I noticed a bunch of songs have music videos and I'd want to link them but last time I checked it would have take 20 minutes per video/track lol
2021-07-09 19050, 2021
Cheezmo
You would need to add the "music videos" relationship and create a recording for the music video. Not sure if there is a quick way to do that for a lot of tracks.
2021-07-09 19001, 2021
Rexodys[m]
So creating a recording just for the music video would be the first step, like this?
2021-07-09 19003, 2021
Rexodys[m] uploaded an image: (69KiB) < https://libera.ems.host/_matrix/media/r0/download/matrix.org/HYQYNinoWzDXGzxReijGdfUG/image.png >
2021-07-09 19012, 2021
Cheezmo
Yes, then edit the other recording and add a relationship. Under the "recording" relationships there is one called "music videos" that will you can then link to your new video recording.
Its a little tedious but I'll try to make a couple see if my speed will improve haha
2021-07-09 19023, 2021
Rexodys[m]
I've been posting to IMVDb for 6 months but none of my edits were reviewed yet, kind of useless and a waste of time 😂
2021-07-09 19010, 2021
Cheezmo
One thing that might speed thing up a bit. Copy the link to the audio recording. Then, when you create the video, you can add the relationship in the other direction right there so you don't have to go back and edit the audio one.
2021-07-09 19003, 2021
Cheezmo
Good idea to check that there isn't a video recording already also, but they aren't that common unless they have been released on DVD or something.
2021-07-09 19022, 2021
Rexodys[m]
Ohh so smart 😀 thx!!
2021-07-09 19047, 2021
Rexodys[m]
<Cheezmo "Good idea to check that there is"> yeah that take some times too as there is a lot of relationships for some recordings
2021-07-09 19056, 2021
Rexodys[m]
is there an easy way to check all music video for an artist?
Both have zero votes and closes in 3 days. It's for a concert
2021-07-09 19007, 2021
kepstin
mmirG: please reference https://musicbrainz.org/doc/Data_Removal_Policy - if the artist in question meets one of the conditions described for data removal, you should contact musicbrainz (metabrainz) support to discuss the details of that.
2021-07-09 19032, 2021
mmirG
I'm asking if this is technically available - not for it to be done.
2021-07-09 19034, 2021
Toasty joined the channel
2021-07-09 19041, 2021
Toasty has quit
2021-07-09 19014, 2021
mmirG
"currently technically do-able?" would be more accurate
2021-07-09 19038, 2021
kepstin
that's not generally desirable, and as far as I know there's been no accepted requests made which required such a system to fulfill. so to my knowledge, such a system does not currently exist.
2021-07-09 19004, 2021
death916 has quit
2021-07-09 19048, 2021
mmirG
desirable? in what way? to who? And my question is if it is do-able?
2021-07-09 19019, 2021
kepstin
see the data removal policy document that i sent you a link to
2021-07-09 19029, 2021
kepstin
there's no technical reason such a system couldn't be built, but it would probably require a well-explained use case to do so, and if you think you have such a case you should contact the support email.
2021-07-09 19005, 2021
mmirG
I am asking a question about technical capability. The application of that ability is a differennt question that I'm not asking here.
2021-07-09 19000, 2021
kepstin
there's nothing technically that would prevent such a system from being built.
2021-07-09 19018, 2021
mmirG
Thanks for your help - I will contact via support email.
2021-07-09 19025, 2021
kepstin
as far as i know, it does not currently exist.
2021-07-09 19058, 2021
kepstin
if you just want to know for yourself if an artist with a specific name exists, you can easily do that by periodically querying the musicbrainz search api.
2021-07-09 19029, 2021
mmirG
this is much more a general case thing - in the very few cases where a removal is necesarry then this could be one semi-automatic way to keep it removed
2021-07-09 19009, 2021
Rexodys[m]
Sorry for the picture, but would you assume that this is the same recording?
2021-07-09 19010, 2021
Rexodys[m] uploaded an image: (25KiB) < https://libera.ems.host/_matrix/media/r0/download/matrix.org/OxppxmbbpLHbzVimiGLLdAac/image.png >
yeah, it's very likely (assuming the song doesn't have any e.g radio edits that occasionally get confused)
2021-07-09 19029, 2021
Rexodys[m]
Thx, so I won't get screamed at if I merged those two? I'm 99% sure it's the same lol
2021-07-09 19049, 2021
Rexodys[m]
kepstin: "What, you were expecting me to put something here? Well, I guess I should say hi…" 😂 you got me
2021-07-09 19032, 2021
kepstin
yeah, should be fine. most of the time those pop music compilations end up using the same recording
2021-07-09 19037, 2021
kepstin
just watch out for the case where there's multiple variations of a recording with close length - sometimes it might have a different one than expected
2021-07-09 19030, 2021
crism
kepstin, mmirG: I actually raised a similar question a couple of weeks ago… I’d like to have an alert on an artist name to look for duplicates and missed disambiguation. E.g., I’d like to subscribe to all current *and future* Ian Anderson, Ian Andersen, etc.
2021-07-09 19014, 2021
DragonsChild has quit
2021-07-09 19056, 2021
mmirG has quit
2021-07-09 19024, 2021
Rexodys[m]
Can I put both the music video and the lyric video for a recording? Like so:
2021-07-09 19026, 2021
Rexodys[m] uploaded an image: (73KiB) < https://libera.ems.host/_matrix/media/r0/download/matrix.org/hjQaXXenBhRjjwXgnUPXKoua/image.png >
2021-07-09 19038, 2021
Rexodys[m]
If they are both official of course...
2021-07-09 19016, 2021
mmirG joined the channel
2021-07-09 19037, 2021
mmirG
@crism interesting convergence - same basic process would allow for both uses. I wonder if there are other uses too.
2021-07-09 19055, 2021
mmirG has quit
2021-07-09 19051, 2021
mmirG joined the channel
2021-07-09 19049, 2021
mmirG has quit
2021-07-09 19015, 2021
eroc1990 joined the channel
2021-07-09 19058, 2021
Rexodys[m]
<kepstin "yeah, should be fine. most of th"> While merging I also notice they both share the same AcoustID 😛
