#musicbrainz

/

      • krono joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15322, 2016

      • gcilou joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15307, 2016

      • mezod has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15356, 2016

      • xps2 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15326, 2016

      • mezod joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15342, 2016

      • xps2 has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15303, 2016

      • CallerNo6 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15326, 2016

      • xps2 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15327, 2016

      • Slurpee joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15316, 2016

      • diana_olhovyk has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15312, 2016

      • diana_olhovyk_ joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15340, 2016

      • diana_olhovyk_ has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15303, 2016

      • Lotheric has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15313, 2016

      • Lotheric joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15317, 2016

      • hibiscuskazeneko has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15344, 2016

      • JoeLlama joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15331, 2016

      • krono_ joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15301, 2016

      • krono has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15316, 2016

      • krono_ has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15312, 2016

      • matoro joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15326, 2016

      • JoeLlama has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15346, 2016

      • yeeeargh joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15348, 2016

      • Lotheric has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15303, 2016

      • Lotheric joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15341, 2016

      • matoro has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15310, 2016

      • matoro joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15335, 2016

      • krono joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15309, 2016

      • aron_kexp joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15330, 2016

      • black-perl joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15346, 2016

      • matoro has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15348, 2016

      • matoro joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15346, 2016

      • Zastai joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15331, 2016

      • achadwick has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15337, 2016

      • ale_ has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15335, 2016

      • ljunkie has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15352, 2016

      • ljunkie joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15308, 2016

      • matoro has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15359, 2016

      • diana_olhovyk joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15329, 2016

      • opatel99 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15319, 2016

      • Gore|home
        is this ok: CAINE 01 : Das Amulett von Kyan'Kor or should it be CAINE, Episode 01: Das Amulett von Kyan'Kor
      • 2016-06-01 15337, 2016

      • Gore|home
        is this ok: "CAINE 01 : Das Amulett von Kyan'Kor" or should it be "CAINE, Episode 01: Das Amulett von Kyan'Kor"
      • 2016-06-01 15314, 2016

      • matoro joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15315, 2016

      • Zastai
        not sure. certainly not " : ", so at least "CAINE 01: Das ..."
      • 2016-06-01 15303, 2016

      • Zastai
        given https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caine_%28H%C3%B6rsp… it should probably be Caine instead of CAINE
      • 2016-06-01 15337, 2016

      • Gore|home
      • 2016-06-01 15340, 2016

      • Gore|home
        official site
      • 2016-06-01 15357, 2016

      • Gore|home
        my OCD wants "CAINE, Episode 01: Das Amulett von Kyan'Kor"
      • 2016-06-01 15354, 2016

      • Zastai
        I'm inclined to see WP as more authorative and use Caine - artist intent is hard to prove; but I don't feel super strongly about it
      • 2016-06-01 15328, 2016

      • Zastai
        as for the ", Episode", is it called an episode anywhere specifically?
      • 2016-06-01 15316, 2016

      • Zastai
        otherwise I'd probably fall back on ", Volume" as generic descriptor; and I'm not sure what MB's policy is (if any) on keeping leading zeroes on chapter/volume numbers
      • 2016-06-01 15314, 2016

      • Zastai
        So if I was adding these CDs, I would probably use "Caine, Volume 1: Das Amulett von Kyan'Kor"
      • 2016-06-01 15320, 2016

      • Gore|home
        I read it somewhere, i´ll search
      • 2016-06-01 15304, 2016

      • Zastai
        they seem to be standalone radio plays, so i'd still use Volume; Episode to me suggests more of a continuity
      • 2016-06-01 15345, 2016

      • Zastai
        ah, the official store lists them as 'Folge 9: Kartaan' etc
      • 2016-06-01 15300, 2016

      • Zastai
        so "Caine, Folge 1: Das ..." I suppose
      • 2016-06-01 15330, 2016

      • Gore|home
        We are still international, so I guess englisch is better except for the title
      • 2016-06-01 15340, 2016

      • Zastai
        (it also has "Mehr von Caine", not "Mehr von CAINE")
      • 2016-06-01 15347, 2016

      • Gore|home
      • 2016-06-01 15348, 2016

      • Zastai
        nah, I don't mind the Folge
      • 2016-06-01 15352, 2016

      • Gore|home
        that was a lot of work :D
      • 2016-06-01 15319, 2016

      • Zastai
        i can imagine. any reason the 40th one there has different RG attributes than the rest?
      • 2016-06-01 15341, 2016

      • Gore|home
        because it´s a soundtrack only
      • 2016-06-01 15346, 2016

      • Gore|home
        no spoken words
      • 2016-06-01 15354, 2016

      • Zastai
        ok
      • 2016-06-01 15323, 2016

      • Zastai
        would still have used Album instead of Other for the others though
      • 2016-06-01 15331, 2016

      • Zastai
        but that's a minor point
      • 2016-06-01 15305, 2016

      • Zastai
        I'm also not sure I would have used the main character as release artist; according to https://beta.musicbrainz.org/doc/Style/Specific_t… it should probably be the author instead
      • 2016-06-01 15357, 2016

      • Gore|home
        yep, I only changed the titels
      • 2016-06-01 15304, 2016

      • Gore|home
        but thought about it aswell
      • 2016-06-01 15308, 2016

      • Gore|home
        I think I have Episode from this channel, and it was that it has more of "ongoing" than volume
      • 2016-06-01 15323, 2016

      • Gore|home
        can´t find it though on the site
      • 2016-06-01 15330, 2016

      • matoro has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15312, 2016

      • matoro joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15331, 2016

      • regagain joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15325, 2016

      • kossy_ joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15333, 2016

      • diana_olhovyk has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15347, 2016

      • diana_olhovyk_ joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15358, 2016

      • canidae has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15347, 2016

      • regagain has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15348, 2016

      • hjak1876jhjd7182 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15355, 2016

      • diana_olhovyk_ has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15302, 2016

      • kartikgupta0909 has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15320, 2016

      • regagain joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15345, 2016

      • hjak1876jhjd7182 has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15306, 2016

      • jcazevedo has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15357, 2016

      • diana_olhovyk_ joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15319, 2016

      • black-perl has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15344, 2016

      • CatQuest
        [19:37] <Zastai> otherwise I'd probably fall back on ", Volume" as generic descriptor;
      • 2016-06-01 15344, 2016

      • CatQuest
        nah, we just go with whatever "generic discriptor" they have, including *no* name at all, just number, name etc. what you're thinking of is the *old*, (hopefully, by now, officially) depreciated volume guideline :)
      • 2016-06-01 15352, 2016

      • CatQuest
        [19:41] <Gore|home> We are still international, so I guess englisch is better except for the title
      • 2016-06-01 15352, 2016

      • CatQuest
        that contradicts itself. :) we are international, so we can use german, japanese, norwegian, etc "volume" words
      • 2016-06-01 15311, 2016

      • aron_kexp has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15320, 2016

      • hjak1876jhjd7182 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15326, 2016

      • aron_kexp joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15321, 2016

      • fc7 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15330, 2016

      • opatel99 has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15340, 2016

      • aron_kexp_ joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15352, 2016

      • aron_kexp has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15352, 2016

      • aron_kexp_ is now known as aron_kexp
      • 2016-06-01 15300, 2016

      • fc7 has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15325, 2016

      • Eleint has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15351, 2016

      • jcazevedo joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15346, 2016

      • CallerNo6
        agreed, that does sound contradictory
      • 2016-06-01 15337, 2016

      • hjak1876jhjd7182 has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15341, 2016

      • aron_kexp has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15309, 2016

      • fc7 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15357, 2016

      • peaveyman has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15355, 2016

      • aron_kexp joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15357, 2016

      • ariscop has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15353, 2016

      • peaveyman joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15317, 2016

      • aron_kexp has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15347, 2016

      • aron_kexp joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15329, 2016

      • Slash_84 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15319, 2016

      • Slash_84 has left the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15357, 2016

      • yeeeargh has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15304, 2016

      • Zastai has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15339, 2016

      • aron_kexp has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15302, 2016

      • Freso
        Gore|home: We're international, so it's better to use the original/native wording. ;)
      • 2016-06-01 15313, 2016

      • Freso
        And I see CatQuest already said as much! 👍
      • 2016-06-01 15314, 2016

      • Freso
        Gore|home: Have a look at https://musicbrainz.org/doc/Style/Specific_types_… - it may or may not apply to your specific case.
      • 2016-06-01 15301, 2016

      • Freso
        But it does touch on using "chapter" and "part" etc., so if nothing more specific to your use case is in the guidelines, it probably wouldn't be completely off to glance towards those.
      • 2016-06-01 15306, 2016

      • mezod has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15309, 2016

      • Freso
        (Note that the audiobook guidelines have this bit in them: "Note, that if the release is not an English language release, the appropriate language's equivalent of "Chapter" and "Part" can be used." - re: being international. :))
      • 2016-06-01 15309, 2016

      • diana_olhovyk_ has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15308, 2016

      • peaveyman has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15339, 2016

      • kartikgupta0909 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15301, 2016

      • ariscop joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15347, 2016

      • aron_kexp joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15338, 2016

      • peaveyman joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15320, 2016

      • fc7 has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15320, 2016

      • Zialus_PT joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15327, 2016

      • Zialus has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15300, 2016

      • mezod joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15353, 2016

      • GuidovanPossum joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15325, 2016

      • GuidovanPossum has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15300, 2016

      • GuidovanPossum joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15310, 2016

      • GuidovanPossum has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15332, 2016

      • fc7 joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15328, 2016

      • matoro has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15327, 2016

      • fc7 has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15336, 2016

      • PityDaFool has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15334, 2016

      • aron_kexp has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15324, 2016

      • matoro joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15337, 2016

      • GuidovanPossum joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15341, 2016

      • daytime has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15336, 2016

      • demonimin has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15321, 2016

      • nighttime joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15309, 2016

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
      • 2016-06-01 15343, 2016

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
      • 2016-06-01 15349, 2016

      • D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel