#musicbrainz

/

      • Maxr1998_ joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34530, 2023

      • Maxr1998 has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34547, 2023

      • minimal has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34510, 2023

      • sentriz
        these are two releases groups by the same name, by the same artist. does one deserve a disambiguation? or is the year enough? https://beta.musicbrainz.org/release-group/282c76… https://beta.musicbrainz.org/release-group/30a8c2…
      • 2023-12-11 34519, 2023

      • crism
        sentriz, maybe take a cue from Wikipedia and add “1980 album” and “2003 album” as disambigs? The release group search results do not include years, so I think that would be helpful. (And release search does not include release groups, so that’s just going to be confusing regardless…)
      • 2023-12-11 34559, 2023

      • sentriz
        crism: ok sure. how about this? don't want to add a disambiguation to both of them https://beta.musicbrainz.org/edit/106659736
      • 2023-12-11 34521, 2023

      • sentriz
        oop sorry for beta link
      • 2023-12-11 34531, 2023

      • crism
        The negative disambig feels wrong to me. What if they come out with another self-titled one? (Looking at you, Peter Gabriel and Chicago.)
      • 2023-12-11 34520, 2023

      • crism
        I thought about just adding a disambig to 2003, too, but then when a new user does a search and gets the 1980 one, how do they know that’s right? I think they both could use disambigs.
      • 2023-12-11 34558, 2023

      • sentriz
        mm yeah I see your point
      • 2023-12-11 34530, 2023

      • sentriz
        that said, the debut is way more popular than the 2003 one
      • 2023-12-11 34559, 2023

      • sentriz
        feels like putting a disambiguation on Pink Floyd or something :~)
      • 2023-12-11 34502, 2023

      • crism
        I hear you… will KJ fans know what’s right?
      • 2023-12-11 34557, 2023

      • sentriz
        haha i'd say so, i've been listening to the debut for years. i only found the 2003 one recently and i got very confused
      • 2023-12-11 34510, 2023

      • sentriz
        (my music player was also very confused)
      • 2023-12-11 34554, 2023

      • crism
        Well, I’d start with “2003 album” for that one… see if confusion ensues around the 1980 one.
      • 2023-12-11 34548, 2023

      • sentriz
        ooh here's another example. the debut has no disambiguation either https://musicbrainz.org/artist/4ebb5ad3-9018-407d…
      • 2023-12-11 34502, 2023

      • sentriz
        ok sure
      • 2023-12-11 34543, 2023

      • sentriz
      • 2023-12-11 34547, 2023

      • crism
        Oh, American Football… I used to bike past their house regularly. (-:
      • 2023-12-11 34529, 2023

      • sentriz
        woah cool
      • 2023-12-11 34553, 2023

      • lusciouslover has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34536, 2023

      • lusciouslover joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34545, 2023

      • lusciouslover has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34546, 2023

      • lusciouslover joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34503, 2023

      • rbatty has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34538, 2023

      • lusciouslover has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34506, 2023

      • srxl has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34513, 2023

      • srxl joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34551, 2023

      • moviuro has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34510, 2023

      • moviuro joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34538, 2023

      • fletchto99 has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34551, 2023

      • fletchto99 joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34522, 2023

      • srxl has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34515, 2023

      • rbatty joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34520, 2023

      • srxl joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34557, 2023

      • anonn joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34540, 2023

      • lusciouslover joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34526, 2023

      • lusciouslover has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34506, 2023

      • eharris joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34528, 2023

      • eharris has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34526, 2023

      • derwin
      • 2023-12-11 34508, 2023

      • ttpcodes_ has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34525, 2023

      • ttpcodes joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34526, 2023

      • lekko joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34517, 2023

      • lekko has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34545, 2023

      • yano has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34549, 2023

      • yano joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34526, 2023

      • relaxoMob has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34539, 2023

      • relaxoMob joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34525, 2023

      • prout has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34550, 2023

      • prout joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34519, 2023

      • minimal joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34539, 2023

      • elomatreb has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34511, 2023

      • elomatreb joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34506, 2023

      • Frikandel joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34505, 2023

      • prathamg joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34559, 2023

      • chris0 joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34509, 2023

      • s4nch1t joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34549, 2023

      • Frikandel has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34552, 2023

      • prathamg has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34547, 2023

      • s4nch1t has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34505, 2023

      • relaxoMob has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34545, 2023

      • gtkgtkgtk has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34500, 2023

      • gtkgtkgtk joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34513, 2023

      • G0d has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34523, 2023

      • relaxoMob joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34511, 2023

      • Cheezm___ has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34534, 2023

      • anonn has quit
      • 2023-12-11 34552, 2023

      • lusciouslover joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34501, 2023

      • Cheezmo joined the channel
      • 2023-12-11 34546, 2023

      • lusciouslover has quit