This release https://musicbrainz.org/release/56c64053-7b98-43d… has a disambiguation that deals with how it was entered. That seems… inappropriate to me. What do other people think? Presumably created by the tool in question?
2025-12-10 34459, 2025
petitminion joined the channel
2025-12-10 34415, 2025
spynxic has quit
2025-12-10 34442, 2025
spynxic joined the channel
2025-12-10 34401, 2025
Che______
Yeah, @crism that is meaningless and should go away.
What's the best way to find a release based on an ISRC using the Metabrainz API? Look-ups by isrc gives me a recording, but I haven't been able to find a connection between recordings and releases
<elkiensad[m]> Thanks, that was easy! I was trying that out locally using the sample data set, but never got any releases in the responses. Maybe I'm having some issues related to indexing... I had a look at the server code and it seemed to me that the releases relation was not supported for recordings (I must brush up my Perl skills apparently).
2025-12-10 34431, 2025
mll joined the channel
2025-12-10 34431, 2025
mll_ has quit
2025-12-10 34432, 2025
petitminion has quit
2025-12-10 34434, 2025
MeatPupp3t217 has quit
2025-12-10 34455, 2025
MeatPupp3t217 joined the channel
2025-12-10 34418, 2025
tagomago joined the channel
2025-12-10 34455, 2025
vardhan joined the channel
2025-12-10 34413, 2025
vardhan has quit
2025-12-10 34421, 2025
SigHunter has quit
2025-12-10 34419, 2025
SigHunter joined the channel
2025-12-10 34431, 2025
hashworks has left the channel
2025-12-10 34447, 2025
v6lur joined the channel
2025-12-10 34451, 2025
antlarr has quit
2025-12-10 34426, 2025
antlarr joined the channel
2025-12-10 34457, 2025
spynx is now known as spynxic
2025-12-10 34433, 2025
AJ_Z0 has quit
2025-12-10 34458, 2025
AJ_Z0 joined the channel
2025-12-10 34457, 2025
farn__ has quit
2025-12-10 34434, 2025
farn__ joined the channel
2025-12-10 34443, 2025
|G0d| has quit
2025-12-10 34411, 2025
vzctr81191 has quit
2025-12-10 34424, 2025
vzctr811910 joined the channel
2025-12-10 34417, 2025
anomie_[m] joined the channel
2025-12-10 34417, 2025
anomie_[m]
Is it still be being argued whether a YouTube release counts as a release?
2025-12-10 34418, 2025
anomie_[m]
No matter how that's decided, I would still like to be able to somehow see the dates a song was covered when I see the list of recordings on a Work page
2025-12-10 34413, 2025
mll_ joined the channel
2025-12-10 34408, 2025
vzctr8119105 joined the channel
2025-12-10 34449, 2025
frodo has quit
2025-12-10 34400, 2025
029AAFLWW joined the channel
2025-12-10 34400, 2025
mll has quit
2025-12-10 34400, 2025
vzctr811910 has quit
2025-12-10 34400, 2025
vzctr8119105 is now known as vzctr811910
2025-12-10 34412, 2025
tagomago has quit
2025-12-10 34416, 2025
029AAFLWW has quit
2025-12-10 34458, 2025
tagomago joined the channel
2025-12-10 34443, 2025
frodo joined the channel
2025-12-10 34424, 2025
lusciouslover has quit
2025-12-10 34411, 2025
chaban[m] joined the channel
2025-12-10 34412, 2025
chaban[m]
<anomie_[m]> "Is it still be being argued..." <- You'll have to add a date to the [relationship](https://musicbrainz.org/relationshi…. Release dates are a different concept and are not displayed there.
2025-12-10 34440, 2025
anomie_[m]
Oh…
2025-12-10 34434, 2025
Che______ has quit
2025-12-10 34406, 2025
Cheezmo_ joined the channel
2025-12-10 34412, 2025
frodo has quit
2025-12-10 34428, 2025
frodo joined the channel
2025-12-10 34433, 2025
Aerozol[m]1 has quit
2025-12-10 34421, 2025
saturday- joined the channel
2025-12-10 34421, 2025
Cheezmo_ has quit
2025-12-10 34433, 2025
Cheezmo_ joined the channel
2025-12-10 34458, 2025
lazybookwyrm[m] joined the channel
2025-12-10 34458, 2025
lazybookwyrm[m]
But that does mean that even if you don't think a YouTube video qualifies as a release, you can still add it as a standalone recording and set that date in the work relationship
2025-12-10 34418, 2025
anomie_[m]
Yeah, that's good. My main gripe is answered then.
2025-12-10 34436, 2025
anomie_[m]
Now I have a lesser gripe that most editors, including me just yesterday, don't think to enter relationship dates for song covers 😅
2025-12-10 34432, 2025
anomie_[m]
Well, gives me a new thing to do when I want to make some contributions without thinking too much ig
