if an album is released by Napalm in Austria, then it's released by Soyuz in Russia, and the back cover has the logo of both labels, should it have both labels on the release entry, or just Soyuz?
2024-12-04 33959, 2024
d4rkie joined the channel
2024-12-04 33901, 2024
d4rkie has quit
2024-12-04 33914, 2024
d4rkie joined the channel
2024-12-04 33910, 2024
calcmandan has quit
2024-12-04 33949, 2024
calcmandan joined the channel
2024-12-04 33914, 2024
minimal has quit
2024-12-04 33912, 2024
mikewilzn has left the channel
2024-12-04 33930, 2024
scrumplex has quit
2024-12-04 33948, 2024
scrumplex joined the channel
2024-12-04 33904, 2024
rnkn joined the channel
2024-12-04 33943, 2024
tagomago has quit
2024-12-04 33909, 2024
rnkn has quit
2024-12-04 33933, 2024
hashworks has quit
2024-12-04 33959, 2024
hashworks joined the channel
2024-12-04 33951, 2024
vardhan__ joined the channel
2024-12-04 33903, 2024
vardhan joined the channel
2024-12-04 33900, 2024
vardhan__ has quit
2024-12-04 33923, 2024
rnkn joined the channel
2024-12-04 33942, 2024
vardhan_ joined the channel
2024-12-04 33940, 2024
d4rkie has quit
2024-12-04 33937, 2024
vardhan has quit
2024-12-04 33932, 2024
d4rkie joined the channel
2024-12-04 33949, 2024
rnkn has quit
2024-12-04 33956, 2024
d4rkie has quit
2024-12-04 33905, 2024
d4rkie joined the channel
2024-12-04 33920, 2024
G0d joined the channel
2024-12-04 33951, 2024
tagomago joined the channel
2024-12-04 33923, 2024
anonn joined the channel
2024-12-04 33900, 2024
MRiddickW joined the channel
2024-12-04 33902, 2024
opticdelusion9 joined the channel
2024-12-04 33958, 2024
opticdelusion has quit
2024-12-04 33958, 2024
opticdelusion9 is now known as opticdelusion
2024-12-04 33901, 2024
elomatreb[m]
ivy: The release should have all the labels that are on the cover, and only those (generally)
2024-12-04 33938, 2024
ivy
that makes sense, thanks
2024-12-04 33948, 2024
scrumplex has quit
2024-12-04 33915, 2024
scrumplex joined the channel
2024-12-04 33926, 2024
ivy
i think that means i've been doing this wrongly, although in my defense a lot of these are only added with a single label... at least now i know how to fix them :-)
"Information about pirate releases is allowed if they are not equivalent to an official release: a direct digital rip of an official CD should not be added, but a pirate release including demos or remixes in addition to the content of the official CD release can be." https://musicbrainz.org/doc/Beginners%20Guide
2024-12-04 33930, 2024
reosarevok[m]
It looks like this might not belong in MB anyway in that case
2024-12-04 33902, 2024
elomatreb[m]
in one of the other edits for that label they have a modified cover fwiw
2024-12-04 33909, 2024
elomatreb[m]
with their logo
2024-12-04 33937, 2024
reosarevok[m]
Yeah, they do here too, but that doesn't make it anything else than "a direct digital rip of an official CD" with a watermark imo
2024-12-04 33912, 2024
elomatreb[m]
faiur
2024-12-04 33947, 2024
ivy
reosarevok[m]: my feeling is the release should be in the db, but it should be modified to reflect the official release (with better artwork)? it seems like this release isn't otherwise in the db
2024-12-04 33911, 2024
reosarevok[m]
Well, yeah, agreed that if there's no original yet this could be made into that
2024-12-04 33943, 2024
reosarevok[m]
The Spotify link is anyway the official one already, so there's clearly an official digital version to display
2024-12-04 33937, 2024
antonmosich joined the channel
2024-12-04 33918, 2024
MeatPupp3t21 has quit
2024-12-04 33900, 2024
antonmosich has quit
2024-12-04 33946, 2024
antonmosich joined the channel
2024-12-04 33954, 2024
MeatPupp3t21 joined the channel
2024-12-04 33957, 2024
antonmosich has quit
2024-12-04 33921, 2024
mikewilzn joined the channel
2024-12-04 33958, 2024
antonmosich joined the channel
2024-12-04 33958, 2024
minimal joined the channel
2024-12-04 33948, 2024
LupinIII has quit
2024-12-04 33959, 2024
MonkeyPython joined the channel
2024-12-04 33946, 2024
LupinIII joined the channel
2024-12-04 33911, 2024
ivy
is there a way to look up a disc id by pasting an EAC log into the website? i know Picard can do this, but i don't always have it open
my recollection is that standalone recordings aren't actually very useful so that might not be the best solution, maybe someone else has a better idea
2024-12-04 33955, 2024
ivy
(i don't think Picard can use them for tagging, for example)
2024-12-04 33924, 2024
bwbuhse
Ah hm
2024-12-04 33940, 2024
ivy
i think if i was adding it i'd just make it a digital media, [no label], no barcode... that's basically what it is even if it's not sold in a real music store
2024-12-04 33904, 2024
ivy
this is one i added a while ago that was a single self-published track on the artist's website: https://musicbrainz.org/release-group/31f3a603-d5… - i asked here and the consensus was that it's still a release
2024-12-04 33944, 2024
bwbuhse
Cool, that makes sense. Thanks :)
2024-12-04 33919, 2024
technonerd joined the channel
2024-12-04 33908, 2024
ivy
i might post on the forum about this deezer thing because i really don't like the idea of removing accurate information from the database to appease automated tools
2024-12-04 33931, 2024
MyNetAz has quit
2024-12-04 33937, 2024
outsidecontext[m joined the channel
2024-12-04 33937, 2024
outsidecontext[m
ivi: picard can also tag against just a recording instead of a full release. This works for both real standalone recordings or any recording, especially if you explicitly load it into picard.
