JonnyJD: it seems to me that you want to work with a stack of patches, rather than a graph of revisions. that's fine, but I'd say that's not the usual dvcs workflow
2013-02-26 05746, 2013
JonnyJD
but I take it as "I shouldn't rebase that often" even if it is only feature branches
2013-02-26 05711, 2013
luks
in fact that's the workflow used mostly in svn
2013-02-26 05727, 2013
luks
where you don't see inside the merged feature branches, so you get just one commit per feature
2013-02-26 05713, 2013
JonnyJD
luks: lets just say I have quite a rapid development approach to feature branches. On my local machine I rebase frequently (one feature only, not multiple things)
2013-02-26 05706, 2013
johtso
When a release consists of separate tracks, and then a continuous mix track, the continuous mix track should be the DJ who mixed it right?
2013-02-26 05736, 2013
JonnyJD
So when most people wouldn't even commit locally. I already commit prototypes and sometimes push them to feature branches for others to see.
2013-02-26 05720, 2013
luks
johtso: not necessarily, but usually yes
2013-02-26 05748, 2013
JonnyJD
But I probably should rebase at least less for feature branches I pushed.
2013-02-26 05731, 2013
JonnyJD
Thanks for the feedback luks.
2013-02-26 05741, 2013
warp never rebases.
2013-02-26 05711, 2013
luks
I can't change your opinion, but for projects that I work on, open source and proprietary, we never throw away any commits
2013-02-26 05733, 2013
luks
and I often found it useful to be able to go back to the broken versions in between
2013-02-26 05736, 2013
JonnyJD
Well, for big changes I create a new branch on git and rebase that. So for the feature_list api on libdiscid I alredy have created like 10 branches with possible solutions.
Leftmost: imager/ directory has the important stuff, mostly C++, scanner/ has all the scripty stuff that would be in the picard plugin, if there was one :P
2013-02-26 05708, 2013
Leftmost
What's the general structure? Using the client, will it submit to your database, or can I create my own?
2013-02-26 05757, 2013
Ben\Sput
the C code take an audio file as a parameter, and extracts the data and computes the image, then outputs it on stdout
2013-02-26 05709, 2013
johtso
is a "vocal remake" the equivalent of a remix for the purposes of relationships?
2013-02-26 05716, 2013
Ben\Sput
you'd then read the output, and submit it to the database using the /submit/ url endpoint
2013-02-26 05718, 2013
johtso
and does anyone know what a vocal remake is? :)
2013-02-26 05745, 2013
Ben\Sput
Leftmost: that's what the python "scanner" does
2013-02-26 05750, 2013
Ben\Sput
so, if you wanted to make your own, you'd take the C application, and write your own submission script for it, which supplies the server with the necessary info
2013-02-26 05754, 2013
Ben\Sput
*C++
2013-02-26 05732, 2013
hawke_1
johtso: haven’t a clue.
2013-02-26 05705, 2013
Leftmost
Freso, ping
2013-02-26 05717, 2013
reosarevok
johtso: I think it's a remix where the vocal line is given extra importance, but yeah, it's not the clearest thing...
2013-02-26 05721, 2013
johtso
reosarevok, makes sense. Found another recording that had the person as a remixer, so seems like the way to go
2013-02-26 05751, 2013
johtso
seems a little strange that you could mark a remixer as "additional"
Is there any way to tell if Picard has submitted acoustID fingerprints successfully?
2013-02-26 05701, 2013
Ben\Sput
johtso: it should say so in the bottom left
2013-02-26 05726, 2013
hawke_1
johtso: also you can check if the recordings you submitted them to now have acoustids.
2013-02-26 05757, 2013
Freso
Leftmost: pong!
2013-02-26 05744, 2013
johtso
Aha, I need to explicitly "scan" them right?
2013-02-26 05751, 2013
Ben\Sput
johtso: yup
2013-02-26 05700, 2013
Ben\Sput
johtso: I didn't work that out for months :P
2013-02-26 05700, 2013
johtso
and if looks up the fingerprint it's also submitting it?
2013-02-26 05713, 2013
johtso
*if it
2013-02-26 05716, 2013
Freso
JonnyJD: I don't mess with hg. And I'm not really a Bitbucket guy. I like the culture around GitHub far better than the one surrounding BB. But, unfortunately, BB's just got some thing More Right(tm) than GH. :/
2013-02-26 05717, 2013
Ben\Sput
johtso: not so far as I know, you need to actually submit them for it to submit
2013-02-26 05750, 2013
JonnyJD
Freso: thanks.
2013-02-26 05702, 2013
johtso
Ben\Sput, how would I do that?
2013-02-26 05721, 2013
Ben\Sput
johtso: there should be a submit button at the top
2013-02-26 05728, 2013
Ben\Sput
next to save iirc
2013-02-26 05751, 2013
Ben\Sput
yeah, in betweeen "Save" and "CD Lookup"
2013-02-26 05704, 2013
johtso
Ben\Sput, aha, it's greyed out, which I assume means they're already in the DB?
2013-02-26 05724, 2013
Ben\Sput
johtso: yes, if you've scanned them and dragged them to a release in the right hand side pane
2013-02-26 05733, 2013
johtso
Or does it only work if it's from a physical CD?
2013-02-26 05750, 2013
Ben\Sput
johtso: it should work for any audio
2013-02-26 05702, 2013
johtso
wait.. you can open a CD in picard, what am I talking about :D
2013-02-26 05704, 2013
Ben\Sput
johtso: although it doesn't really make sense if it's not from digital sources
luks: As late as yseterday night, a branch was branched off from the wrong parent branch. Of course, the commits could have been exported and re-applied to the proper branch - but it was easier and quicker to simply rebase the new branch on top of what was supposed to have been its parent branch.
2013-02-26 05707, 2013
Freso
Leftmost: I'm guessing it is.
2013-02-26 05725, 2013
Freso
Leftmost: Remind me in the morrow, and I'll give my recording a listen and compare.
2013-02-26 05713, 2013
mr_maxis
hawke_1: I think I explained enough in the first edit, you seem so sure of yourself, I give up, congrats.
2013-02-26 05749, 2013
Freso
Leftmost: But Anne-Marie of Prisme is a harpist, FWIW.
2013-02-26 05712, 2013
hawke_1
mr_maxis: yeah, but the voting in the first edit pretty much covered that whole thing, the second edit didn’t justify the revert at all.
2013-02-26 05737, 2013
Leftmost
Nor did it link to the earlier discussion.
2013-02-26 05741, 2013
mr_maxis
hawke_1: in your opinion
2013-02-26 05752, 2013
hawke_1
mr_maxis: you think the picture link was self-explanatory?
2013-02-26 05725, 2013
Leftmost
At least one editor who voted yes was unaware of the previous discussion.
2013-02-26 05753, 2013
Leftmost
Freso, well, the harp is a convenient video. There's a recording "Song of the Kelpie" on a Solas album, wanted to see if I could use that work.
2013-02-26 05703, 2013
Leftmost
The second edit linked to a Discogs release which didn't even include the contested picture, merely showing that someone at Discogs thought it should be credited that way.
2013-02-26 05705, 2013
VxJasonxV
hmm
2013-02-26 05717, 2013
VxJasonxV
I need an example of an album on Juno Download
2013-02-26 05722, 2013
VxJasonxV
a VA/comp
2013-02-26 05734, 2013
VxJasonxV
that contains one track that is a mashup of two tracks
2013-02-26 05749, 2013
VxJasonxV
I have a VA with artist credits that's working well.
2013-02-26 05756, 2013
VxJasonxV
My ability to search for this is terrible for some reason.
2013-02-26 05732, 2013
VxJasonxV
also, searching for 'mashup' on junodownload is disheartening
2013-02-26 05704, 2013
VxJasonxV
aha, found one
2013-02-26 05717, 2013
derwin
VxJasonxV: awesome :)
2013-02-26 05726, 2013
derwin
I would have helepd but I just read this :)
2013-02-26 05724, 2013
ruaok joined the channel
2013-02-26 05754, 2013
Leftmost
It's so hard to find cover art scans of some of these albums I want to correct. Someone should really archive those.
