#musicbrainz-devel

These database additions are getting silly :P If they get any more specific we'll be adding databases for individual artist next...

(STYLE-183)

Well, that doesn't look any more genre-based than some of the existing stuff

hmm i guess

it just seems odd to me to be adding databases for small portions of releases

(i don't actually know how small a portion it is though)

but the majority of releases will never use these sites

Sure

Which is why we don't add a relationship for them

The majority of releases will never use creative commons licenses, nor the vacuum cleaner instrument, nor the karaoke relationship

If we had to add only the stuff the majority of releases have, we'd lack half our stuff :D

(I do still see where you're coming from, but still)

(I don't think it's a big problem)

(generally, this stuff is added because someone wants to use it - if nobody was to use the things it wouldn't make sense to add them, but as long as someone does, hey, it's extra data for some stuff)

ok :)

heh

Yeah, adding a whole rel for it would be a bit silly

It got done, at some point

Which is one of the reasons I asked for the other dbs thing :)

on another note, how are you feeling about Audiobook Style as it is now?

I only gave it a quick look since I have never edited audiobooks

So I'm not the best person to say, but well

there doesn't seem to be much interest in it :(

I suspect the main style people and the main audiobook editors just don't intersect much

yeah I suspect that too :P

Hmm

I'd have expected "George R.R. Martin, read by Roy Dotrice"

(with a comma)

But couldn't say *why*

Maybe I'm just too used to the composer; performer division :)

"The Whole Bible Narrated in Hebrew" by Shlomo Bertonov (author unknown, narrator known)

what you mean, author VA surely? :p

Or anon! :p

No, because the original author isn't known

so there we just put the narrator

Hmm

What would you do if the author is anonymous?

(a few Spanish classics which I'm sure have readings are anon)

Just narrator, or anon read by narrator?

then it'd probably be narrator only

but it's only for cases where the author is truly unknown by anyone

Hmm ok. I'll ask in style anyway - maybe someone will have an opinion and in any case it'll remind people it's there

"by a join phrase such as" includes other language versions of it I assume?

yeah

it's whatever it is on the release

Cool

Yeah, ok

the idea behind the narrator thing is: the narrator has just gone "oh, I'll read this anonymously written book", which sort of makes it more of the narrator's release than the author's

heh works for books

Makes sense though, yeah

yeah I expect that'll be expanded on if/when hawke passes some/all of his list :)

(book works)

We scared him away!

that's exactly what I thought :D

Hmm

I think I'll post on the forums

Maybe there's some audiobook fan there :p

haha there must be at least one somewhere :)

Posted

thanks reo :D

perhaps if an artist is actually credited as anonymous, we should use that

and leave the current case for where no artist is credited

Unsure - that's why I brought it up! :)

haha don't worry I was mostly talking to myself ;)

Oops 3AM

Ok, I think it's a nice moment to call it a day!

Night!

blip, seemsi missed another devmeet

well i painted the room so

hello!

hello!

i chose roald dahl

choose, chose?

to choose, i chose yesterday

idunnno

anyway

hello

Chose is the proper past tense. :)

\o/

Good morning

hi!

Hellocharles! :D

You really did that?

Ok, you have no right to complain about my bad jokes anymore :p

reosarevok: I have to do something to top you, y'know.

Hmm

Fair enough

the word was firstest

reosarevok: http://chatlogs.musicbrainz.org/musicbrainz-dev...

oh god

lol

You're all terrible

Time to fix critical regressions

Please! :)

urgh, I know exactly what the problem with MBS-5788 is

As in, I knew it when I was reviewing, but forgot to leave the comment :(

Well, that should be a simple fix then! :p

It is, yea

\o/

Project libmusicbrainz build #25: SUCCESS in 21 sec: http://ci.musicbrainz.org/job/libmusicbrainz/25/

warp: review on https://github.com/metabrainz/musicbrainz-serve... please

ocharles: Is that MBS-5791 too?

Freso: yea

and a few bugs that weren't even reported yet

Ah, I see you've already assigned yourself to that. :)

Yet. :p

ocharles: ship it!

warp: ok, wanna drive servers?

sure

lets just wait for ci to be happy

ok

:)

enjoying it?

it just started, but enjoying it so far, yes.

Hah. So you closed just before I submitted my comment. Great. :p

Freso: GitHub closed it :P

warp: grmbl. I can't find the LP in FLAC

ocharles: Well, you pushed it. :)

Boomkat only has the EP

ocharles: there is a CD version with 14 tracks and the iTunes version has 19 tracks.

I haven't searched further

Oh, I bet Beatport has a massively overpriced FLAC

haha

I think that iTunes version is exclusive :/

What format do you have it in?