381878 Aniplex Inc. elsewhere
      • 2021-02-28 05912, 2021

      • Lotheric
        according to spotify api
      • 2021-02-28 05910, 2021

      • Erin
        oh api
      • 2021-02-28 05913, 2021

      • Erin
        thats useful
      • 2021-02-28 05919, 2021

      • jesus2099 has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05938, 2021

      • Erin
        thanks
      • 2021-02-28 05938, 2021

      • iarp has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05929, 2021

      • Erin
        actually i wonder ... did the spotify api say anything about a label for it?
      • 2021-02-28 05935, 2021

      • Erin
        i know it's aniplex but im not sure what htat should be
      • 2021-02-28 05912, 2021

      • iarp joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05904, 2021

      • MajorLurker joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05953, 2021

      • MajorLurker has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05949, 2021

      • xplt joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05919, 2021

      • xplt has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05905, 2021

      • fading_epilogue joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05948, 2021

      • davic has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05920, 2021

      • Lo_Fidelity has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05937, 2021

      • Lo_Fidelity joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05907, 2021

      • adhawkins has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05911, 2021

      • adhawkins joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05925, 2021

      • Vacuity joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05909, 2021

      • sublim20 has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05945, 2021

      • Vacuity_ has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05935, 2021

      • Lo_Fidelity has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05955, 2021

      • Lo_Fidelity joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05926, 2021

      • toconnect2me joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05908, 2021

      • toconnect2me has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05929, 2021

      • toconnect2me joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05902, 2021

      • toconnect2me has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05947, 2021

      • Misty_Pond joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05918, 2021

      • Misty_Pond
        I'd like to add an entity for https://vgmdb.net/org/1677, but I'm not sure which category it goes under. Label?
      • 2021-02-28 05933, 2021

      • cheezmo2_ joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05902, 2021

      • cheezmo2 has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05915, 2021

      • darwin
        " Only became a company in 2010, released albums as a label prior to that. "
      • 2021-02-28 05919, 2021

      • darwin
        I am.. confused by that statement
      • 2021-02-28 05944, 2021

      • MajorLurker joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05958, 2021

      • MajorLurker has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05904, 2021

      • adhawkins has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05957, 2021

      • adhawkins joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05946, 2021

      • d4rkie has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05927, 2021

      • Nyanko-sensei joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05933, 2021

      • crism has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05932, 2021

      • crism joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05922, 2021

      • Etua joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05917, 2021

      • Etua has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05911, 2021

      • eFfeM joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05913, 2021

      • MajorLurker joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05923, 2021

      • MajorLurker has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05922, 2021

      • Misty_Pond has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05951, 2021

      • xplt joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05936, 2021

      • reosarevok
        darwin: imprint vs actual legal firm I guess?
      • 2021-02-28 05947, 2021

      • atj
      • 2021-02-28 05930, 2021

      • atj
        There's no need for a separate legal name artist here
      • 2021-02-28 05903, 2021

      • MajorLurker joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05928, 2021

      • MajorLurker has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05944, 2021

      • eFfeM has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05905, 2021

      • Lotheric
        atj, yup
      • 2021-02-28 05917, 2021

      • Lotheric
        imho, we should only reference the artists and his multiple aliases/projects and make the UI better instead of splitting different projects (to filter them)
      • 2021-02-28 05944, 2021

      • Lotheric
        but that's just me
      • 2021-02-28 05950, 2021

      • Lotheric
        not a guideline
      • 2021-02-28 05936, 2021

      • atj
        thanks Lotheric
      • 2021-02-28 05941, 2021

      • atj
        In the past I've created some legal name artists purely for credit purposes as that seemed most logical to me, but I didn't understand the style guidelines at that point.
      • 2021-02-28 05941, 2021

      • chaban
        David Nugent aka Mr Angles going at it again: https://musicbrainz.org/edit/77681937
      • 2021-02-28 05914, 2021

      • antlarr has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05916, 2021

      • antlarr joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05940, 2021

      • MajorLurker joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05902, 2021

      • atj
        If you wouldn't want your real info put online then don't put it online in multiple places!
      • 2021-02-28 05923, 2021

      • atj
      • 2021-02-28 05955, 2021

      • MajorLurker has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05906, 2021

      • atj
        Pezzner seems to be the primary artist name based on Discogs, so I was going to merge into that, thoughts?
      • 2021-02-28 05935, 2021

      • evelyn
        I am thinking these two labels, FMS https://musicbrainz.org/label/3c3bac8c-7bae-4e06-…, and Fenn Music Service GMBH should be merged: https://musicbrainz.org/label/3760cbdd-845f-400e-…
      • 2021-02-28 05905, 2021

      • evelyn
        the Fenn Music Service one is linked to https://www.discogs.com/label/40016, which is just FMS there
      • 2021-02-28 05934, 2021

      • evelyn
        on the CDs, basically FMS is in the logo, and Fenn Music Service GMBH is always printed below it
      • 2021-02-28 05940, 2021

      • evelyn
        and the LC code is linked to just FMS on that list of label codes on RYM..
      • 2021-02-28 05953, 2021

      • evelyn
        so essentially, I'm not sure if Fenn Music Service GMBH should be merged into FMS (it's a publisher/holding company but there don't seem to be any publisher relationships added as of yet), or the other way round.
      • 2021-02-28 05941, 2021

      • evelyn
        (although, to my mind, I would probably merge into FMS then set the label code there given the above, and then add Fenn Music Service GMBH as the parent company of the FMS label)
      • 2021-02-28 05910, 2021

      • atj
        The artwork seems to be FMS, so I'd go with that, but I'm often wrong.
      • 2021-02-28 05952, 2021

      • evelyn
        might just enter the merge and see if anyone votes it down (pretty doubtful it would get voted down, but still)
      • 2021-02-28 05927, 2021

      • chaban
        It seems Fenn Music Service GmbH has many subsidiaries or is it just the labels they've distributed? https://labelrecherche.gvl.de
      • 2021-02-28 05940, 2021

      • evelyn
        I honestly have no idea
      • 2021-02-28 05955, 2021

      • evelyn
        but that does suggest the label is FMS, and then the parent is Fenn Music Service GMBH.., although now I am worried some of those titles in the database are not to FMS at all but to one of the sibling labels of FMS.
      • 2021-02-28 05959, 2021

      • eFfeM joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05955, 2021

      • atj
      • 2021-02-28 05905, 2021

      • chaban
        It seems Fenn Music Service is generally a distributor while FMS is a record label: https://www.abendblatt.de/region/kreis-lauenburg/… https://www.waz.de/staedte/duisburg/fuer-sysiphus…
      • 2021-02-28 05910, 2021

      • chaban
        You can bypass the paywall with something like https://gitlab.com/magnolia1234/bypass-paywalls-f…
      • 2021-02-28 05923, 2021

      • CatQuest
        [14:14] <Lotheric> imho, we should only reference the artists and his multiple aliases/projects and make the UI better instead of splitting different projects (to filter them)
      • 2021-02-28 05923, 2021

      • CatQuest
        I agree totally though
      • 2021-02-28 05914, 2021

      • eFfeM has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05948, 2021

      • CatQuest
        hm re the angles thing, woudl it rally be that bad to merge tri angels int othe dude and thne rename it "tri angles" and have "david Nugent" as an legal name alias?
      • 2021-02-28 05908, 2021

      • CatQuest
        or whatever performance names the gy is using, merge thme all and have a legal name alias?
      • 2021-02-28 05909, 2021

      • CatQuest
        idk.
      • 2021-02-28 05945, 2021

      • chaban
        Merging wouldn't resolve this issue. It's the legal name they want to get rid off.
      • 2021-02-28 05954, 2021

      • evelyn
        hmm,... OK so Fenn Music Service GMBH is already with the relationship 'distributor', so what I will do is just set the existing releases to use FMS (if it's the case) and then add a distributor relationship for it
      • 2021-02-28 05957, 2021

      • evelyn
        and remove the LC code
      • 2021-02-28 05904, 2021

      • evelyn
        and attach that to FMS instead
      • 2021-02-28 05916, 2021

      • Lotheric
        CatQuest, I don't see the point of performance names when we have artist credits now
      • 2021-02-28 05942, 2021

      • adhi001 joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05950, 2021

      • rubdos_ joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05906, 2021

      • n86cc joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05950, 2021

      • n86cc has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05914, 2021

      • upperechelon has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05906, 2021

      • BCMM joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05952, 2021

      • upperechelon joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05930, 2021

      • adhi001 has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05954, 2021

      • rubdos_ is now known as rubdos
      • 2021-02-28 05909, 2021

      • MajorLurker joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05923, 2021

      • MajorLurker has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05916, 2021

      • BCMM has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05909, 2021

      • DarthKnight joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05935, 2021

      • xplt has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05923, 2021

      • simukis__ is now known as simukis_
      • 2021-02-28 05921, 2021

      • DarthKnight has quit
      • 2021-02-28 05927, 2021

      • Erin
        drama cds are the worst T.T
      • 2021-02-28 05904, 2021

      • Erin
        got 13 out of 17, but now im reduced to listening to the last 4 to try to identify the voice actors myself cause i cant find anything that says it T.T
      • 2021-02-28 05911, 2021

      • BCMM joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05910, 2021

      • Glycem has left the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05923, 2021

      • d4rkie joined the channel
      • 2021-02-28 05902, 2021

      • Nyanko-sensei has quit