<04zoe.division> I remember watching the first one livestreamed while I was holed up in a hotel room, good times
2024-09-21 26513, 2024
scrumplex has quit
2024-09-21 26545, 2024
scrumplex joined the channel
2024-09-21 26501, 2024
adamus1red has quit
2024-09-21 26502, 2024
__DuBPiRaTe__ has quit
2024-09-21 26539, 2024
adamus1red joined the channel
2024-09-21 26535, 2024
JetpackJackson has quit
2024-09-21 26552, 2024
crism joined the channel
2024-09-21 26504, 2024
aerozol[m]
Hey tarulia , you can definitely change all the releases under ‘Horizon Forbidden West’ artist to their actual composers or various artists. It’s a shortcoming of streaming services that releases are (incorrectly) credited like that, which MB handles in series etc
2024-09-21 26516, 2024
Cheezm___ joined the channel
2024-09-21 26536, 2024
Cheezmo_ has quit
2024-09-21 26547, 2024
tarulia[m]1
Done. What happens to the empty "Horizon Forbidden West" artist after the edits go through?
<12lazybookwyrm> It'll be auto-deleted if it has no relationships
2024-09-21 26553, 2024
scrumplex has quit
2024-09-21 26533, 2024
scrumplex joined the channel
2024-09-21 26541, 2024
scrumplex has quit
2024-09-21 26503, 2024
scrumplex joined the channel
2024-09-21 26504, 2024
tatar10 joined the channel
2024-09-21 26556, 2024
JetpackJackson joined the channel
2024-09-21 26558, 2024
everypizza[m] has quit
2024-09-21 26536, 2024
MeatPupp3t2 has quit
2024-09-21 26550, 2024
MeatPupp3t2 joined the channel
2024-09-21 26552, 2024
logistic-bot joined the channel
2024-09-21 26500, 2024
seasharp_ joined the channel
2024-09-21 26526, 2024
seasharp has quit
2024-09-21 26551, 2024
logistic-bot has quit
2024-09-21 26505, 2024
logistic-bot joined the channel
2024-09-21 26504, 2024
trolley has quit
2024-09-21 26513, 2024
trolley joined the channel
2024-09-21 26537, 2024
minimal joined the channel
2024-09-21 26546, 2024
aerozol[m]
tarulia: Nice! I had a minute so I had already deleted the relationships in preparation for your edits. I left some notes on your edits, hopefully not too annoying :D
I guess for that one it would kinda make sense? Just wasn't sure if it would make sense to keep them together since the soundtrack overall is credited to Joris 🤔
2024-09-21 26551, 2024
aerozol[m]
The credits are so evenly split I think it’s pretty clear that it’s VA! It would be appealing in terms of tidiness, keeping all the Horizon soundtracks in one page/artist, but for that you can use a series (example: https://musicbrainz.org/series/c1fca078-0449-48c0…)
2024-09-21 26550, 2024
tarulia[m]1
hm
2024-09-21 26525, 2024
tarulia[m]1
was about to say could also add the Horizon Zero Dawn soundtracks to the series but I wouldn't even know what to call the series then 🤣
2024-09-21 26531, 2024
tarulia[m]1
Guess it could just be Horizon as Wikipedia calls it
2024-09-21 26556, 2024
aerozol[m]
Yeah I think so. Or even both, e.g. Horizon (video game series) + Horizon Zero Dawn (video game)
2024-09-21 26542, 2024
tarulia[m]1
I assume the order in a series is just determined by release date?
2024-09-21 26523, 2024
aerozol[m]
The default one, yeah
2024-09-21 26502, 2024
tarulia[m]1
also wondering if it would make sense instead of using "Various Artists" to use all 4 as release artist? in the game credits they're also all 4 credited as composers
You could def do [artist 1], [artist 2], [artist 3] & [artist 4], but personally 1 track from each composer “feels” VA to me. I’m not sure if there’s a guideline on where to draw the line
2024-09-21 26504, 2024
tarulia[m]1
IDK this might just be personal but IMO VA fits more when the release artist is unrelated to the individual artists/composers
2024-09-21 26515, 2024
aerozol[m]
There’s no guideline that I could find so ¯_(ツ)_/¯
2024-09-21 26529, 2024
aerozol[m]
You can enter the edit how you would prefer it, other editors can feedback if they don’t like it
2024-09-21 26504, 2024
tarulia[m]1
yea
2024-09-21 26525, 2024
bloot joined the channel
2024-09-21 26529, 2024
MeatPupp3t2 has quit
2024-09-21 26559, 2024
MeatPupp3t2 joined the channel
2024-09-21 26501, 2024
MeatPupp3t2 has quit
2024-09-21 26528, 2024
MeatPupp3t2 joined the channel
2024-09-21 26530, 2024
tarulia[m]1
uh nice, it does extract the wikipedia summary when linked 😂 wasn't sure about that
2024-09-21 26523, 2024
tarulia[m]1
OK done 😓... (full message at <https://matrix.chatbrainz.org/_matrix/media/v3/download/chatbrainz.org/qcdKfasytMFrlXDciqeBEnjm>)
2024-09-21 26548, 2024
tarulia[m]1
now if only audio players could actually utilise that data :P
2024-09-21 26505, 2024
aerozol[m]
Nice work!!
2024-09-21 26557, 2024
aerozol[m]
Fun fact: If you use a wikidata link instead of a wikipedia link, MB will use it to serve up a blurb in the users language (if that wiki translation/page is available)
2024-09-21 26515, 2024
tarulia[m]1
mh good to know
2024-09-21 26559, 2024
tarulia[m]1
IDK if it has a WikiData page though.. it should, but I don't see it linked from Wikipedia anywhere
2024-09-21 26530, 2024
aerozol[m]
Oh yeah, it’s kind of tucked away. Let me check.
2024-09-21 26505, 2024
MeatPupp3t2 has quit
2024-09-21 26509, 2024
tarulia[m]1
not really a fan of the new Wikipedia layout lol
2024-09-21 26517, 2024
tarulia[m]1
I liked the old school one that looked like from the 80s
Nice. Yeah I didn’t find it for ages when the layout changed! I like the general new look of Wikipedia though, easier to read imo. But change is always weird
yeah it seems only Apple Music does that (for now)
2024-09-21 26553, 2024
tarulia[m]1
its also a completely different cover though so not sure what the appropriate way to handle that in MB would be
2024-09-21 26553, 2024
aerozol[m]
Different cover = new MB release, but since MB doesn’t have support for adding animated covers (yet?) it seems very silly to make a new release for those
Just to make it clear, the Zoom sessions are (currently) only for the Plenary sessions from 5.30-7.30pm India Standard Time / 12-2pm UTC, right? There are (currently) no Zoom sessions scheduled for outside of these time periods?
2024-09-21 26512, 2024
tarulia[m]1
also apparently I am too dumb to even find the animated version in the chrome dev tools 🤔
2024-09-21 26542, 2024
aerozol[m]
I’ll make a quick edit to the post to clarify, thanks - As I understand it from a brief discussion with Rob today the plan is to have Zoom sessions for the “TBD: Breakouts, Project Plenary, etc” sessions as well. I’m not 100% sure when those links are going to be created and shared
2024-09-21 26501, 2024
tarulia[m]1
tarulia[m]1: yeah.. I'm actually blind, the element is literally called `video-artwork` 🤣
2024-09-21 26512, 2024
discordbrainz
<13zabey> aerozol: new release for each frame of animation? 😉
2024-09-21 26533, 2024
tarulia[m]1
Also I just noticed that the HFW soundtrack is actually credited to all 4 on Apple Music... sssooooo ugh
Yeah I have mixed feelings as well, but wouldn’t lean enough either way to put in a vote (I’m not sure that the guideline mentioned is just talking about what’s on the cover, but chaban is a very experienced editor so I wouldn’t dismiss it)
2024-09-21 26500, 2024
Cheezmo joined the channel
2024-09-21 26534, 2024
Cheezm___ has quit
2024-09-21 26505, 2024
leftmostcatUTC-7 has quit
2024-09-21 26512, 2024
ats has quit
2024-09-21 26531, 2024
tarulia[m]1
well I mean...
2024-09-21 26532, 2024
tarulia[m]1
> Use only writers and performers who are featured on the front cover (or the spine); don't add artists from the back cover or the inside of the booklet or other places.
2024-09-21 26532, 2024
tarulia[m]1
It does kinda of say that but IMO that is just not an ideal guideline to begin with. I get that it's for consistency, but sometimes consistency doesn't make sense
2024-09-21 26516, 2024
tarulia[m]1
There's a difference betweem a VA Album that is basically just a compilation of things and an album where there's just multiple people involved
