(or a broadcast, or whatever - it's an uniform thing, anyway)
2014-07-12 19325, 2014
reosarevok
Seems to be a radio show, listening to it - or it's digital equivalent
2014-07-12 19331, 2014
reosarevok
We even have guidelines for those already
2014-07-12 19340, 2014
reosarevok
er. Its. Sorry D:
2014-07-12 19322, 2014
reosarevok
Anyway
2014-07-12 19320, 2014
reosarevok
That still could go in as a release or a recording or whatever
2014-07-12 19314, 2014
reosarevok
http://quasi.rockit.it/2014/05/20/pesaro-wave-cit… is a series if anything - although I don't think we're using series for lists like those at the moment so style approval would probably be needed to use them as arbitrary lists rather than real series
2014-07-12 19339, 2014
reosarevok
(the videos themselves of course can be added as standalone video recordings)
2014-07-12 19358, 2014
gioele
being the rational person I am, I am looking for a way to tell releases and playlists apart, I hope "it has a cover art" is not the litmus test to apply :)
2014-07-12 19358, 2014
reosarevok
Intentionality, probably
2014-07-12 19340, 2014
reosarevok
I don't know if there's a single clear border, I doubt it since there rarely is in MB stuff :p
2014-07-12 19347, 2014
gioele
:)
2014-07-12 19302, 2014
gioele
can we have series of series?
2014-07-12 19336, 2014
gioele
I think all these http://quasi.rockit.it/category/liste/ as a single series (the authors' intent is shown by the fact that they have a section for them). But if a playlist is a series, then we have a series of series
2014-07-12 19310, 2014
reosarevok
Well not at the moment. That's a trivial change though
2014-07-12 19314, 2014
reosarevok
I don't think I would agree either that that's a series, though - they're unconnected as such, just happen to be all the lists in the same page. That's a bit like saying all releases on a netlabel are a series.
2014-07-12 19324, 2014
reosarevok
(I would agree though you can have series of playlists)
2014-07-12 19306, 2014
gioele
reosarevok: yes, you are right, that is more a catalog than a series
2014-07-12 19309, 2014
reosarevok
(If they did that Pesaro thing for different cities, I'd call that a series - or if they have a weekly "we ask an artist to pick 10 songs for us")
2014-07-12 19320, 2014
reosarevok
About the limits, yeah, unsure
2014-07-12 19322, 2014
reosarevok
If a magazine asks an artist to select 10 songs that influenced them and print the names, that's obviously not a release. If they ask him and put them on a CD, that is a release. If they link to them in youtube... it is indeed a bit of a grey area :)
2014-07-12 19301, 2014
gioele
I think the difference between artist chooses 10 songs in an article and artist chooses 10 songs for a CD is that the first links to works, the second links to recordings, the third…
2014-07-12 19351, 2014
gioele
so MB does not care about "list of titles linked to works" but cares about "list of titles linked to recordings"
2014-07-12 19309, 2014
gioele
at list this is a decent test
2014-07-12 19353, 2014
gioele
s/list/least/
2014-07-12 19301, 2014
gioele
now, are lists of embedded videos links to works or recordings? I'd say the latter: these people spend time choosing a good video, or a version of song X made by artist Y
2014-07-12 19315, 2014
reosarevok
Heh
2014-07-12 19302, 2014
reosarevok
I don' tthink that's what MB cares about - it cares about the, well, release-ness of it :p
2014-07-12 19346, 2014
reosarevok
And about notability as well, up to a point - that CD would be allowed if it's done by an artist, but it'd probably be voted down if it's my wedding's playlist on a CD :p
2014-07-12 19300, 2014
reosarevok is very much not getting married, but to put an example
2014-07-12 19348, 2014
gioele
well, I think the people behind these sites spend quite a bit of time to polish those posts, then the push them on social networks and all those things. Notable I do not know (quite a bit for rockit.it), but release-ness I'd say a lot (at least they try to look as people that do releases)
2014-07-12 19348, 2014
CallerNo6
is a radio dj notable? they're cranking out playlists faster than we could ever enter them.
