#musicbrainz

/

      • sp1ff joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32646, 2025

      • Toasty has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32626, 2025

      • ansg191 has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32640, 2025

      • ansg191 joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32655, 2025

      • tagomago has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32628, 2025

      • UltraFuzzy has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32609, 2025

      • UltraFuzzy joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32614, 2025

      • Island_ joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32615, 2025

      • Island has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32643, 2025

      • ivoireshi[m] joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32644, 2025

      • ivoireshi[m]
        and/or enshittify it
      • 2025-11-22 32644, 2025

      • ivoireshi[m]
        and/or limit access to the data
      • 2025-11-22 32626, 2025

      • ansg191 has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32644, 2025

      • ansg191 joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32625, 2025

      • Vacuity_ has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32612, 2025

      • Vacuity joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32619, 2025

      • Rawr joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32654, 2025

      • glabnob665589 joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32646, 2025

      • Erin has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32656, 2025

      • Island_ has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32621, 2025

      • ansg191 has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32644, 2025

      • ansg191 joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32632, 2025

      • G0d joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32642, 2025

      • tagomago joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32648, 2025

      • ___nick___ joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32623, 2025

      • lusciouslover has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32626, 2025

      • lusciouslover joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32629, 2025

      • sp1ff` joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32630, 2025

      • sp1ff has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32655, 2025

      • HSOWA has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32616, 2025

      • HSOWA joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32637, 2025

      • Maxr1998_ joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32600, 2025

      • Maxr1998 has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32642, 2025

      • scrumplex_ has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32629, 2025

      • scrumplex joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32625, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[ joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32625, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        I want to add music to musicbrainz
      • 2025-11-22 32634, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        But the artist I want to upload music from has recorded in so many studios😔
      • 2025-11-22 32649, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        And I want to add them, since I have the info available
      • 2025-11-22 32602, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        But I have to create the studios and the recorders/sound engineers etc.
      • 2025-11-22 32605, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        Is it bad if I dont add the studios?👉👈
      • 2025-11-22 32643, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        And add the rest of info laterTM (which might be never)
      • 2025-11-22 32659, 2025

      • MeatPupp3t217 has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32614, 2025

      • MeatPupp3t217 joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32635, 2025

      • notthejohn[m]
        I think that’s more than fine! It’s better for some info to be in the database than none at all, it can always get fleshed out more later whether by your or someone else entirely
      • 2025-11-22 32641, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        True true😊
      • 2025-11-22 32611, 2025

      • i522 joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32611, 2025

      • i522
        tbh i kinda wish there was a "incomplete release" feature where you can mark something as a WIP
      • 2025-11-22 32634, 2025

      • i522
        but keeping artists that are attached to it not GCed. since if you just make artists and not put them on a release, they get deleted after a day
      • 2025-11-22 32606, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        i522: Theres the quality setting I think
      • 2025-11-22 32616, 2025

      • elomatreb[m] joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32616, 2025

      • elomatreb[m]
        you can make them stick around if you add something as simple as a URL to them
      • 2025-11-22 32618, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        Yeah
      • 2025-11-22 32642, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        Or add any relathionship in general I think
      • 2025-11-22 32600, 2025

      • i522
        BlastboomStrice[: mhm
      • 2025-11-22 32627, 2025

      • i522
        use case is for huge albums like 400 tracks long which are an utter pain in the ass to try and tag in 1 go
      • 2025-11-22 32636, 2025

      • i522
        i don't know how you fucking do that
      • 2025-11-22 32655, 2025

      • elomatreb[m]
        yeah a way to save work-in-progress stuff in the editor would be very nice
      • 2025-11-22 32613, 2025

      • elomatreb[m]
        also for the relationship editor, although there you can at least save incomplete stuff to the database
      • 2025-11-22 32646, 2025

      • i522
        i think you can use the tracklist editor (as a text string) to save your work
      • 2025-11-22 32646, 2025

      • i522
        and if you enter a mbid as an artist name it'll be linked automatically? i think?
      • 2025-11-22 32624, 2025

      • elomatreb[m]
        yes, but that also loses quite a lot of detail (such as manually selected artists)
      • 2025-11-22 32634, 2025

      • elomatreb[m]
        or selected recordings
      • 2025-11-22 32604, 2025

      • i522
        but yeah
      • 2025-11-22 32604, 2025

      • i522
        later goop house stuff is so incredibly long and a pain in the ass to tag, so like half of their albums are untagged
      • 2025-11-22 32622, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        Something related:
      • 2025-11-22 32622, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        Can I somehow upload a .json or something to an entity (artist/release etc.) to update or append info on jt?
      • 2025-11-22 32628, 2025

      • i522
        https://soundcloud.com/goophouse and it'd be like. a solid day of work per album to try and track down artists by name
      • 2025-11-22 32635, 2025

      • elomatreb[m]
        no, there is no automated editing support
      • 2025-11-22 32654, 2025

      • elomatreb[m]
        artists should think of the poor metadata editors before making huge releases like that IMO
      • 2025-11-22 32651, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        elomatreb[m]: Oh I might have that script installed then
      • 2025-11-22 32602, 2025

      • mven97132 joined the channel
      • 2025-11-22 32604, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        Like, my thinking is, if I somehow contact the artists and they give me all the metadata, could I somehow automatically add them to musicbrainz?
      • 2025-11-22 32641, 2025

      • mven9713 has quit
      • 2025-11-22 32641, 2025

      • mven97132 is now known as mven9713
      • 2025-11-22 32650, 2025

      • elomatreb[m]
        fully automated editing without human review is against the rules, but you could use the seeding functionality to save a lot of work (similar to how Harmony and other importer tools make adding a release as simple as a couple of clicks)
      • 2025-11-22 32608, 2025

      • BlastboomStrice[
        Yeah Id like to be able to review them first
      • 2025-11-22 32628, 2025

      • elomatreb[m]
        but the key difficulty here is fitting the data into the Musicbrainz schema and terminology (e.g. we are picky about what "EP" means or capitalization)
      • 2025-11-22 32634, 2025

      • anonn joined the channel