#musicbrainz

/

      • drsaunde
        wizzcat: who's playin? (or i guess that'll be a long list...) who are you goin' to see?
      • 2008-07-01 18335, 2008

      • alastairp joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18344, 2008

      • alastairp
      • 2008-07-01 18309, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        drsaunde: black mountain, holy fuck, battles, band of horses, cadence weapon, digitalism, hot chip, my bloody valentine, yeasayer
      • 2008-07-01 18326, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        and quite a bit of other stuff too I probably missed
      • 2008-07-01 18339, 2008

      • drsaunde
        i'd be remiss if i didn't (on Canada day) point out that 3 of those are Canadian!
      • 2008-07-01 18357, 2008

      • drsaunde
        I am really looking forward to My Bloody Valentine, i have tickets here for Sept.
      • 2008-07-01 18305, 2008

      • LotR
        yeasayer++
      • 2008-07-01 18326, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        a lot of good bands from canada yeah
      • 2008-07-01 18306, 2008

      • alastairp
        New Pornographers == win
      • 2008-07-01 18332, 2008

      • Infinito_ joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18340, 2008

      • adamgolding joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18341, 2008

      • xlotlu
        nice
      • 2008-07-01 18351, 2008

      • a12345 has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18315, 2008

      • Freso joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18333, 2008

      • xlotlu
        can we have a "has score at IMSLP" AR?
      • 2008-07-01 18336, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        how would that work without works?
      • 2008-07-01 18321, 2008

      • Freso
        Wizzcat: Like all the other ARs?
      • 2008-07-01 18342, 2008

      • Freso
        Wizzcat: If we can have a composer and a lyricist, a link to the score shouldn't be a problem.
      • 2008-07-01 18307, 2008

      • ruaok has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18307, 2008

      • alastairp
        xlotlu: oh, that would be awesome
      • 2008-07-01 18334, 2008

      • alastairp
        I want to go the other way, as well
      • 2008-07-01 18301, 2008

      • alastairp
      • 2008-07-01 18305, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        freso: well yes, but the same score would need to be linked to every performance wouldn't it?
      • 2008-07-01 18327, 2008

      • xlotlu
        alastairp: then you can go through the ML/RFC/RFV mess :)
      • 2008-07-01 18333, 2008

      • Freso
        Wizzcat: Just like it is now with composer and lyricist.
      • 2008-07-01 18339, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        true
      • 2008-07-01 18345, 2008

      • alastairp
        xlotlu: the wha?
      • 2008-07-01 18311, 2008

      • xlotlu
        and now all the ARs need to be linked to every release... what's the difference
      • 2008-07-01 18345, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        mostly the amount, but nevermind
      • 2008-07-01 18308, 2008

      • xlotlu
        i for one focus on a single release with the ARs, hoping to get those imported into a "work list"
      • 2008-07-01 18319, 2008

      • luks
        it would serve as a nice grouping of recordings
      • 2008-07-01 18328, 2008

      • luks
        until we have the grouping on MB (works)
      • 2008-07-01 18341, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        that's a good point
      • 2008-07-01 18349, 2008

      • xlotlu
        e.g. beethoven complete edition vs. beethoven nine symphonies, which is in fact the same recording
      • 2008-07-01 18345, 2008

      • xlotlu
        now this is interesting: http://imdbp.org/wiki/Main_Page ... i wonder what he's up to
      • 2008-07-01 18302, 2008

      • luks
        hm, but it would be even better if they had separate page for each movement
      • 2008-07-01 18303, 2008

      • xlotlu
        MB competition or complementary stuff?
      • 2008-07-01 18342, 2008

      • stochasticism joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18307, 2008

      • alastairp
        xlotlu: yeah, mediawiki doesn't strike me as the best choice for something like that
      • 2008-07-01 18313, 2008

      • xlotlu
        luks: if you're talking about IMSLP, most of the times they do
      • 2008-07-01 18347, 2008

      • xlotlu
      • 2008-07-01 18318, 2008

      • Infinito_ has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18325, 2008

      • duckman joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18306, 2008

      • `duckman has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18303, 2008

      • stochasticism has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18311, 2008

      • stochasticism joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18338, 2008

      • outsidecontext joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18338, 2008

      • adamgolding has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18342, 2008

      • adamgolding joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18341, 2008

      • duckman has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18353, 2008

      • mx80 joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18304, 2008

      • CatCat
        why is it in vietnamese?
      • 2008-07-01 18336, 2008

      • FauxFaux
        Why is /your face/ in vietnamese?
      • 2008-07-01 18356, 2008

      • CatCat poops on FauxFaux
      • 2008-07-01 18347, 2008

      • Muzzz FauxFauxs on CatCat
      • 2008-07-01 18341, 2008

      • CatCat
        hi MuzMuz
      • 2008-07-01 18319, 2008

      • FauxFaux
        I'd MuzMuz on it.
      • 2008-07-01 18346, 2008

      • Muzzz
        :o
      • 2008-07-01 18352, 2008

      • Muzzz runs off to make a baconriffic lunch
      • 2008-07-01 18328, 2008

      • mikemorr
        xlotlu: IMSLP is back up! \o/ \o/
      • 2008-07-01 18322, 2008

      • mikemorr
        That IMDBP thing looks interesting; probably he/they want to have a separate DB for stuff that is public domain regardless of country or year
      • 2008-07-01 18342, 2008

      • mikemorr
        (i.e. information _about_ music)
      • 2008-07-01 18352, 2008

      • alastairp
        mikemorr: yeah, there seems to already be some sharing of content between the sites
      • 2008-07-01 18325, 2008

      • mikemorr was _so_ bummed out when IMSLP went down
      • 2008-07-01 18358, 2008

      • alastairp
        it went down about a week after I handed in a project that used some charts from it :-P
      • 2008-07-01 18307, 2008

      • alastairp
        I was really lucky :)
      • 2008-07-01 18326, 2008

      • mikemorr
        alastairp: whoops, I didn't scroll back far enough. I guess it was you who first mentioned it in here. Thanks for the heads up!
      • 2008-07-01 18333, 2008

      • mikemorr
        (Thanks xlotlu also :) )
      • 2008-07-01 18339, 2008

      • alastairp
        mikemorr: no worries :)
      • 2008-07-01 18346, 2008

      • alastairp
        I only got it from slashdot, so, yeah
      • 2008-07-01 18352, 2008

      • alastairp
        :)
      • 2008-07-01 18326, 2008

      • alastairp
        the prospect of imslp/mb links is pretty awesome
      • 2008-07-01 18321, 2008

      • mikemorr
        +1
      • 2008-07-01 18332, 2008

      • mikemorr
        I wonder if we would need to steer clear of such links for scores that are not PD worldwide, though?
      • 2008-07-01 18351, 2008

      • alastairp
        hmm
      • 2008-07-01 18356, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        I don't really see why, mb wouldn't be linking directly to the pdfs
      • 2008-07-01 18309, 2008

      • alastairp
        as I understand it, imslp is on to that a lot more
      • 2008-07-01 18311, 2008

      • CatCat
        ugh
      • 2008-07-01 18318, 2008

      • CatCat
        somebody kill me or something
      • 2008-07-01 18325, 2008

      • CatCat
        @make some sort fo heling thing
      • 2008-07-01 18339, 2008

      • CatCat
        how come there's no real helig poitions outside of games
      • 2008-07-01 18341, 2008

      • alastairp
        such that country based rights are (more) clearly stated
      • 2008-07-01 18341, 2008

      • CatCat
        :C
      • 2008-07-01 18358, 2008

      • CatCat
        :C
      • 2008-07-01 18359, 2008

      • CatCat
        :C
      • 2008-07-01 18300, 2008

      • CatCat
        :C
      • 2008-07-01 18305, 2008

      • alastairp
        :)
      • 2008-07-01 18305, 2008

      • CatCat
        :C
      • 2008-07-01 18307, 2008

      • CatCat
        :C:C
      • 2008-07-01 18343, 2008

      • slaad joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18320, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        CatCat: large amounts of paracetamol, tea and fisherman's friend
      • 2008-07-01 18329, 2008

      • Freso has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18341, 2008

      • rjmunro has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18321, 2008

      • duckman joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18337, 2008

      • alastairp has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18353, 2008

      • nikki_ joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18340, 2008

      • stochasticism has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18333, 2008

      • nikki has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18356, 2008

      • rjmunro joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18318, 2008

      • mikemorr
        Seeking opinions. Do you all agree with me on http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=8942487 ?
      • 2008-07-01 18323, 2008

      • guardian has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18339, 2008

      • guardian joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18357, 2008

      • guardian
        guardian is now known as guardian4741
      • 2008-07-01 18349, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        that cover art scares me
      • 2008-07-01 18304, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        but yes, ": Hixxy's Mix" imo
      • 2008-07-01 18349, 2008

      • nikki_
        I don't see why it shouldn't be
      • 2008-07-01 18301, 2008

      • nikki_
        nikki_ is now known as nikki
      • 2008-07-01 18334, 2008

      • mikemorr
        http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=2046307 was 9 to 1 against, but I think that was before ARs existed
      • 2008-07-01 18350, 2008

      • mikemorr
        so maybe they were trying to create a DJMixStyle
      • 2008-07-01 18341, 2008

      • mikemorr
        I didn't read all the way through the mb-users 2004-12 archives to see what was being discussed
      • 2008-07-01 18354, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        couldn't find the thread
      • 2008-07-01 18357, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        seems id's changed or something
      • 2008-07-01 18319, 2008

      • Wizzcat
        but yeah, it's a pretty clear cut case according to current practice I'd say
      • 2008-07-01 18316, 2008

      • luks
        mikemorr: 'Mixed by X' used to be like 'Orchestra feat. composer: Composer' before we had the DJ-mixed AR
      • 2008-07-01 18333, 2008

      • luks
        so Hixxy's Mix as a subtitle would be fine, otherwise it should be removed
      • 2008-07-01 18346, 2008

      • juxtap joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18348, 2008

      • mikemorr
        luks: Cool. Thanks for the historical info :)
      • 2008-07-01 18315, 2008

      • mikemorr
      • 2008-07-01 18338, 2008

      • mikemorr
        In this case, I'd say it really is a DiscTitle (i.e. a subtitle) and not just ExtraTitleInformation about who the DJ is.
      • 2008-07-01 18333, 2008

      • nikki agrees
      • 2008-07-01 18322, 2008

      • mikemorr
        pbryan: I would say no, they should not be merged. Looks like one is a stand-alone disc and the other is part of a box set.
      • 2008-07-01 18320, 2008

      • mikemorr
        If BrianFreud were around I think he'd probably say "no merge" on those for sure.
      • 2008-07-01 18339, 2008

      • srotta
        Damn those track titles look ugly.
      • 2008-07-01 18344, 2008

      • srotta
        Just an observation, carry on.
      • 2008-07-01 18345, 2008

      • srotta
        8)
      • 2008-07-01 18324, 2008

      • mikemorr
        srotta: on the Reich tracks, or the Bonkers thing?
      • 2008-07-01 18351, 2008

      • srotta
        Reich.
      • 2008-07-01 18334, 2008

      • milosz
        is there a way to make picard only move tracks according to the file-naming settings?
      • 2008-07-01 18352, 2008

      • milosz
        i've tagged 500 or so files with it previously without moving them, now they're all in one directory
      • 2008-07-01 18308, 2008

      • mikemorr
        srotta: They look OK to me, assuming "Section I" etc. is printed in the score.
      • 2008-07-01 18329, 2008

      • milosz
        it seems that if they are fully qualified, picard just doesn't operate on them at all
      • 2008-07-01 18329, 2008

      • srotta
        mikemorr: They probably are OK, they are just ugly 8)
      • 2008-07-01 18349, 2008

      • mikemorr
        heh
      • 2008-07-01 18335, 2008

      • atsampson has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18343, 2008

      • duckman has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18303, 2008

      • atsampson joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18309, 2008

      • adamgolding has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18313, 2008

      • adamgolding joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18352, 2008

      • adamgolding has quit
      • 2008-07-01 18356, 2008

      • adamgolding joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18330, 2008

      • Freso joined the channel
      • 2008-07-01 18345, 2008

      • CatCat
        OMG
      • 2008-07-01 18348, 2008

      • CatCat
        youy guys
      • 2008-07-01 18353, 2008

      • CatCat
        guess what I did
      • 2008-07-01 18306, 2008

      • adamgolding
        ?
      • 2008-07-01 18328, 2008

      • Freso
        You...
      • 2008-07-01 18330, 2008

      • Freso
        Eh.
      • 2008-07-01 18348, 2008

      • Freso
        Entered everything in your collection with complete ARs?
      • 2008-07-01 18354, 2008

      • CatCat
        nooo