Appreciate you digging into trad stuff at the tune level!
2025-07-24 20525, 2025
vzctr811 has quit
2025-07-24 20506, 2025
glabnob joined the channel
2025-07-24 20508, 2025
Doc_X
crism: When organizing my collection, I want to a) know if tracks are duplicated across releases and b) be able to assemble a track list for each release.
And I'm still not sure why the soundtrack would be listed as a "work" and not a "release".... am I misunderstanding the nature of what that work is representing?
2025-07-24 20542, 2025
Maxr1998 has quit
2025-07-24 20552, 2025
Maxr1998_ joined the channel
2025-07-24 20552, 2025
lusciouslover has quit
2025-07-24 20511, 2025
lusciouslover joined the channel
2025-07-24 20537, 2025
d4rkie has quit
2025-07-24 20514, 2025
d4rkie joined the channel
2025-07-24 20521, 2025
lusciouslover has quit
2025-07-24 20541, 2025
lusciouslover joined the channel
2025-07-24 20502, 2025
wargreen has quit
2025-07-24 20507, 2025
yoshiyosh
RE: My confusion about that "CD1" and "CD2" digital release thing. I made the release group like this: https://musicbrainz.org/release-group/2381001b-ce… , which seemed the most reasonable to me, though I'd appreciate if someone else took a looksie at it
2025-07-24 20515, 2025
wargreen joined the channel
2025-07-24 20538, 2025
Maxr1998_ has quit
2025-07-24 20530, 2025
glabnob
Not an expert by any means but those two releases with the split media for one makes sense to me, given how they’ve presented it on Bandcamp vs Spotify
2025-07-24 20528, 2025
glabnob
the LAEU-001 CDX code in the bandcamp description makes it pretty clear they consider them to be separate discs of the same release, I think
2025-07-24 20502, 2025
anonn joined the channel
2025-07-24 20501, 2025
yoshiyosh
yeah that was my line of reasoning too
2025-07-24 20531, 2025
Maxr1998 joined the channel
2025-07-24 20520, 2025
LainIwakura joined the channel
2025-07-24 20559, 2025
tagomago has quit
2025-07-24 20508, 2025
flamingspinach has quit
2025-07-24 20523, 2025
d4rkie has quit
2025-07-24 20513, 2025
flamingspinach joined the channel
2025-07-24 20519, 2025
d4rkie joined the channel
2025-07-24 20531, 2025
flamingspinach has quit
2025-07-24 20536, 2025
flamingspinach joined the channel
2025-07-24 20544, 2025
LainIwakura has quit
2025-07-24 20541, 2025
LainIwakura joined the channel
2025-07-24 20539, 2025
LainIwakura has quit
2025-07-24 20542, 2025
LainIwakura joined the channel
2025-07-24 20513, 2025
d4rkie has quit
2025-07-24 20559, 2025
d4rkie joined the channel
2025-07-24 20508, 2025
d4rkie has quit
2025-07-24 20555, 2025
d4rkie joined the channel
2025-07-24 20525, 2025
Island joined the channel
2025-07-24 20550, 2025
Techman has quit
2025-07-24 20502, 2025
Techman joined the channel
2025-07-24 20506, 2025
vzctr811 joined the channel
2025-07-24 20537, 2025
crism
Doc_X: There have been multiple releases of the soundtrack. Someone considered the soundtrack as an abstract concept to be sufficiently coherent to merit being its own work, just as a symphony or sonata is, and modeled it accordingly. You can’t listen to a work, only a performance (or recording) of a work.
2025-07-24 20507, 2025
crism
Also, there is exactly one soundtrack-work, while there have been multiple releases. Which release should be “the” soundtrack? Having the work explicit makes that easier.
2025-07-24 20513, 2025
crism
The tracks on those releases, however, are all from releases called “evangelion:1.0 you are (not) alone. original sound track” or something similar, so I’m not sure what information you’re lacking.
