i had an old idea for that actualy. a new work-work relationship: "contains compositional elements from"
2021-12-13 34703, 2021
CatQuest
i had in mind more for popular music than classical, but
2021-12-13 34711, 2021
reosarevok
Yeah - right now all we have is "based on"
2021-12-13 34714, 2021
CatQuest
popular music borrow compositional bits from classical
2021-12-13 34733, 2021
CatQuest
tink only of the many many many that have bits of bethovens 5th for exampke
2021-12-13 34742, 2021
reosarevok
Classical does that from classical very often too :)
2021-12-13 34748, 2021
CatQuest
hah
2021-12-13 34704, 2021
CatQuest
actually that'd be interesting information
2021-12-13 34717, 2021
CatQuest
what do you think of my idea reo?
2021-12-13 34742, 2021
reosarevok
For stuff like "variations on piece X" I've always used "based on", but for stuff like "this contains a brief quotation of Beethoven's Emperor piano concerto" we have nothing rn
2021-12-13 34752, 2021
CatQuest
yea!
2021-12-13 34756, 2021
reosarevok
There's probably a ticket for something like this already, and it probably makes sense
2021-12-13 34713, 2021
reosarevok
We just need to word it clearly so that people won't use it stupidly, but I'm not against the idea
2021-12-13 34728, 2021
CatQuest
I had never made a ticket for "contains compositional elements" (ir "contaisn a brief quotation") becasue my idea was back in the dakr ages of style
2021-12-13 34756, 2021
CatQuest
hench why "compositional elements". I like the "brief quote too"
i think these two songs would use the same relationship, if it existed
2021-12-13 34727, 2021
ttree has quit
2021-12-13 34721, 2021
derwin
what is the difference between a "quotation" and an "interpolation"?
2021-12-13 34708, 2021
CatQuest
well. they're basically the same oncept, I'd say :D
2021-12-13 34717, 2021
CatQuest
concept even
2021-12-13 34747, 2021
zer0bitz joined the channel
2021-12-13 34744, 2021
reosarevok
Releasing prod, forgot to say :)
2021-12-13 34703, 2021
aerozol
Oh yeah, that would do the trick! I guess I assumed this kind of thing would already be used as it seems like something that would be used throughout parts of symphonies etc. But I guess it's probably so 'obvious' that symphony parts would include similar motifs that it's redundant there.
2021-12-13 34740, 2021
aerozol
Not sure about the terminology re. 'quote' but that's what I would use. CatQuest nailed it too
2021-12-13 34727, 2021
aerozol
But this convo is already helpful, I will link this stuff via 'based on' for now. Some of the Halo tracks have little pieces of a few other tracks in there (like 3) but I think it will be fine
2021-12-13 34705, 2021
dogga joined the channel
2021-12-13 34749, 2021
fhe joined the channel
2021-12-13 34721, 2021
dogga has quit
2021-12-13 34748, 2021
antlarr joined the channel
2021-12-13 34717, 2021
antlarr
hi, if an artist releases a song (just a track that is not part of an album) in youtube and bandcamp, should that be added as a single to musicbrainz? or as a standalone recording?
ah, I looked for the track name and found many recordings but not this one. It was a good idea to check the artist first, since it was already in the database
