#musicbrainz

/

      • ttpcodes_ joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14141, 2022

      • ttpcodes has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14127, 2022

      • Vacuity has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14156, 2022

      • Vacuity joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14157, 2022

      • skelly37 joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14104, 2022

      • ttree has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14132, 2022

      • fhe joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14158, 2022

      • G0d joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14130, 2022

      • thuna` has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14106, 2022

      • skelly37 has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14113, 2022

      • ttpcodes_ has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14118, 2022

      • ttpcodes joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14130, 2022

      • G0d has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14130, 2022

      • MRiddickW joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14144, 2022

      • Lotheric
        hah
      • 2022-05-21 14114, 2022

      • MRiddickW has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14157, 2022

      • skelly37 joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14108, 2022

      • zer0bitz joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14120, 2022

      • xplt joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14152, 2022

      • skelly37 has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14159, 2022

      • notsosmart
        should different CD pressing be entered separately in MB? I see in discogs even different pressings at the same plant are entered separately
      • 2022-05-21 14102, 2022

      • notsosmart
      • 2022-05-21 14102, 2022

      • notsosmart
      • 2022-05-21 14103, 2022

      • notsosmart
      • 2022-05-21 14133, 2022

      • notsosmart
        https://musicbrainz.org/release/de31ca06-a515-4c0… -- this one should correspond to one of them, or some other pressing which is not entered
      • 2022-05-21 14129, 2022

      • Erin
        notsosmart : i believe if it's literally just the same thing, you can enter a second release date
      • 2022-05-21 14104, 2022

      • Erin
        just add a release event and fill out the second date
      • 2022-05-21 14127, 2022

      • Erin
        although if it fundamentally changed in some way, then you do a second release
      • 2022-05-21 14139, 2022

      • notsosmart
        but the release date is unknown
      • 2022-05-21 14132, 2022

      • notsosmart
        I very much doubt it is different in any even barely substantial way
      • 2022-05-21 14112, 2022

      • notsosmart
        I could link to all three of them, but there is a distinction between two pressing plants in discogs, and on MB there is an option to enter a pressing plant
      • 2022-05-21 14135, 2022

      • notsosmart
        so by linking to discogs I indicate that the release is pressed in one of those plants, but I don't know that
      • 2022-05-21 14141, 2022

      • notsosmart
        so I'd rather remove a link to discogs
      • 2022-05-21 14106, 2022

      • notsosmart
        but I could also link to all three discogs releases, if pressing plant is not relevant
      • 2022-05-21 14145, 2022

      • ItsPizzaTime1501 has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14137, 2022

      • xplt has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14149, 2022

      • xplt joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14130, 2022

      • Erin
        notsosmart i mean you say its a re-pressing right?
      • 2022-05-21 14135, 2022

      • Erin
        if there's no known release date
      • 2022-05-21 14138, 2022

      • Erin
        then what is distinct about it?
      • 2022-05-21 14135, 2022

      • notsosmart
        https://www.discogs.com/release/12299829 - pressed by Cinram, Olyphant, PA, Mastering SID Code: ifpi L909
      • 2022-05-21 14136, 2022

      • notsosmart
        https://www.discogs.com/release/1384087 - pressed by Cinram, Olyphant, PA, Mastering SID Code: ifpi L902
      • 2022-05-21 14136, 2022

      • notsosmart
      • 2022-05-21 14150, 2022

      • notsosmart
        that is what is different between them
      • 2022-05-21 14125, 2022

      • notsosmart
        the first pressing of this CD was in 1996, but it is not known from what dates 2 of them are
      • 2022-05-21 14127, 2022

      • skelly37 joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14121, 2022

      • crism
        Discogs is for collectors, and they care very much about different pressings, matrix, etc. MusicBrainz is primarily for taggers, so if the essentials are unchanged (cover art, barcode, track times), it doesn’t generally warrant a separate release.
      • 2022-05-21 14128, 2022

      • skelly37 has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14142, 2022

      • trolley has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14153, 2022

      • fhe has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14107, 2022

      • ttpcodes has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14124, 2022

      • ttpcodes joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14129, 2022

      • zer0bitz has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14102, 2022

      • Lotheric has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14114, 2022

      • Lotheric joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14146, 2022

      • Lotheric has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14123, 2022

      • Lotheric joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14152, 2022

      • xplt has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14106, 2022

      • xplt joined the channel
      • 2022-05-21 14116, 2022

      • Lotheric has quit
      • 2022-05-21 14153, 2022

      • MRiddickW joined the channel