#musicbrainz

Well, "important" :)

It's our standard anyway

sorry, didn't get it

put a dot after the letter on each track? or just on that case because the name is repeated?

After the movement numbers

(or in this case, movement number and part letter)

So, movement 1 of symphony N would be "Symphony no. N: I. Whatever"

In this case, it is a movement in several parts, so it's Ia. Whatever, Ib. Whatever, etc

1. Symphony no. 7: Ia. Langsam (Adagio) 2. Symphony no. 7: Ib. Nicht schleppen 3. Symphony no. 7: Ic. Allegro risoluto, ma non troppo 4. Symphony no. 7: Id. A tempo (sempre l'istesso) like this right?

Yep

;) thanks

oh forgot to change to cd. now if I add another edit just with that without changing the tracks again, will it work? or have to change again the tracks and cancel the other edit?

Yeah, should work I think

Anyway, I've approved them since I want to do two small corrections (of mistakes that were there from the beginning but I just noticed)

:) thanks. already added cd

another doubt: "6ième mouvement" or "6ième Mouvement" ?

pffft

No idea

I suck at French caps

You could always do VI. and forget the problems! :p

http://www.discogs.com/Clearlight-Symphony-II/r... http://musicbrainz.org/release/a27a7461-536c-42...

it's for this one

Oh

Dunno

Just leave it like it is

(lowercased I mean)

If some French person wants to change it they can

ok

http://musicbrainz.org/release/f47fca4a-c64e-47... and http://www.allmusic.com/album/beethoven-symphon...

sorry, trying to get used to classical ;)

Symphony No. 6 in F major ("Pastoral"), Op. 68: 1. Allegro ma non troppo / Symphony No. 6 in F major ("Pastoral"), Op. 68: 2. Andante molto moto

and the same until track 5

and then Symphony No. 5 in C minor ("Fate"), Op. 67: 1. Allegro con brio / Symphony No. 5 in C minor ("Fate"), Op. 67: 2. Andante con moto

I. is better than 1. and we traditionally put "Pastoral" after Op. 68

Although I'm not sure if that's a guideline anymore

Not a guideline at the moment, just tradition

you would change it to "Symphony No. 6 in F major, Op. 68, Pastoral: I. Allegro ma non troppo"

' Op. 68 "Pastoral" ' with no comma and quote marks

And again, I guess new guidelines do say op. and no. in lowercase

(still getting used to that one...)

ok

and what about the artist credits?

and the conductor and all

huh

Not too sure what to do with the Music Director one

But the release and release group artist should probably be "Ludwig van Beethoven; Tafelmusik Orchestra, Bruno Weil"

(and the track artist should be just Beethoven)

ok

And then just add the orchestra and conductor relationships to all recordings

Oh, "andante con mot" should be "moto" not "mot"

So fix that while you're at it :)

thanks ;)

already corrected the rest

and regarding this http://musicbrainz.org/release/76684441-0c58-41... http://www.discogs.com/Tschaikowsky-Berliner-Ph...

discogs has Symphonie Nr. 2 C-Moll Op. 17 »Kleinrussische«

That's probably good enough

Nr. instead of no.?

yeah, no. - that's what's on the cover

Symphonie Nr. 2 C-Moll Op. 17 »Kleinrussische« - don't get the c-moll

yeah, no. - that's what's on the cover

fuck my antivirus and its attempt to restart the OS

Symphonie Nr. 2 C-Moll Op. 17 »Kleinrussische« - don't get the c-moll

Nr. is correct German and C-Moll (or c-Moll, can never remember) is "C minor" in German

http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=1395590 but on the cover there's No.2

well, the problem is that this release has 3 languages on the cover

so you have to decide which language to use as the primary one in MB

reosarevok: what do you think?

I mean, I'm not comfortable on giving opinion on this

well, the three languages that are present are just translating Kleinrussische right?

german comes first on that

but regarding symphonie no. 2 there is no german there

Sorry, I had to go pick up 2 boxes of 5kgs of strawberries :D

I would probably just go full German

But it wouldn't be "wrong" to keep no. I guess

"Symphonie Nr. 2 C-Moll Op. 17 »Kleinrussische«: I. Andante Sostenuto - Allegro Vivo"

for the tracks

since it's german, leave "Nr." or "nr." ?

and for the release title.. it is "Symphonie No. 2 »Kleinrussische • Little Russian • Petite Russie« • 1812 - Ouvertüre (Berliner Philharmoniker feat. conductor: Herbert von Karajan)"

Berliner Philharmoniker + Herbert von Karajan go to the artist credits and do I leave the rest like it is? or "Symphonie Nr. 2 C-Moll Op. 17 »Kleinrussische« / Ouverture Solennelle »1812« Op. 49" ?

Nr., but "sostenuto" and "vivo" (since that part's Italian)

And the rest, like your second example I'd say

ok

thanks~

What's the difference between the single and the song just posted on the artist website? He can do it every day. Is it all singles? I don't think so. How can I move a single to standalone recording?

if it's a single, there's already a recording

You remove the release

you can just delete the release

If there's a download/stream link or something, you can also link the recording to that URL, always nice

If I remove a release the recordings remain?

yes

thanks

They're only removed if the original add edit fails or is canceled

(and I think they stay even in that case, if they have relationships)

If someone's credites as "technician" on a recording... == engineer?

*credited

I guess so

Didn't we use to have a technician AR?

ocharles has changed the topic to: MusicBrainz.org | Developers: #musicbrainz-devel | Latest Release: 2012-07-09 - http://blog.musicbrainz.org/?p=1481 | IRC Log: http://chatlogs.musicbrainz.org | http://scheduling.ocharles.org.uk/ is back! | New Soundtrack Style is OFFICIAL!

i wonder why http://i18n.mbsandbox.org/ keeps showing up in german, when my browser's locale is set to estonian...

ianmcorvidae ^ when you're around

v6lur: Is the languages set to Estonian as well? (Ie., not the language of the browser, but the languages the browser requests.)

Freso: yes, that's what i meant

(although the browser itself -- the whole system locale, even -- is set to estonian, too)

v6lur or Freso: do you know how No. is in Norwegian?

reosarevok: "No." as in number?

Yes

CatCat: ^

It's "nr." in Danish.

I didn't ask him because I thought he's not around - if you're around, do say, CatCat :)

It might be same in Norwegian. CatCat would know.

reosarevok: iirc it's "nr."

Since when is #mb-devel more active than #mb?

could music video releases be added?

Sure

and it's meeting day

when people have problems to solve :P

Could I get these merged so I can then merge the recordings which are duplicated in other releases? :) http://musicbrainz.org/edit/18293293

I love how it claims to be the suite, but is not

It's just taken from a full recording of Peer Gynt with choirs and everything

(and the same for the Sigurd Jorsalfar which isn't the orchestral suite, but bits of the full recording)

The DG site is now more honest about it

But the original release clearly wasn't http://www.discogs.com/release/3104578

demosdemon: I'm adding a small bunch of music videos from YouTube.

s/demosdemon/derr84

Third vote on http://musicbrainz.org/edit/18293293 please? 8)