#musicbrainz

If it was called The Heart (Remix) everywhere, we'd still change it to The Heart (remix) unless it was explicit that they meant for it to be capitalized. That's the whole point of having guidelines. Otherwise, we would just copy everything from platforms, change nothing, and have a horrible mess

There's clearly no consistency, part two for example is "The Heart Pt 2" on https://www.discogs.com/release/12331566-Kendri...

I suspect nobody in either artist's camp gives a shit whether there's a comma or not or it's Pt or Part

And that's how artist intent works - generally, if it's *weird*, it's likely to be intentional - otherwise, it probably isn't

If all of them were something like "The <3 PArT X" or something, I'd maybe believe there's artist intent - here, I don't

[23:13] <crism> It does seem clear that the Drake song should follow the same convention as Kendrick’s. But—it’s not clear whether Kendrick’s tracks show artist intent. That should be the focus here, not Drake.

this

I agree with reosarevok and reo's reasoning here

but I have to say that atj can word himself slightly less abrasive. Techman isn't doing anything wrong or unreosonable, asking questions is fine. if he(?) had said "I don't care about this guideline, iyt's clearly so and such and i'm gonig ot edit it this way! i'd agree that woudl be a bad attitude to hae

but yes. musicbrainz has a guideline for a reason

and it seems lamarr's tracks are not intentionally anything spesific

so thne the comma should be put in