so no need for flac that way? then i'll stop looking into fpcalc sources :-)
2014-03-01 06053, 2014
JonnyJD
Zastai: yes, no need for flac
2014-03-01 06010, 2014
Gentlecat joined the channel
2014-03-01 06002, 2014
JonnyJD updated the forum post
2014-03-01 06053, 2014
KillDaBOB joined the channel
2014-03-01 06016, 2014
simukis_ joined the channel
2014-03-01 06038, 2014
JonnyJD_hex joined the channel
2014-03-01 06052, 2014
JonnyJD_kvirc joined the channel
2014-03-01 06007, 2014
Zastai
i'm seeing triple
2014-03-01 06041, 2014
JonnyJD_kvirc
yeah, sorry about that. I am testing IRC programs on my Laptop
2014-03-01 06043, 2014
JonnyJD_hex
hexchat looks the best so far, but KVIrc has a lot of features and 1-2 I like..
2014-03-01 06039, 2014
Zastai
looks like fpcalc relies on ffmpeg's libavresample api for opening/readig files/pipes, so nothing to fix there for wav. still, might mean that a newer ffmpeg fixes even the wav case
2014-03-01 06002, 2014
Zastai
i only use irc occasionally for #musicbrainz, so the freenode webchat is good enough
2014-03-01 06044, 2014
JonnyJD
ffmpeg 2.1.1 on my end
2014-03-01 06057, 2014
simukis_ joined the channel
2014-03-01 06058, 2014
JonnyJD__hex joined the channel
2014-03-01 06003, 2014
JonnyJD__kvirc joined the channel
2014-03-01 06036, 2014
JonnyJD_ joined the channel
2014-03-01 06012, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
Zastai: I really think the problem isn't with the tools, but that WAV files inherently just don't have a header telling about lenght and fpcalc needs the length at start
2014-03-01 06042, 2014
Zastai
Maybe - but not sure why it _needs_ the length
2014-03-01 06034, 2014
Zastai
in any case, it works for cd ripping with aiff/aifc so the point is mostly moot
2014-03-01 06038, 2014
JonnyJD__kvirc
maybe it's not the length, just some kind of header to say what file it is
2014-03-01 06029, 2014
Zastai
nah; there's other errors it throws for unknown audio streams; it will already have been past that
2014-03-01 06004, 2014
JonnyJD__kvirc
well, at least for the cdparanoia "backend" it is no issue.
2014-03-01 06013, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
finding a command line backend on Windows might be a problem, but that is a TODO for later..
2014-03-01 06035, 2014
luks
Zastai: it needs the length because the acoustid service needs the length
2014-03-01 06004, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
luks, but does it need the length up front?
2014-03-01 06004, 2014
luks
maybe it doesn,t it's probably just how wav demuxing in ffmpeg works
2014-03-01 06049, 2014
luks
but the point is, if it can't get the length at the start, it won't get it in the middle
2014-03-01 06000, 2014
luks
and it never gets to the end, because fpcalc closes the pipe after 120 seconds
2014-03-01 06010, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
ah okay
2014-03-01 06012, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
didn't think about that. So it is a conceptional problem with WAV/RAW data
2014-03-01 06017, 2014
luks
yesx
2014-03-01 06043, 2014
luks
but I think that WAV generally does have the total number of samples in the header
2014-03-01 06003, 2014
luks
so I think it's not the same problem as with RAW files, at least in general
2014-03-01 06042, 2014
Zastai
could be that ffmpeg chooses not to trust the sample count for its get_av_length function
2014-03-01 06000, 2014
Zastai
(or whatever it's called)
2014-03-01 06006, 2014
luks
maybe
2014-03-01 06036, 2014
Zastai
jonny, i know cdrdao does commandline extraction on windows -not sure how maintained it is though
2014-03-01 06010, 2014
Zastai
not very it seems- last release is from 2009
2014-03-01 06018, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
Zastai, cdrdao only theoretically works on Windows. As in: only very few users will have a working installation, I guess.
2014-03-01 06050, 2014
Zastai
for reading too? its writing will be driver-dependent of course, but that's not needed
2014-03-01 06001, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
Never tried it, but in theory I also use it as a backend with isrcsubmit on Windows
2014-03-01 06002, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
Well, I think one of the problems was that no Windows build is available or something like that
gui side of cueripper is interesting - even uses MB
2014-03-01 06049, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
first question I would have if it is using WS/2 WS/1 or FreeDB, but that is off-topic..
2014-03-01 06014, 2014
Zastai
console ripper works, but rips entire cd + cue. so probably not usable for your purposes
2014-03-01 06030, 2014
Zastai
i see no option to rip only a specific track with the console client
2014-03-01 06058, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
well, if you rip the whole CD anyways you can just use Picard or similar, yes
2014-03-01 06008, 2014
HibiscusKazeneko joined the channel
2014-03-01 06039, 2014
mokes joined the channel
2014-03-01 06028, 2014
jacobbrett joined the channel
2014-03-01 06045, 2014
jacobbrett has left the channel
2014-03-01 06046, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
my basic use case for getting AcoustIDs directly from Disc is having no pressure at all to do something with some files laying around and doing it fast
2014-03-01 06000, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
(my test took 3 minutes for a whole disc)
2014-03-01 06011, 2014
JonnyJD__hex
so if you have a stack of discs you might not even like, you can submit/match IDs to MusicBrainz fast
2014-03-01 06059, 2014
Mineo joined the channel
2014-03-01 06009, 2014
mokes joined the channel
2014-03-01 06044, 2014
orangeblock joined the channel
2014-03-01 06034, 2014
johtso_ joined the channel
2014-03-01 06043, 2014
D4RK-PH0ENiX joined the channel
2014-03-01 06030, 2014
rocker joined the channel
2014-03-01 06005, 2014
Freso
3 minutes? That's pretty neat.
2014-03-01 06011, 2014
Freso /late
2014-03-01 06054, 2014
jacobbrett joined the channel
2014-03-01 06015, 2014
CallerNo6 joined the channel
2014-03-01 06042, 2014
HibiscusKazeneko joined the channel
2014-03-01 06040, 2014
Krystof joined the channel
2014-03-01 06044, 2014
JonnyJD_
Freso: yes, removing all "paranoia" and leading only the first 2 minutes of every track (since fpcals closes the pipe after that)
2014-03-01 06050, 2014
JonnyJD_
*reading
2014-03-01 06003, 2014
Freso
I would probably do 2:05 or some such, perhaps even 2:10, just to be sure. But yeah.
2014-03-01 06022, 2014
JonnyJD_
well, I didn't hard-code these 2 minutes. It's just that fpcalc closes the pipe and luks said it was after 120 seconds ;-)
2014-03-01 06051, 2014
JonnyJD_
that is 120 seconds of audio data read, not 120 seconds elapsed time
2014-03-01 06027, 2014
JonnyJD_
3 minutes is elapsed time for the whole disc
2014-03-01 06031, 2014
JonnyJD_
ripping is considerably faster than listening.. although you can try and listen to a faster version of the tracks so it doesn't take that long :-P
2014-03-01 06030, 2014
mokes joined the channel
2014-03-01 06001, 2014
xplt joined the channel
2014-03-01 06014, 2014
simukis_ joined the channel
2014-03-01 06017, 2014
voiceinsideyou joined the channel
2014-03-01 06041, 2014
voiceinsideyou1 joined the channel
2014-03-01 06030, 2014
Freso does that all the time!
2014-03-01 06031, 2014
nikki joined the channel
2014-03-01 06049, 2014
mokes joined the channel
2014-03-01 06006, 2014
johtso joined the channel
2014-03-01 06021, 2014
kossy joined the channel
2014-03-01 06053, 2014
CatQuest
there's a guy in my passersby wh's name is"hawke"
2014-03-01 06001, 2014
CatQuest
I did a serious double take man
2014-03-01 06054, 2014
JonnyJD joined the channel
2014-03-01 06032, 2014
h-darklow joined the channel
2014-03-01 06019, 2014
HSOWA
I like this song
2014-03-01 06022, 2014
HSOWA
The Beatles ~ I'm Only Sleeping (3:02) Revolver)(1966)
