#musicbrainz

/

      • theracermaster has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14611, 2022

      • theracermaster5 joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14635, 2022

      • theracermaster joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14640, 2022

      • theracermaster5 has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14649, 2022

      • bitmap joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14647, 2022

      • Vacuity has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14643, 2022

      • Vacuity joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14612, 2022

      • fhe joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14612, 2022

      • Neopolitan has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14631, 2022

      • Neopolitan joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14620, 2022

      • ttpcodes has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14640, 2022

      • ttpcodes joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14630, 2022

      • G0d joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14607, 2022

      • ttree has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14645, 2022

      • MRiddickW joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14625, 2022

      • otisolsen70 joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14630, 2022

      • ttpcodes has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14652, 2022

      • ttpcodes joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14617, 2022

      • zer0bitz joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14602, 2022

      • fhe has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14615, 2022

      • zer0bitz_ joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14634, 2022

      • zer0bitz has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14632, 2022

      • MRiddickW has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14648, 2022

      • thuna` has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14632, 2022

      • otisolsen70 has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14634, 2022

      • ttpcodes has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14608, 2022

      • ttpcodes joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14634, 2022

      • scrumplex_ joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14642, 2022

      • scrumplex has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14616, 2022

      • ttree joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14605, 2022

      • thuna` joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14625, 2022

      • thuna`
        If an album has the title "Infinity Awaits Us: A Royalty Free OST" in bandcamp, would it be appropriate to name it "Infinity Awaits Us" in MB?
      • 2022-05-26 14608, 2022

      • scrumplex_ is now known as scrumplex
      • 2022-05-26 14653, 2022

      • kepstin
        thuna`: no, just use the full name.
      • 2022-05-26 14613, 2022

      • kepstin
        there's no special guidelines for soundtrack titles on musicbrainz (any more)
      • 2022-05-26 14625, 2022

      • thuna`
        I see. What about "X - EP"? Is it appropriate to name it "X"?
      • 2022-05-26 14622, 2022

      • Lotheric_
      • 2022-05-26 14651, 2022

      • Lotheric_
        f a release includes a designation such as EP/E.P., 7", CD, LP or single as part of its title, include it in the release title. If a format designation is not explicitly part of the title, it should not be added.
      • 2022-05-26 14656, 2022

      • Lotheric_ is now known as Lotheric
      • 2022-05-26 14641, 2022

      • thuna`
        Is bandcamp able to mark a release as an EP outside the title? How do you distinguish between an "EP" that is actually a part of the title and one that is simply metadata?
      • 2022-05-26 14647, 2022

      • thuna`
        In my specific case, the Spotify release resolves it; EP is not part of the title. What about in general, however?
      • 2022-05-26 14631, 2022

      • derwin
        if a release is 3-5 tracks
      • 2022-05-26 14635, 2022

      • derwin
        isn't promoted as an album
      • 2022-05-26 14646, 2022

      • derwin
        isn't named after one of the tracks on it (which may have multiple mixes)
      • 2022-05-26 14650, 2022

      • derwin
        it's probably an EP
      • 2022-05-26 14641, 2022

      • Lotheric
        you should check if there's a physical release and see hosw it's titled
      • 2022-05-26 14609, 2022

      • Lotheric
        digital release are often inconsistent between stores/sources
      • 2022-05-26 14609, 2022

      • derwin
        the place you are most likely to see the label say whether it's an EP is soundcloud or beatport, depending on genre
      • 2022-05-26 14630, 2022

      • derwin
        (as those places tend to have the promo copy)
      • 2022-05-26 14604, 2022

      • thuna`
        There's no physical release as far as I'm aware
      • 2022-05-26 14642, 2022

      • thuna`
        derwin: The issue isn't wheter it's an EP or not, it's wheter the album name is "X - EP" or "X"
      • 2022-05-26 14601, 2022

      • derwin
        sure, it was slightly ambiguous to me what you meant by "in general"
      • 2022-05-26 14620, 2022

      • derwin
        " How do you distinguish between an "EP" that is actually a part of the title and one that is simply metadata? " etc.
      • 2022-05-26 14636, 2022

      • thuna`
        Ok, I guess it was a bit confusing.
      • 2022-05-26 14658, 2022

      • thuna`
        The question is: Because bandcamp does not make the Album/EP distinction, an EP must explicitly name itself one. When this is done in the title, must that be considered a part of the title not?
      • 2022-05-26 14610, 2022

      • thuna`
        or not*
      • 2022-05-26 14604, 2022

      • Lotheric
        what is the release url on bandcamp ?
      • 2022-05-26 14601, 2022

      • derwin
        basically the answer to your question is "online stores are terrible about making any distinction between EP, single and Album, and you have to rely on other cues"
      • 2022-05-26 14626, 2022

      • thuna`
      • 2022-05-26 14629, 2022

      • derwin
        in 99% you just have to make your best guess
      • 2022-05-26 14616, 2022

      • thuna`
      • 2022-05-26 14636, 2022

      • meLon_ is now known as earthmeLon
      • 2022-05-26 14604, 2022

      • Lotheric
      • 2022-05-26 14624, 2022

      • Lotheric
        says it's en EP here
      • 2022-05-26 14653, 2022

      • Lotheric
      • 2022-05-26 14603, 2022

      • Lotheric
        I'D keep EP in the name since the artist himself posted the title this way
      • 2022-05-26 14612, 2022

      • thuna`
        Alright so the description in bandcamp reads "Masks is a goodie bag of seasonal Halloween tracks and other fantastical spooky legends!"
      • 2022-05-26 14632, 2022

      • thuna`
      • 2022-05-26 14601, 2022

      • thuna`
        Tardis EP certainly has the EP as part of the title, since it is part of the cover art
      • 2022-05-26 14625, 2022

      • thuna`
        With Tardis EP, the description reads "The TARDIS - EP is a small collection of my Doctor Who fan music."
      • 2022-05-26 14622, 2022

      • derwin
        Lotheric: I wouldn't. bandcamp title information sucks.
      • 2022-05-26 14646, 2022

      • derwin
        it doesn't say EP in the title on any other service...
      • 2022-05-26 14619, 2022

      • Lotheric
        well, there's always a edge case
      • 2022-05-26 14625, 2022

      • Lotheric
        guidelines are guidelines
      • 2022-05-26 14632, 2022

      • Lotheric
        put it to a vote
      • 2022-05-26 14634, 2022

      • Lotheric
        :)
      • 2022-05-26 14656, 2022

      • theracermaster has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14607, 2022

      • theracermaster joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14603, 2022

      • scrumplex has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14603, 2022

      • scrumplex joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14620, 2022

      • SothoTalKer joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14602, 2022

      • CatQuest
        personally I will only put "ep" asa type if it's explicitly stated (described as, or includes in title) the "EP" bit
      • 2022-05-26 14602, 2022

      • CatQuest
        also i will only includ "ep" in title if coerart does so.
      • 2022-05-26 14651, 2022

      • CatQuest
        I will *not* fall back on "ep designation" based on titles or amount of tracks
      • 2022-05-26 14613, 2022

      • CatQuest
        there are 4 track albums and 7 track "ep's"
      • 2022-05-26 14626, 2022

      • CatQuest
        (in the digital era atleast)
      • 2022-05-26 14634, 2022

      • CatQuest
        with vinyl it's much simpler
      • 2022-05-26 14630, 2022

      • CatQuest
        (but these will, ostensibly be called "ep" or state "ep" on them, regardless usually)
      • 2022-05-26 14646, 2022

      • CatQuest
        anyay i go to bed propperly now
      • 2022-05-26 14650, 2022

      • CatQuest
        natta!
      • 2022-05-26 14654, 2022

      • ehmry has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14629, 2022

      • G0d has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14634, 2022

      • zer0bitz_ has quit
      • 2022-05-26 14629, 2022

      • PelvicSorcery joined the channel
      • 2022-05-26 14614, 2022

      • PelvicSorcery
        Does anyone know the difference between these two releases?  I think they're the same but I want a second opinion.
      • 2022-05-26 14622, 2022

      • PelvicSorcery
      • 2022-05-26 14627, 2022

      • PelvicSorcery