don't know iuf this is the right place but i'd like to thank anyone who worked on improving the release submission process, i just found out recently that importing releases from bandcamp is smoother than ever
2021-04-22 11216, 2021
reosarevok
That'd mostly be whoever worked on the importer, but chances are they're also here :)
2021-04-22 11228, 2021
leonardo
well i hope my feeling of gratitude will reach everyone who pushed at least a single commit in the last six months on any musicbrainz-related project :D
2021-04-22 11216, 2021
Rotab
awww, 12 months ago here :(
2021-04-22 11220, 2021
leonardo
you're still in time to commit something now
2021-04-22 11241, 2021
Lotheric_ is now known as Lotheric
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
Glassjoe has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
RetroPunk has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
Lotheric has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
aidalgol has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
furq has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
strycore has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
pinoaffe has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
moufl has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
kloeri has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
lovesegfault has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
assink has quit
2021-04-22 11206, 2021
Jormangeud has quit
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
Glassjoe joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
RetroPunk joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
Lotheric joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
aidalgol joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
furq joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
strycore joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
lovesegfault joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
pinoaffe joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
kloeri joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
moufl joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
Jormangeud joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
assink joined the channel
2021-04-22 11234, 2021
Lotheric_ joined the channel
2021-04-22 11256, 2021
Lotheric has quit
2021-04-22 11220, 2021
Lotheric_ is now known as Lotheric
2021-04-22 11209, 2021
dinoex joined the channel
2021-04-22 11254, 2021
Lotheric_ joined the channel
2021-04-22 11241, 2021
Lotheric has quit
2021-04-22 11224, 2021
otisolsen70 joined the channel
2021-04-22 11208, 2021
otisolsen70_ has quit
2021-04-22 11224, 2021
otisolsen70 has quit
2021-04-22 11227, 2021
Guilhem_ joined the channel
2021-04-22 11212, 2021
yvanzo has quit
2021-04-22 11248, 2021
griff__ joined the channel
2021-04-22 11211, 2021
griff__ has quit
2021-04-22 11237, 2021
SirPHOENiX1 joined the channel
2021-04-22 11205, 2021
dryad joined the channel
2021-04-22 11252, 2021
Lotheric_ is now known as Lotheric
2021-04-22 11258, 2021
Guilhem_ has quit
2021-04-22 11223, 2021
yvanzo joined the channel
2021-04-22 11231, 2021
atsampson has quit
2021-04-22 11250, 2021
Guilhem_ joined the channel
2021-04-22 11246, 2021
reosarevok
We need to add tagging to genres
2021-04-22 11252, 2021
reosarevok
Just so CatQuest can go and add sillyname to a bunch
2021-04-22 11208, 2021
reosarevok rolls his eyes at sophisti-pop
2021-04-22 11216, 2021
averyfollett joined the channel
2021-04-22 11218, 2021
atsampson joined the channel
2021-04-22 11238, 2021
Lotheric
can we add genre tags to genre tags ?
2021-04-22 11253, 2021
Lotheric
that genre is of ther -core genre :)
2021-04-22 11257, 2021
Lotheric
haha
2021-04-22 11222, 2021
MusicbrainzB0T2 joined the channel
2021-04-22 11224, 2021
sublim21 joined the channel
2021-04-22 11247, 2021
tedster_ joined the channel
2021-04-22 11221, 2021
calcmandan_ joined the channel
2021-04-22 11237, 2021
QinYingxin joined the channel
2021-04-22 11243, 2021
trolley_ joined the channel
2021-04-22 11245, 2021
antlarr2 joined the channel
2021-04-22 11211, 2021
chrysn_ joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
antlarr has quit
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
sublim20 has quit
2021-04-22 11234, 2021
trolley has quit
2021-04-22 11234, 2021
chrysn has quit
2021-04-22 11234, 2021
calcmandan has quit
2021-04-22 11234, 2021
tedster has quit
2021-04-22 11234, 2021
hachiroku has quit
2021-04-22 11234, 2021
MusicbrainzB0T has quit
2021-04-22 11246, 2021
tedster_ is now known as tedster
2021-04-22 11207, 2021
AJ_Z0 has quit
2021-04-22 11241, 2021
AJ_Z0 joined the channel
2021-04-22 11249, 2021
Guilhem_ has quit
2021-04-22 11213, 2021
sublim21 has quit
2021-04-22 11251, 2021
Guilhem_ joined the channel
2021-04-22 11208, 2021
reosarevok has quit
2021-04-22 11220, 2021
alastairp has quit
2021-04-22 11241, 2021
chaban has quit
2021-04-22 11243, 2021
zas has quit
2021-04-22 11251, 2021
ruaok has quit
2021-04-22 11244, 2021
alastairp joined the channel
2021-04-22 11254, 2021
reosarevok joined the channel
2021-04-22 11259, 2021
chaban joined the channel
2021-04-22 11203, 2021
ruaok joined the channel
2021-04-22 11214, 2021
zas joined the channel
2021-04-22 11207, 2021
SirPHOENiX1 has quit
2021-04-22 11228, 2021
SirPHOENiX1 joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
Guilhem_ has quit
2021-04-22 11253, 2021
danoply has quit
2021-04-22 11222, 2021
danoply joined the channel
2021-04-22 11255, 2021
MRiddickW joined the channel
2021-04-22 11233, 2021
MRiddickW has quit
2021-04-22 11248, 2021
MRiddickW joined the channel
2021-04-22 11217, 2021
evelyn
Could somebody help me understand: which is better, track-level arrangement relationships or recording-level arrangement relationships?
Subsequently, the recording by Pentangle was added to use this work
2021-04-22 11235, 2021
evelyn
However, the Pentangle recording was much earlier, in 1974 not 1978.
2021-04-22 11246, 2021
evelyn
So, there was another work added, just Jack Orion (the original traditional song), which I added as a work relationship ie. Fairport's version based on the traditional song
2021-04-22 11205, 2021
evelyn
this song is itself based on an older, text-only ballad which I also set the relationship to.
2021-04-22 11259, 2021
evelyn
So, I'm wondering if we should just remove the Fairport version's arrangement-level relationship and merge the works (Fairport's version is literally the traditional song with rock and roll beats) and then set the Fairport version's arrrangement relationship at the recording level.
2021-04-22 11218, 2021
evelyn
(actually, the Pentangle one is even earlier still - 1970 not 1974)
2021-04-22 11246, 2021
thomasross joined the channel
2021-04-22 11222, 2021
averyfollett has quit
2021-04-22 11212, 2021
evelyn
as it stands we have Glasgerion (the original ballad) -> basis of -> Jack Orion -> basis of -> Jack O'Rion (which has work-level arrangement attributed to Fairport Convention)
2021-04-22 11216, 2021
averyfollett joined the channel
2021-04-22 11224, 2021
crism
evelyn, I’d say that whoever connected the Pentangle recording to the Fairport arrangement probably made the error. A new work should have been added (of which the Fairport work is an arrangement). But it’s hard to be careful about that, especially if there’s no disambiguation…
2021-04-22 11200, 2021
crism
It’s likely that the Fairport liner notes have something like, “All arrangements by Fairport Convention,” and whoever entered that was trying to capture that relationship.
2021-04-22 11218, 2021
crism
… though whether it belongs on the recording or the work is debatable.
