0:04 AM
VxJasonxV_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13344, 2013
0:05 AM
peaveyman_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13313, 2013
0:13 AM
VxJasonxV^ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13309, 2013
0:25 AM
drsaunde joined the channel
2013-05-13 13308, 2013
0:32 AM
VxJasonxV^ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13323, 2013
0:44 AM
VxJasonxV^ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13323, 2013
0:45 AM
VxJasonxV^ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13345, 2013
1:23 AM
Prophet5 joined the channel
2013-05-13 13351, 2013
1:35 AM
DarkerAudit joined the channel
2013-05-13 13352, 2013
1:39 AM
ianmcorvidae|alt joined the channel
2013-05-13 13353, 2013
1:39 AM
ianmcorvidae|alt joined the channel
2013-05-13 13351, 2013
1:40 AM
JonnyJD_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13342, 2013
2:23 AM
DarkerAudit joined the channel
2013-05-13 13318, 2013
2:26 AM
Vorpal_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13357, 2013
2:37 AM
ianmcorvidae joined the channel
2013-05-13 13358, 2013
2:40 AM
lidel_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13355, 2013
2:45 AM
Prophet5_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13312, 2013
2:48 AM
Vorpal joined the channel
2013-05-13 13318, 2013
2:48 AM
CatQuest joined the channel
2013-05-13 13339, 2013
2:52 AM
Vorpal joined the channel
2013-05-13 13345, 2013
2:53 AM
Vorpal joined the channel
2013-05-13 13344, 2013
3:35 AM
peaveyman joined the channel
2013-05-13 13315, 2013
3:53 AM
STalKer-Y joined the channel
2013-05-13 13339, 2013
3:53 AM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13303, 2013
3:54 AM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13353, 2013
5:38 AM
xsteadfastx joined the channel
2013-05-13 13359, 2013
6:06 AM
SultS joined the channel
2013-05-13 13315, 2013
6:23 AM
SultS_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13326, 2013
6:25 AM
flamingspinach
2013-05-13 13324, 2013
6:38 AM
Prophet5 joined the channel
2013-05-13 13312, 2013
6:54 AM
ijabz joined the channel
2013-05-13 13348, 2013
6:57 AM
napterk joined the channel
2013-05-13 13301, 2013
7:06 AM
peaveyman_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13300, 2013
7:19 AM
reosarevok joined the channel
2013-05-13 13307, 2013
7:44 AM
panther2k joined the channel
2013-05-13 13359, 2013
7:46 AM
culinko joined the channel
2013-05-13 13328, 2013
8:27 AM
MBChatLogger
is logging
2013-05-13 13328, 2013
8:27 AM
wolfe.freenode.net
Users on #musicbrainz: Fluke Jormangeud KingJ hangy tenthirteen danoply shardz innocuous mr_maxis yvesr Lotheric kapu dwg sampsyo jamesh hawke_ petteyg Muz Shepard murdos_ skd5aner ocharles ianwelle1 DremoraLV choupy leonardo xgnu_andrew srotta kloeri demosdemon Rondom_ bitmap flamingspinach jordi mat_ Clint alastairp MissDee_ navap nioncode Almatraz bricas derwin phunyguy Schisma_ nano- evilnick uptown frewsxcv massdosage smgoller Leftmost _flow__ misterswag
2013-05-13 13349, 2013
8:27 AM
tyteen4a03 joined the channel
2013-05-13 13334, 2013
8:32 AM
night199uk joined the channel
2013-05-13 13334, 2013
8:32 AM
HSOWA joined the channel
2013-05-13 13304, 2013
8:33 AM
night199uk joined the channel
2013-05-13 13324, 2013
8:37 AM
HSOWA joined the channel
2013-05-13 13324, 2013
8:37 AM
night199uk joined the channel
2013-05-13 13336, 2013
8:42 AM
Krystof joined the channel
2013-05-13 13336, 2013
8:44 AM
Cook879 joined the channel
2013-05-13 13324, 2013
8:48 AM
adhawkins joined the channel
2013-05-13 13339, 2013
8:49 AM
Guest40453 joined the channel
2013-05-13 13347, 2013
8:51 AM
flamingspinach
I was asking whether it would fail because track 3 (which the edit doesn't touch) has already been changed by a different edit
2013-05-13 13343, 2013
8:52 AM
ijabz joined the channel
2013-05-13 13303, 2013
8:54 AM
ruaok joined the channel
2013-05-13 13319, 2013
8:54 AM
reosarevok
I'd generally expect karaoke versions to be credited to the same artist as the normal song, but I don't edit them so I don't know what people who do think
2013-05-13 13303, 2013
8:55 AM
reosarevok
Anyway, that annoying "voting no in the last minute" thing will thankfully stop being an issue soon, ianmcorvidae has a patch that would extend the duration of an edit a couple days after a No vote which is too close to the expiration date...
2013-05-13 13314, 2013
8:55 AM
reosarevok
sadly it won't help with this one though
2013-05-13 13327, 2013
8:55 AM
flamingspinach
the normal song is typically credited to the singer, and karaoke versions are specifically created to *remove* the singer's contribution to the track
2013-05-13 13335, 2013
8:55 AM
flamingspinach
it makes no sense to me to have the karaoke version of a song credited to the singer
2013-05-13 13356, 2013
8:55 AM
nikki
yet that's how thousands of releases have already been entered
2013-05-13 13309, 2013
8:56 AM
flamingspinach sighs
2013-05-13 13314, 2013
8:56 AM
flamingspinach
is it a style guideline?
2013-05-13 13348, 2013
8:57 AM
JoeLlama joined the channel
2013-05-13 13317, 2013
8:59 AM
nikki
2013-05-13 13338, 2013
8:59 AM
nikki
also in general the track/recording artist is meaningless and just represents who it's credited to on the cover and we have relationships for saying who did what
2013-05-13 13358, 2013
8:59 AM
nikki
it doesn't make sense if you interpret track artist as "performer", but that's not what track artist means :)
2013-05-13 13300, 2013
9:02 AM
flamingspinach
2013-05-13 13311, 2013
9:02 AM
nikki
so it inherits from the release artist
2013-05-13 13318, 2013
9:02 AM
flamingspinach
yup, I guess so
2013-05-13 13322, 2013
9:02 AM
flamingspinach
according to your link
2013-05-13 13338, 2013
9:02 AM
flamingspinach
but that kind of thing can become ridiculous
2013-05-13 13347, 2013
9:02 AM
flamingspinach
do you also want to credit the orchestral third track to a pop singer?
2013-05-13 13307, 2013
9:03 AM
flamingspinach
(someone else made that edit)
2013-05-13 13319, 2013
9:04 AM
nikki
I would, yes
2013-05-13 13329, 2013
9:06 AM
gmk joined the channel
2013-05-13 13309, 2013
9:07 AM
flamingspinach
nikki: is it plausible that the thing in the upper left of the image I linked is a tracklist?
2013-05-13 13322, 2013
9:07 AM
flamingspinach
if so, that provides grounds to write the tracklist the way I wanted to
2013-05-13 13318, 2013
9:08 AM
v6lur joined the channel
2013-05-13 13324, 2013
9:08 AM
nikki
it does?
2013-05-13 13331, 2013
9:08 AM
nikki wonders if we're looking at the same image
2013-05-13 13311, 2013
9:12 AM
flamingspinach
sort of, maybe :)
2013-05-13 13338, 2013
9:12 AM
flamingspinach
it lists the three tracks with numbers next to them, and underneath each track lists one or two people
2013-05-13 13306, 2013
9:13 AM
flamingspinach
and it is the only such list of tracks anywhere in the packaging
2013-05-13 13311, 2013
9:19 AM
ijabz joined the channel
2013-05-13 13357, 2013
9:20 AM
Cook880 joined the channel
2013-05-13 13336, 2013
9:23 AM
Cook879 joined the channel
2013-05-13 13315, 2013
9:34 AM
JoeLlama joined the channel
2013-05-13 13328, 2013
9:45 AM
ijabz_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13301, 2013
9:54 AM
ruaok joined the channel
2013-05-13 13331, 2013
10:19 AM
ijabz_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13331, 2013
10:25 AM
jcazevedo joined the channel
2013-05-13 13350, 2013
10:34 AM
KingJ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13317, 2013
10:36 AM
peaveyman joined the channel
2013-05-13 13332, 2013
10:42 AM
CatQuest
2013-05-13 13337, 2013
10:42 AM
CatQuest
NEKO
2013-05-13 13342, 2013
10:42 AM
CatQuest
WRITE WITH CATS
2013-05-13 13312, 2013
10:45 AM
_5moufl joined the channel
2013-05-13 13302, 2013
10:49 AM
KingJ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13301, 2013
11:10 AM
STalKer-Y joined the channel
2013-05-13 13343, 2013
11:10 AM
joshk joined the channel
2013-05-13 13328, 2013
11:11 AM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13352, 2013
11:11 AM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13332, 2013
11:12 AM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13336, 2013
11:12 AM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13315, 2013
11:13 AM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13316, 2013
11:13 AM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13339, 2013
11:13 AM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13314, 2013
11:14 AM
Vorpal joined the channel
2013-05-13 13349, 2013
11:16 AM
Leftmost joined the channel
2013-05-13 13324, 2013
11:17 AM
v6lur joined the channel
2013-05-13 13319, 2013
11:25 AM
v6lur joined the channel
2013-05-13 13319, 2013
11:25 AM
jcazevedo joined the channel
2013-05-13 13319, 2013
11:25 AM
ijabz joined the channel
2013-05-13 13319, 2013
11:25 AM
Krystof joined the channel
2013-05-13 13355, 2013
11:26 AM
reosarevok joined the channel
2013-05-13 13347, 2013
11:34 AM
Yoyoto joined the channel
2013-05-13 13305, 2013
11:36 AM
Yoyoto
Hello, So I'm new to the site and adding some releases to the database but I've come along something I don't really know where to put.... I've got a song that an artist released as a stand alone free download. It's not listed on his site but it's on his offical youtube page. How would I go about adding that?
2013-05-13 13312, 2013
11:38 AM
reosarevok
heh
2013-05-13 13317, 2013
11:38 AM
reosarevok
There are two options
2013-05-13 13327, 2013
11:38 AM
reosarevok
Some people would add it as a promotional single
2013-05-13 13335, 2013
11:38 AM
reosarevok
I'd just add it as a standalone recording
2013-05-13 13344, 2013
11:38 AM
reosarevok
(so, from the sidebar of the artist page, "Add recording")
2013-05-13 13309, 2013
11:39 AM
Yoyoto
Thank you
2013-05-13 13325, 2013
12:00 PM
voiceinsideyou joined the channel
2013-05-13 13303, 2013
12:08 PM
_5moufl joined the channel
2013-05-13 13315, 2013
12:10 PM
joshk_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13328, 2013
12:14 PM
djinni` joined the channel
2013-05-13 13319, 2013
12:15 PM
reosarevok joined the channel
2013-05-13 13323, 2013
12:41 PM
reosarevok_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13354, 2013
12:41 PM
STalKer-Y joined the channel
2013-05-13 13318, 2013
12:42 PM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13343, 2013
12:42 PM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-13 13307, 2013
12:44 PM
gmk1 joined the channel
2013-05-13 13309, 2013
12:44 PM
VxJasonxV joined the channel
2013-05-13 13339, 2013
12:44 PM
xsteadfa1tx joined the channel
2013-05-13 13349, 2013
12:49 PM
Vorpal_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13309, 2013
12:51 PM
tyteen4a- joined the channel
2013-05-13 13302, 2013
12:58 PM
Leftmost joined the channel
2013-05-13 13349, 2013
12:59 PM
xsteadfastx joined the channel
2013-05-13 13349, 2013
13:06 PM
puneet joined the channel
2013-05-13 13345, 2013
13:07 PM
puneet_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13326, 2013
13:23 PM
Leftmost` joined the channel
2013-05-13 13311, 2013
13:27 PM
Jormangeud joined the channel
2013-05-13 13354, 2013
13:28 PM
JonnyJD_ joined the channel
2013-05-13 13320, 2013
13:30 PM
CatQuest joined the channel
2013-05-13 13322, 2013
13:30 PM
sivoais joined the channel
2013-05-13 13338, 2013
13:30 PM
CatQuest
blup
2013-05-13 13342, 2013
13:30 PM
CatQuest
am I here?
2013-05-13 13312, 2013
13:32 PM
reosarevok_
yes
2013-05-13 13316, 2013
13:32 PM
reosarevok_
For some of us
2013-05-13 13326, 2013
13:32 PM
reosarevok_
(for the ones who have split, no :) )
2013-05-13 13301, 2013
13:33 PM
Mineo
well, the cool guys are here, so :)
2013-05-13 13312, 2013
13:33 PM
reosarevok_
Yeah, true
