#musicbrainz

is logging

Users on #musicbrainz: MBChatLogger gnu_andrew amino_

were are all people?

is logging

Users on #musicbrainz: Wizzcat_ KingJ timo VxJasonxV DWSR SultS juhae EM3RY demosdemon Sergey_Ivanov Muz luks adrianw bricas noobie mchou pankkake nikki kanzure Synergist czaja vinci Rondom warp Jormangeud frewsxcv yvesr leonardo iarp asmodai rburton ocharles_ sampsyo mat_ nobraina ianweller Munger flamingspinach njh

Users on #musicbrainz: Wizzcat_ KingJ timo VxJasonxV DWSR SultS juhae EM3RY nobraina ianweller Munger flamingspinach njh mat_ sampsyo ocharles_ rburton asmodai iarp leonardo yvesr frewsxcv Jormangeud warp Rondom vinci czaja Synergist kanzure nikki pankkake mchou noobie bricas adrianw luks Muz Sergey_Ivanov demosdemon

is logging

good mornin

hello

http://musicbrainz.org/edit/17587270 I was confused too, and didn't bother finding what was to cancel :p

:p

i just screwed it^^

although it would be nice if two open and countervailing edits would be automatically cancelled

hi, could someone please point me toward the new guideline for artist AR in classical music ? I can't seem to find it

is there a special guideline for classical ?

pankkake: ?

there is one, but I never read it :p

Sekhmetouserapis:

nah i did not ask because of that :D

"Status: This Page is Glorious CSG History!" but yet I can't find an updated version :/

bootleg ?

it's a compilation done without the artists consent?

well,i guess it was made with the artists consent,but it seems to be a no label release

and the dj / compiler is unknown too

that wouldn't make it a bootleg

well,it might suggest that it's not completely with the artists cosent

I can't find any info on these compilation, only downloads!

yes,that's why i am not sure what to do with it

some of them were released at jamendo some years ago but they recently removed it from their site

and no idea if it is a CD rip, or a web release

definitely web

oh, well that would settle it, it was an official web release then

unless jamendo got tricked

is it me or a lot of jamendo releases disappear after some time?

yeah i think so

the darkpsy section was shrinked to like 5 releases

lol

i remember beeing it like 50 or more

lol that sentence sucked -.-

pf i won't add that series

averag bitrate 180 o.O

kepstin-laptop: you've gotta use the "link to this result" link at the bottom, jup

Sekhmetouserapis, in case nobody has linked it: http://musicbrainz.org/doc/Style/Classical

I don't know what you mean by artist AR though

<Error><Code>SlowDown</Code><Message>Please reduce your request rate.</Message><Resource /><RequestId>50a76de8-5e9d-45e9-bb22-2ca53ebfe939</RequestId></Error>

again??

is this going to become a regular thing on sunday? :)

:d

should we reopen http://tickets.musicbrainz.org/browse/MBS-4661 ?

did anyone of you try it?

yes, me

k

warp: and if you haven't got anything to do, test is screwed up and ISEing all over the place :P

reosarevok: thanks (and pankkake too, I wasn't in front of my computer when you posted it)

really?

nikki: I've just tested my MBS-842 changes, and did not notice anything breaking.

so, where are you seeing ISEs?

I saw them in the search results, artist page, artist aliases page, add artist, add work, add release group

they were all something about the transaction being aborted

so if you just restarted the server, maybe it's ok for now

I can't reproduce them right now...

I did restart the server, but that was 20 or 30 minutes ago.

I hadn't checked until you said you hadn't seen any

because earlier it was unusable

why in cover art page, miss size information and only "Types", I think resolution and size will be nice addition, because now i must click image properties

http://tickets.musicbrainz.org/browse/MBS-4702 we even got two tickets (not by me) for it

dubwai: presumably because we don't store the size. the images don't pass through our servers so we never have chance to find out

dubwai: the musicbrainz server doesn't have access to that information.

ok, but maybe possible to make that musicbrainz server once download image and save this info, and show it later, until image will be replaced

types info stored, so i think my reqeust is possbile

because, for example i download album witch also have full scan, some is better resolution that on mb, some not, and now i must to preview all image manually :-(

dubwai: we do not want to have the images on the musicbrainz server for copyright reasons.

warp: string "Res: 1280x1280, Size: 434 kb" will be any copyright issues? I just think that to store this info, like info abot type.

not image

dubwai: yes, but how can we get that info without downloading the image?

download get info and delete :-)

or copyright pigs can and in this find violation of their rights?

I hope that before the schema change release is made, some updates are done so that compilations and soundtracks aren't cluttering up artist album listings :/

how does coverartarchive solve the copyright issue?

^

I wonder how discogs does it, too

pankkake: it doesn't, really. It just pushes the issue off to the internet archive, who know how to deal with it.

oh, ok :p

kepstin-laptop: am I seeing a raised hand there? 8)

reosarevok: is there already a ticket open for that?

(seriously, I guess it'll be enough work for warp and ocharles to ensure stuff doesn't ship broken)

I assume it is, nikki?

there isn't a ticket

and it's unlikely to be fixed in time

:/

I did propose splitting it into main type and main type + extra types originally

it's a bit annoying on e.g. http://test.musicbrainz.org/artist/b6c18308-82c... because the tags are drawing your attention to releases that are really less interesting.

I guess the main problem will be figuring out how we want to display it

so if you have any good ideas, it'd help

I like the main type and main type + extra types idea.

what would you call the headings?

alternately, turning everything marked as a 'compilation' into gray so it's less distracting :)

"Albums", "Other Albums"? that's not great :/

yeah :/

one option might be to just put the albums without subtypes before the albums with subtypes, with a simple dividing line between them

Hmm. one thing that might be nice is to pull out all the compilations, soundtracks, etc. into a separate "Compilation", "Soundtrack" section, ignoring the primary type.

kepstin-laptop, nikki: "albums", and "albums, but..."? :p

that does make compilation soundtracks tricky tho :)

hmm, and I'd probably want to keep soundtrack singles with the other singles in typical cases...

it is just a bit of a mess, eh.

hmm. maybe just albums and other albums but don't split single/ep/other

the 'Filter' tool on the release group list page doesn't let you filter by subtypes right now either - only primary types.

Yeah

IMO that's what needs changing, with the list maybe remaining as-is

Or maybe a two-state switch, "list all albums" vs "separate albums with subtypes"

Dunno

I'm still annoyed that various artists releases aren't shown on the same page as single artist releases.

I would rather have single and various artist releases on one page, with compilations hidden away somewhere.

huh?

If the artist's involvement was small enough for it not to get in NGS' multiple AC

That sounds like barely related at all

Why should it be in an overview?