#musicbrainz

/

      • brianfrud_ joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15219, 2010

      • outsidecontext joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15243, 2010

      • outsidecontext joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15221, 2010

      • brianfrud_ joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15240, 2010

      • Leftmost joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15251, 2010

      • zazi joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15209, 2010

      • danbri_ joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15258, 2010

      • Milosz_ joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15231, 2010

      • Jormangeud joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15245, 2010

      • czaja joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15247, 2010

      • Milosz joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15254, 2010

      • danbri joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15218, 2010

      • aCiD2 joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15213, 2010

      • mr_maxis joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15249, 2010

      • brianfrud_ joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15250, 2010

      • mr_maxis joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15206, 2010

      • Leftmost joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15256, 2010

      • brianfrud_ joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15239, 2010

      • outsidecontext joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15230, 2010

      • hawke_ joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15244, 2010

      • xlotlu_ joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15229, 2010

      • DarkerAudit joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15243, 2010

      • kurros joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15233, 2010

      • ruaok joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15207, 2010

      • aCiD2
        Eating fish for breakfast was the worst idea ever
      • 2010-06-01 15223, 2010

      • aCiD2
        all i've been able to smell and taste since this morning has been mackerel :(
      • 2010-06-01 15232, 2010

      • nikki wonders why you would eat fish for breakfast
      • 2010-06-01 15202, 2010

      • hawke_ wonders why you would eat fish.
      • 2010-06-01 15240, 2010

      • navap wonders why you would eat
      • 2010-06-01 15251, 2010

      • nikki wonders...
      • 2010-06-01 15259, 2010

      • navap
        * navap
      • 2010-06-01 15257, 2010

      • Leftmost
        I went to a friend's house for fish tacos a week or so ago. They were delicious, but I couldn't smell anything but fried fish for a couple of days.
      • 2010-06-01 15204, 2010

      • aCiD2
        well, I like fish, and I had some mackerel to eat
      • 2010-06-01 15209, 2010

      • aCiD2
        so I thought fish for breakfast!
      • 2010-06-01 15230, 2010

      • aCiD2
        I'm mostly worried about the gym, because I sweat like crazy now any way that we're on heavy weights, and I think fishy sweat is going to be even worse
      • 2010-06-01 15243, 2010

      • aCiD2
        mwahaha
      • 2010-06-01 15232, 2010

      • Leftmost
        I wish my university didn't charge extra for summer gym access.
      • 2010-06-01 15207, 2010

      • aCiD2
        it's cost me about 50 quid for 10 weeks
      • 2010-06-01 15226, 2010

      • aCiD2
        which is alright. it's not a brilliant gym, but all I need is plates, a squat rack, a bench and barbells
      • 2010-06-01 15243, 2010

      • aCiD2
        i sure would be tempted to pay extra for a place with some air conditioning though...
      • 2010-06-01 15210, 2010

      • Leftmost
        The summer here is around $30, I think. Which is better than any other gym I'd find, and it's well-equipped. But I'm poor.
      • 2010-06-01 15222, 2010

      • Leftmost
        And I don't think they'll let me pay it with financial aid.
      • 2010-06-01 15241, 2010

      • Kanmu joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15205, 2010

      • aCiD2
        ah
      • 2010-06-01 15234, 2010

      • fatih joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15215, 2010

      • Mineo
        sorry to disturb your talk but: is there any way, if an album has different ASINs in different countries, to choose a specific one for the cover art retrieval?
      • 2010-06-01 15254, 2010

      • hawke_
        Mineo: Nope.
      • 2010-06-01 15207, 2010

      • Mineo
        :(
      • 2010-06-01 15213, 2010

      • hawke_
        Maybe once NGS comes out, I’m not sure
      • 2010-06-01 15233, 2010

      • aCiD2
        nope, NGS doesn't really change that (it just uses one of them)
      • 2010-06-01 15253, 2010

      • aCiD2
        ok, I'm off - Leftmost i'll try and get back to meet tonight, I might be a little late because I have to help some guy with some PHP
      • 2010-06-01 15255, 2010

      • aCiD2 shudders
      • 2010-06-01 15213, 2010

      • Leftmost
        No worries.
      • 2010-06-01 15217, 2010

      • Leftmost comforts aCiD2.
      • 2010-06-01 15231, 2010

      • hawke_
        Doesn’t NGS do some stuff with associating things with actual releases (e.g. disc IDs and corresponding release events)?
      • 2010-06-01 15250, 2010

      • hawke_
        I would’ve thought that if it did that, it would also connect ASINs to those release events.
      • 2010-06-01 15207, 2010

      • Mineo
        well, that's unfortunate
      • 2010-06-01 15226, 2010

      • hawke_
        I agree.
      • 2010-06-01 15232, 2010

      • hawke_
        Speaking of NGS: On the NGS beta, how do you go about setting a release’s format?
      • 2010-06-01 15208, 2010

      • navap
        Since a release can now consist of several mediums you can't set a *release* format, only a medium format.
      • 2010-06-01 15243, 2010

      • hawke_
        Fair enough...where do you do that? I would expect it to be in the same place as packaging...
      • 2010-06-01 15255, 2010

      • navap
        The stuff in the sidebar is release specific information, it applies to the entire release - the format(s) do not. They're found on the tracklist tab of the release editor.
      • 2010-06-01 15203, 2010

      • navap
        er s/sidebar/first tab/
      • 2010-06-01 15205, 2010

      • navap
        haha
      • 2010-06-01 15220, 2010

      • hawke_
        Also, I see that you can’t apparently change the release(?) type; the dropdown says album, and is disabled.
      • 2010-06-01 15226, 2010

      • hawke_
        Is there a way to do that?
      • 2010-06-01 15251, 2010

      • navap
        If you're editing a release then the release type is taken from the release group the release is in. 
      • 2010-06-01 15207, 2010

      • navap
        A release doesn't have a "type" anymore, that's only at the release group level.
      • 2010-06-01 15227, 2010

      • hawke_
        Aha.
      • 2010-06-01 15242, 2010

      • hawke_
        Then why’s it displayed on the release editor. :-p
      • 2010-06-01 15213, 2010

      • navap
        Let me ask you this: If it wasn't displayed, wouldn't you have wondered where it was?
      • 2010-06-01 15233, 2010

      • hawke_
        Well, I would have looked for it somewhere else...
      • 2010-06-01 15237, 2010

      • hawke_
        or asked.
      • 2010-06-01 15218, 2010

      • hawke_
        But putting it on the release editor raises the question for all: “this is obviously where I’m supposed to be editing the type [since it has a widget there], now why is it disabled?”
      • 2010-06-01 15236, 2010

      • hawke_
        Instead of “where do I go to edit the album type?”
      • 2010-06-01 15248, 2010

      • hawke_
        Which at least gives me the idea that I need to search more.
      • 2010-06-01 15254, 2010

      • navap
        I think that question will be answered once we stick in the appropriate documentation in the right side of the first tab.
      • 2010-06-01 15205, 2010

      • hawke_
        Perhaps.
      • 2010-06-01 15200, 2010

      • navap
        It's a good observation though, maybe the type doesn't need to be shown at all in the release editor.
      • 2010-06-01 15227, 2010

      • hawke_
        How about the format selection being on the tracklist tab? Shouldn’t it and packaging go together?
      • 2010-06-01 15252, 2010

      • navap
        Although then the editor wouldn't be 100% consistent because the type needs to be asked when adding a new release outside of an existing release group.
      • 2010-06-01 15222, 2010

      • navap
        When you buy a two disc album, does each disc come in different packaging?
      • 2010-06-01 15208, 2010

      • navap
        Actually I'm not too sure how packaging will work with a release that has different medium formats.
      • 2010-06-01 15222, 2010

      • navap
        A CD+Vinyl release probably can't be classified as having just one type of packaging.
      • 2010-06-01 15223, 2010

      • nikki
        the packaging stuff is pretty basic anyway, it's not like you can say something came in a normal jewel case with a bonus disc in a slim jewel case in a cardboard thingy to keep the discs together
      • 2010-06-01 15241, 2010

      • nikki
        http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/Next_Generation_Schem… <- but this is all we've got at the moment
      • 2010-06-01 15238, 2010

      • pronik` joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15220, 2010

      • hawke_
        I’m a bit surprised that the “advanced” track editor isn’t the default...
      • 2010-06-01 15246, 2010

      • hawke_
        given that the “basic” one seems to be a free-form text editor.
      • 2010-06-01 15202, 2010

      • nikki
        people think tables are too databasey :(
      • 2010-06-01 15242, 2010

      • hawke_
        I think free-form text editors are too pain-in-the-ass-and-you-have-to-guess-what-the-format-is-ey.
      • 2010-06-01 15222, 2010

      • Leftmost
        nikki, they're wrong then.
      • 2010-06-01 15249, 2010

      • nikki
        Leftmost: I never said they were right :P
      • 2010-06-01 15252, 2010

      • Leftmost
        We're a database, oddly enough.
      • 2010-06-01 15200, 2010

      • nikki idly ponders if it's just her that cares about the size of the packaging rather than just the style...
      • 2010-06-01 15219, 2010

      • hawke_
        nikki: ??
      • 2010-06-01 15234, 2010

      • nikki
        I was just looking at that wiki page I linked and was thinking about the different ones I have
      • 2010-06-01 15249, 2010

      • hawke_
        There’re some problems with the basic text editor, too...
      • 2010-06-01 15256, 2010

      • nikki
        and I've got loads which would come under digipak I think, but they're all sorts of sizes
      • 2010-06-01 15204, 2010

      • navap images disputes about whether to record measurements in inches or centimetres.
      • 2010-06-01 15243, 2010

      • Leftmost
        navap, allow either, store as cm internally, display by user preference.:)
      • 2010-06-01 15259, 2010

      • ruaok heads to the office
      • 2010-06-01 15211, 2010

      • nikki
        I wasn't thinking about being that specific :P
      • 2010-06-01 15238, 2010

      • Leftmost
        Feet is a bit large of a measurement for that.:P
      • 2010-06-01 15205, 2010

      • nikki
        I just mean that I've got cd sized ones, dvd sized ones, those weird thin tall japanese 8cm cd ones and a few which are bigger than dvds and a right pain in the arse to put anywhere
      • 2010-06-01 15207, 2010

      • nikki
        haha
      • 2010-06-01 15212, 2010

      • hawke_
        it seems to be impossible to set a track to unknown length after you’ve set it to a known length.
      • 2010-06-01 15237, 2010

      • Leftmost
        DVD-sized digipaks?
      • 2010-06-01 15248, 2010

      • nikki
        assuming I know what a digipak is :P
      • 2010-06-01 15254, 2010

      • hawke_
        (In the basic text editor)
      • 2010-06-01 15208, 2010

      • nikki smells food
      • 2010-06-01 15209, 2010

      • Leftmost
        I guess I have DVDs that come in digipak-y containers.
      • 2010-06-01 15212, 2010

      • nikki
        back in a bit
      • 2010-06-01 15220, 2010

      • Leftmost
        Hmm. So when do we create MovieBrainz?:P
      • 2010-06-01 15227, 2010

      • Leftmost
        And BookBrainz.
      • 2010-06-01 15236, 2010

      • hawke_
        Make moviebrainz first. :-p
      • 2010-06-01 15245, 2010

      • Leftmost
        I care more about books myself.
      • 2010-06-01 15211, 2010

      • hawke_
        Yeah, but movies (and DVDs) are much closer to music (and CDs) than books.
      • 2010-06-01 15228, 2010

      • hawke_
        Is there a way to delete a disc (medium) in the NGS beta?
      • 2010-06-01 15218, 2010

      • hawke_
        The freaking text editor keeps on setting the length of tracks other than the one with which I’m working, in addition to the one with which I’m working.
      • 2010-06-01 15225, 2010

      • Leftmost
        In what way are they closer?
      • 2010-06-01 15255, 2010

      • Leftmost
        Form factor?
      • 2010-06-01 15238, 2010

      • hawke_
        Books in digital form are much less standardized....
      • 2010-06-01 15251, 2010

      • hawke_
        In printed form, they tend to have a lot more printings and editions.
      • 2010-06-01 15235, 2010

      • Leftmost
        I don't see how that makes movies any more suitable for databasification, though.
      • 2010-06-01 15245, 2010

      • Leftmost
        And also word coinerosity.
      • 2010-06-01 15216, 2010

      • hawke_
        I think the MB schema could be adapted to movies much more easily than to books.
      • 2010-06-01 15217, 2010

      • hawke_
        That’s all.
      • 2010-06-01 15216, 2010

      • Leftmost
        I'm sure that for either movies or books you'd want to create a custom-suited schema, rather than trying to adapt one.
      • 2010-06-01 15206, 2010

      • hawke_
        Well...if that’s the case then it’s already done: See imdb, goodreads, etc.
      • 2010-06-01 15223, 2010

      • Leftmost
        Neither have open data. Open Library does, I think, but I haven't tried their new setup and their old one was kind of terrible.
      • 2010-06-01 15224, 2010

      • pronik`` joined the channel
      • 2010-06-01 15225, 2010

      • hawke_
        Open in what sense? Open to editing, or providing APIs to retrieve their data?
      • 2010-06-01 15246, 2010

      • Leftmost
        Licensing and retrieval. IMDB isn't really editable and goodreads just bottles up their data.
      • 2010-06-01 15210, 2010

      • hawke_
        No, I know imdb isn’t editable; I agree with that one.
      • 2010-06-01 15234, 2010

      • hawke_
        imdb isn’t open in any sense.
      • 2010-06-01 15201, 2010

      • Muz
        I'm sure they used to do data dumps
      • 2010-06-01 15208, 2010

      • Muz
        And imdb is editable if you sign up and pay iirc.
      • 2010-06-01 15248, 2010

      • nikki reappears
      • 2010-06-01 15249, 2010

      • hawke_
        Is there anywhere official that I should be reporting problems that I find with the NGS test?
      • 2010-06-01 15210, 2010

      • nikki
        jira I guess, for release editor stuff you might want to ping warp first
      • 2010-06-01 15236, 2010

      • hawke_
        Alright.
      • 2010-06-01 15208, 2010

      • hawke_
        I’ll talk to warp then, when I get a chance.
      • 2010-06-01 15200, 2010

      • hawke_
        Anyone know what “Enable vinyl track numbers” does?
      • 2010-06-01 15204, 2010

      • navap
        Maybe it will parse the letter out of track numbers like: a1, a2, a3, b1, b2, b3
      • 2010-06-01 15226, 2010

      • hawke_
        navap: Maybe. I can’t see that it’s doing anything now.
      • 2010-06-01 15243, 2010

      • hawke_
        The track numbers seem to be totally ignored in the basic editor.
      • 2010-06-01 15244, 2010

      • navap
        The editor on test is not finished. It's still got plenty of missing features.
      • 2010-06-01 15230, 2010

      • navap
        The track parser options look like they were taken from the options available on the current server.
      • 2010-06-01 15202, 2010

      • hawke_
        You can put pretty much anything (e.g: “testnum testname” will appear as “1. testname” in the preview.