I see it credited at the release level relatively often
reosarevok
Probably because it wasn't considered super useful - I mean, "this piece was composed while (at my home|staying at hotel X)" doesn't seem a lot more valuable than "in city X"
atj
mainly I see a "written at studio X" in Bandcamp notes
*credit
which is a lot more specific than "in city X"
reosarevok
Huh, ok
Make a ticket? I'm not used to stuff getting written already in the studio, but I guess I'm more used to editing classical - what genres are these? Electronic?
atj
not sure why it's different to the work vs. release written at credit
yeah
reosarevok
Ah, wait, place-release
atj
i mean, I'm not saying it's super common
reosarevok
If there's place-work then it's probably just an oversight tbh
atj
yeah there is
reosarevok
Since I barely ever think of release level writing
Then no need for even a ticket
I'll just add it
atj
i generally follow the "if not specifically credited for every track set at the release level" rule
reosarevok
Well, if it says the whole release was written in place X then that's work level info
atj
sometimes they helpfully say "all tracks written by"
reosarevok
But if you're not sure 🤷♂️
atj
"If you are unsure which tracks a relationship applies to, enter it at release level. A basic effort to determine to which tracks the relationship is applicable is appreciated, but do not guess if you can't figure it out with certainty."
unless i know the artist / label consistently credits in a general way it's difficult to not feel like you're making an assumption
but that's probably just me being weird
reosarevok
Sure. If there's only one place and it says "written at X" it'd be kinda weird if they only credited the one place out of many
But dunno :)
atj
heh, i've just noticed that on the release i added that prompted this the cover art says "all tracks written by / at" :P