Realistically, why would a new editor really need to vote? Most new editors don't even understand the voting process. The primary exception is sockpuppets.
2023-05-29 14929, 2023
CatQuest
because we have so many edits autoediting
2023-05-29 14933, 2023
reosarevok
Yes, I was going to say
2023-05-29 14939, 2023
CatQuest
a person cna have several months witouth 10 edits
2023-05-29 14956, 2023
reosarevok
I *like* that you don't have to wait until you get 10 edits, but I was thinking we should at least have some sort of a time limit
2023-05-29 14900, 2023
akshaaatt
lucifer, can you please lead the agenda?
2023-05-29 14904, 2023
CatQuest
yep i agree
2023-05-29 14904, 2023
reosarevok
A day or two seems enough to discourage most sockpuppeting
2023-05-29 14910, 2023
akshaaatt is actually travelling rn
2023-05-29 14911, 2023
yvanzo
š to rdswift
2023-05-29 14914, 2023
CatQuest
mmm..
2023-05-29 14916, 2023
lucifer
akshaaatt: š
2023-05-29 14922, 2023
CatQuest
3 days min i say
2023-05-29 14952, 2023
CatQuest
and then they cna get a "yo ucna now vote" banner popup ting wich links ot hpw vptong wprks?
2023-05-29 14952, 2023
monkey
I'd say a week is already pretty short.
2023-05-29 14952, 2023
reosarevok
Another option would be to keep 2 weeks and drop the 10 edit requirement for "beginner" tbh
2023-05-29 14956, 2023
yvanzo
I donāt think that voting is something any beginner would be able to do.
2023-05-29 14910, 2023
CatQuest
I don't super agree but I think i get it
2023-05-29 14914, 2023
reosarevok
Because you can add a thousand releases, well, without ever getting 10 voted-through edits
2023-05-29 14916, 2023
CatQuest
a week is fine
2023-05-29 14920, 2023
yvanzo
Keeping the usual beginner requirements seem good.
2023-05-29 14935, 2023
rdswift
The time frams should be no less than the time for an edit to go through voting. That should truly discourage sockpuppets.
2023-05-29 14939, 2023
reosarevok
(since those auto-apply)
2023-05-29 14942, 2023
rdswift
*frame*
2023-05-29 14944, 2023
reosarevok
rdswift: that's a fair point :)
2023-05-29 14948, 2023
CatQuest
i do think that once it's made possible to vote, we shoudl put in a link to stuff and a "congrats" or something :P
2023-05-29 14951, 2023
yvanzo
Voting requires a bit of knowledge of the editing process to start with.
2023-05-29 14907, 2023
CatQuest
yea
2023-05-29 14924, 2023
reosarevok
honestly, the other option I could see is make it so *all beginner edits are automatically votable*
2023-05-29 14945, 2023
reosarevok
That'd mean a prolific editor would get 10 edits through before the two weeks are in, and probably cut a lot of auto-added bad stuff
2023-05-29 14945, 2023
yvanzo
that's good too
2023-05-29 14955, 2023
rdswift
Didn't that used to be the case? I'm good with that.
2023-05-29 14904, 2023
CatQuest
mm.. would encourage even more sockpuppets imo
2023-05-29 14912, 2023
jasje
<Yvanzo: I donāt think that voting is something any beginner would be able to do.>
2023-05-29 14914, 2023
reosarevok
CatQuest: doesn't help if they can't vote tho :)
2023-05-29 14921, 2023
jasje
I can confirm first hand
2023-05-29 14946, 2023
CatQuest
well we do the thing that if you f up wou cna autoedit your fix witin 24 hours tho
2023-05-29 14957, 2023
petitminion has quit
2023-05-29 14903, 2023
reosarevok
Ok, thanks for the useful discussion, I got a bunch of good possibilities from here, and the conviction that we should wait a week at least anyway
2023-05-29 14907, 2023
reosarevok
Will think it through from here
2023-05-29 14918, 2023
reosarevok
lucifer cc akshaaatt: profile pics!
2023-05-29 14923, 2023
lucifer
hi all!
2023-05-29 14925, 2023
CatQuest
ara?
2023-05-29 14934, 2023
CatQuest
hmm!
2023-05-29 14912, 2023
lucifer
To improve the UI of the mobile apps, we want to add profile pictures for users. It probably makes sense to make it common across all our projects.
2023-05-29 14925, 2023
reosarevok
So, there was the idea for a long time to use Discourse profile pics on MB
2023-05-29 14928, 2023
lucifer
However, that comes with many issues, especially moderation.
2023-05-29 14933, 2023
CatQuest
yes!
2023-05-29 14940, 2023
reosarevok
I forget if bitmap researched how that'd work
2023-05-29 14943, 2023
mayhem
I like this topic.
2023-05-29 14944, 2023
lucifer
so thoughts on if/how to do it?
2023-05-29 14953, 2023
mayhem
let people select cover art!
2023-05-29 14958, 2023
mayhem
and only cover art
2023-05-29 14959, 2023
CatQuest
I had one idea. what if we allowed peopel to use a coerart of a releae as a profile pic?
2023-05-29 14905, 2023
monkey
I've thought in the past selecting a cover art would be a good solution
2023-05-29 14905, 2023
lucifer
that's one possible way we discussed,
2023-05-29 14907, 2023
CatQuest
HA
2023-05-29 14910, 2023
monkey
^
2023-05-29 14911, 2023
CatQuest
mayhem: ++++
2023-05-29 14916, 2023
mayhem
seems like there is support for this.
2023-05-29 14918, 2023
lucifer
people can choose a cover art from CAA as their profile pic.
2023-05-29 14919, 2023
mayhem
it just makes sense.
2023-05-29 14933, 2023
reosarevok
So
2023-05-29 14936, 2023
CatQuest
wow cool
2023-05-29 14936, 2023
monkey also thinks that could work if we end up with books in CAA
2023-05-29 14938, 2023
lucifer
just one concern, are there chances people will spam CAA due to this?
"Anyone who picks an NSFW pic will be forced to use Rick Astley for a year once we find out"
2023-05-29 14952, 2023
mayhem
DEAL!
2023-05-29 14952, 2023
CatQuest
i mena that's a great solution
2023-05-29 14953, 2023
mayhem
WINNER!
2023-05-29 14954, 2023
monkey
Haha
2023-05-29 14904, 2023
jasje
time to go to fresh releases for my new profile pic
2023-05-29 14909, 2023
CatQuest
:DDD
2023-05-29 14919, 2023
yvanzo
but a SFW Rick Astley then.
2023-05-29 14925, 2023
CatQuest
( Ķ”Ā° ĶŹ Ķ”Ā°)
2023-05-29 14950, 2023
reosarevok
But a SFW Rick Astley is never gonna get yours up
2023-05-29 14957, 2023
mayhem
groan.
2023-05-29 14957, 2023
reosarevok
Ok, I think we're done here :D
2023-05-29 14900, 2023
mayhem
yes
2023-05-29 14904, 2023
CatQuest
i don't want ot get in a situiation where a tasteful or artful nude overart. or a weird one or anime titties is considered "worng" can we jsut say "no genitalia?"
2023-05-29 14908, 2023
reosarevok
Thanks everyone! That's a well filled hour
2023-05-29 14923, 2023
yvanzo
1min left
2023-05-29 14925, 2023
reosarevok
We'll discuss implement-ation details later for the NSFW implements
2023-05-29 14936, 2023
CatQuest
maybe we cna jsut dela with it by case by case
2023-05-29 14940, 2023
reosarevok
</BANG> in a SFW way for now
2023-05-29 14944, 2023
CatQuest
lololol
2023-05-29 14921, 2023
yvanzo
rdswift: Thanks for the added sections about template variables and specific items.
