#musicbrainz

/

      • reosarevok_
        It will work

        • 2015-01-07 00731, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        The recording merges will (I assume) fail if the release merges first, but they'll end up merged anyway

        • 2015-01-07 00754, 2015

      • hibiscuskazeneko
        I entered the recording merges first

        • 2015-01-07 00749, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        So yeah - either the recording merges pass, then the release merge merges just the releases, or the release merge passes, merging both recordings and releases, and the independent merge edits (I imagine) fail dependency

        • 2015-01-07 00757, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        End result should be all merged, anyway :)

        • 2015-01-07 00729, 2015

      • meaning joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00719, 2015

      • LordSputnik has left the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00708, 2015

      • mezod joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00758, 2015

      • Nyanko-sensei joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00704, 2015

      • achadwick
        I've been having trouble understanding dependencies. Are any of https://musicbrainz.org/user/achadwick/edits/open likely to be doomed too?

        • 2015-01-07 00737, 2015

      • achadwick
        (The first recording is notable because it's on the Voyager 1 Golden record: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contents_of_the_Voy… . Is there a MusicBrainz entry for that release yet? ☺)

        • 2015-01-07 00738, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        haha

        • 2015-01-07 00752, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        I doubt it, actually, but haven't checked

        • 2015-01-07 00758, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        "After NASA had received criticism over the nudity on the Pioneer plaque (line drawings of a naked man and woman)"

        • 2015-01-07 00703, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        ...

        • 2015-01-07 00713, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        Sometimes people amaze me still

        • 2015-01-07 00710, 2015

      • JesseW joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00733, 2015

      • kahu joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00727, 2015

      • darthanubis joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00729, 2015

      • JoeLlama joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00734, 2015

      • JoeLlama joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00756, 2015

      • CatQuest
        reosarevok_: wat. *seriously*? uh.. uh

        • 2015-01-07 00757, 2015

      • CatQuest
        that's kinda the POINT that they were naked. no? to show off howwe look like as an organism? it would be weird to have a diagram of a frog in bioclass but cover it up with a panty or somthing

        • 2015-01-07 00715, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        Dunno, it was on the wiki link

        • 2015-01-07 00719, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        I didn't read into it :)

        • 2015-01-07 00719, 2015

      • CatQuest
        >_<

        • 2015-01-07 00749, 2015

      • JonnyJD joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00726, 2015

      • yeeeargh joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00754, 2015

      • murk_ joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00738, 2015

      • hawke1 joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00751, 2015

      • ruaok joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00711, 2015

      • v6lur joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00707, 2015

      • murk_ joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00757, 2015

      • xps2 joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00746, 2015

      • hawke1
        Am I missing something or is this a bug: http://beta.musicbrainz.org/event/7a37da40-010e-4… — “might attend” for a past concert?

        • 2015-01-07 00728, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        For some definition of bug, but yes. It also should differentiate "attending" and "might attend"

        • 2015-01-07 00743, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        There's a ticket for the latter, but probably not for your issue, go ahead and add one :)

        • 2015-01-07 00756, 2015

      • hawke1
        How would that be differentiated at all, though?

        • 2015-01-07 00709, 2015

      • hawke1
        Is there a 'maybe' attribute for a list?

        • 2015-01-07 00726, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        There are two types of event collections, attending and maybe attending

        • 2015-01-07 00757, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        (as in, not just different names but their own type each as well)

        • 2015-01-07 00758, 2015

      • hawke1
        Nod.

        • 2015-01-07 00716, 2015

      • hawke1
        That feels a little limiting in how one might use event collections.

        • 2015-01-07 00738, 2015

      • hawke1
        Since I guess that means you can’t have “I attended this one, will attend that one, and might attend the other” in the same list.

        • 2015-01-07 00737, 2015

      • hawke1
        Anyway, http://tickets.musicbrainz.org/browse/MBS-8127 has been entered

        • 2015-01-07 00729, 2015

      • v6lur joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00746, 2015

      • Audioburn joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00739, 2015

      • JoeLlama joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00732, 2015

      • chungy joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00732, 2015

      • Freso
        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ItMJtA8vfpw

        • 2015-01-07 00734, 2015

      • Freso
        reosarevok_: ^

        • 2015-01-07 00709, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        haha

        • 2015-01-07 00717, 2015

      • xps2 joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00721, 2015

      • Leo_Verto joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00739, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        hi#

        • 2015-01-07 00732, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        so I've found this acoustid, which has 3 fingerprints, two of them equal, the third one entirely different, and 2 tracks

        • 2015-01-07 00710, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        https://acoustid.org/track/f8299d07-e9bc-4597-9c3…

        • 2015-01-07 00757, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        and that second song is associated with two different acoustids

        • 2015-01-07 00714, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        only the length is the same, the songs are entirely different

        • 2015-01-07 00745, 2015

      • chirlu`
        Yes, that happens. :)

        • 2015-01-07 00709, 2015

      • chirlu`
        Do you know which recording it actually is?

        • 2015-01-07 00739, 2015

      • chirlu`
        Oh, there is a download-for-free, I can check myself …

        • 2015-01-07 00723, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        should multiple releases be used when there are both a digital download and a CD version of a release?

        • 2015-01-07 00733, 2015

      • chirlu`
        Yes.

        • 2015-01-07 00753, 2015

      • hawke1
        Is there any logic to how the support/main artists are listed on events?

        • 2015-01-07 00757, 2015

      • hawke1
        I’d expect main then support, or vice-versa. Or maybe alphabetical. But there doesn’t seem to be any: http://beta.musicbrainz.org/series/3c261975-c56d-…

        • 2015-01-07 00756, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        similar to featured artists maybe? https://musicbrainz.org/doc/Style/Titles/Featured…

        • 2015-01-07 00734, 2015

      • reosarevok_
        hawke1: that's done in the same way we load writers for a work. I don't think either have any ordering at the moment, but I might be wrong

        • 2015-01-07 00711, 2015

      • xps2_ joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00739, 2015

      • ariscop joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00711, 2015

      • xps2_b joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00759, 2015

      • madmouser1 has left the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00730, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        VLC just derped hard

        • 2015-01-07 00754, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        autolaunched CD, kyrillic titels and album name

        • 2015-01-07 00715, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        music is good though

        • 2015-01-07 00700, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        should instrumental edits of tracks be tagged as karaoke versions?

        • 2015-01-07 00735, 2015

      • Freso
        Like, using tags?

        • 2015-01-07 00746, 2015

      • Freso
        If so: if you feel like it.

        • 2015-01-07 00747, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        relationship

        • 2015-01-07 00702, 2015

      • Freso
        Only if they are karaoke versions.

        • 2015-01-07 00714, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        umm

        • 2015-01-07 00754, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        so this album has instrumental edits, which just have the vocal tracks removed https://musicbrainz.org/release/5fc01e44-f127-44a…

        • 2015-01-07 00726, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        otherwise exactly the same, not really intended for karaoke though, I suppose

        • 2015-01-07 00712, 2015

      • Freso
        There is a Recording-Work "performance of" relationship which has an "instrumental" attribute though.

        • 2015-01-07 00725, 2015

      • Freso
        Which sounds like what I would use.

        • 2015-01-07 00752, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        I guess I'll cancel a few edits then

        • 2015-01-07 00745, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        although, that doesn't work

        • 2015-01-07 00718, 2015

      • Leo_Verto
        because the original song is a recording, I can't relate to it as a work

        • 2015-01-07 00757, 2015

      • hawke1
        You might need to make a new work for the original song.

        • 2015-01-07 00758, 2015

      • Freso
        You will have to create a Work for it then.

        • 2015-01-07 00712, 2015

      • Freso
        Works are different entities from Recordings.

        • 2015-01-07 00739, 2015

      • demonimin_ joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00744, 2015

      • CatQuest is wondering what's bad about senior citizen choir singing MC Hammer

        • 2015-01-07 00759, 2015

      • CatQuest thought it was pretty awesome :D

        • 2015-01-07 00729, 2015

      • CatQuest
        or is this one of those "seniors are gross" things?

        • 2015-01-07 00730, 2015

      • hawke1
        CatQuest: The idea is fine, but they are not very good singers. :-)

        • 2015-01-07 00746, 2015

      • CatQuest dosent really get that

        • 2015-01-07 00700, 2015

      • CatQuest
        njaa

        • 2015-01-07 00702, 2015

      • CatQuest
        maybe?

        • 2015-01-07 00752, 2015

      • CatQuest
        there was atleast one lady with a pretty good voice i herd

        • 2015-01-07 00711, 2015

      • CatQuest only skimmed through the songs since couldn't be bothered to listen to all

        • 2015-01-07 00729, 2015

      • CatQuest
        also I got the info on magnetic flux so now I must return to work work

        • 2015-01-07 00720, 2015

      • joseph joined the channel

        • 2015-01-07 00725, 2015

      • Alkahest joined the channel