I also finally finished MBS-8736 just need to submit the PR. it generates a 116MB dump currently and contains examples of pretty much every entity/relationship type
Well, inasmuch as we'd need to move all the all uses somewhere else before we can merge/remove it.
Do people think it is ok to move these all to guitar and if so, can we make a bot for it?
reosarevok
And we would want to basically move all the "guitars" stuff to "guitar"
oh, ok. What he said
CatQuest
:D
To "guitar" + an instrument credit.
reosarevok
I think that the amount of uses that are "an unspecified instrument of the guitar family", rather than just "multiple guitars", is probably small enough to be negligible in a bot move
But of course, it's hard to prove this
Freso
I'd be okay with this.
reosarevok
Other than by checking them all by hand, which yeah no
naiveaiguy has left the channel
Freso
Everyone in favour of this, say YAY!
reosarevok
Since the bot should make edits, if someone has used it right they will probably notice it in their subscriptions and shout to us about it
Freso
Everyone in opposition to this, say NAY!
CatQuest
to be fair there are "errounous" instrument credits added every day. errounous as in not perfect or sub optimla or peopel don't quite get the right instrument
reosarevok
YAY!
CatQuest
YAY
reosarevok: good point
Freso
(If you're neutral, say RAY!)
CatQuest
lol
hello people!
reosarevok
heh. I think it's basically us having an opinion here :p
Freso
RAY, leaning towards YAY.
Anyway.
reosarevok
Well, no NAYs at least :p
CatQuest
:P
Freso
No one seems opposed to this, and INST and STYLE leads are both in favour.
reosarevok wonders if writing a bot script for this could be GCI
CatQuest
lets wait a few more mins jsut in case soem oen was in the batchroom
reosarevok
Because we do have a couple bots
CatQuest
WC
reosarevok
But I'm not sure if any is designed so far to deal with instruments and credits
CatQuest
batchroom? oh ew
Leo_Verto
YAY!
CatQuest
\O/
Freso
reosarevok: I think that's worth looking into.
reosarevok
:) ok
Freso
Anyway.
CatQuest
chhavi_, ruaok Leo_Verto
yvanzo:
Freso
4 YAYs, 0 RAYs, 0 NAYs.
yvanzo
reosarevok: if you move it, will you still be able to find correct use once a definitive solution is found?
reosarevok
I think that's more likely to work than hoping some dev will write the bot
CatQuest
reosarevok: +1
Freso
yvanzo: It would keep artist credit "guitars".
CatQuest
yes
Freso
*inst credit
reosarevok
yvanzo: the idea is to move the existing uses to instrument guitar as "guitars", and rename "guitars" to something more clearly about the family
Freso
(Unless it already has another credit I assume.)
reosarevok
Any actual existing credits about the family would need to be moved back, but I expect that to be like... 10?
CatQuest
indeed, actually those coudl be shown and not automated
Freso
^
yvanzo
Unless what Freso mentioned.
CatQuest
since these would be contenders for *not* multiple guitars
Freso
The bot could ignore "guitars" that has another inst. credit already, as CatQuest suggested.
CatQuest
honestly there'd be so few i coudl probably go throught thme myself
(though i wouldn't say not to some hlep ;))
Freso
yvanzo: YAY/RAY/NAY?
reosarevok
Yeah I think those credited ones can be done by hand by CatQuest and I at some point :)
CatQuest
reosarevok: 👍
yvanzo
Freso: YAY for selective move.
CatQuest
i know i've myself (shame! but it was a long time ago) added "guitars" credits with real guitars