Does anyone know how discids like this get created? https://musicbrainz.org/cdtoc/T6hoak93U7w8XbGZO9A… There is a correct one attached to this release which shows it to be 1:17 but this discid (which someane attached to a release indicates it is 10 hours long.
2020-10-09 28303, 2020
reosarevok
A faulty cd scanner of some sort
2020-10-09 28320, 2020
reosarevok
loujine has a report in review for too long discids, actually, I just fixed it up today a bit :)
2020-10-09 28359, 2020
cheezmo2
Look what good friend of mine voted against removing it. Yeesh.
From the discussion it seems that that they can't do it within specs. (single layer, uncompressed DSD)
2020-10-09 28300, 2020
evelyn
(or a hybrid one for that matter)
2020-10-09 28317, 2020
cheezmo2
Definiteley can't be hybrid
2020-10-09 28338, 2020
evelyn
is it to do with the SHM manufacturing process?
2020-10-09 28358, 2020
JoeLlama has quit
2020-10-09 28300, 2020
cheezmo2
From what I read the creators felt that single layer uncompressed DSD sounds better so they don't do it. I'm sure the manufacturing process would support it but it isn't possible with the limitaions they put on the spec.
2020-10-09 28359, 2020
evelyn
In fact most of the ones I've seen have been reissues of stereo LPs
2020-10-09 28311, 2020
cheezmo2
We just added medium formats for SHM-SACD (2ch) and SHM-SACD (mch) as part of a bigger SACD medium format improvement. They should probably go away.
2020-10-09 28309, 2020
Hexadigital has quit
2020-10-09 28316, 2020
Hexadigital joined the channel
2020-10-09 28316, 2020
Hexadigital has quit
2020-10-09 28316, 2020
Hexadigital joined the channel
2020-10-09 28311, 2020
xtim_41 has quit
2020-10-09 28349, 2020
MajorLurker joined the channel
2020-10-09 28304, 2020
cheezmo2
With the new SACD medium format for the "mch" area, debate is starting over whether it is still appropriate to add ETI for the mix info. A big issue seems to be that most editors use userscripts that show disambiguation after the track titles but general users would not see that info (or get it when tagging with picard without adding release_comment in a script. https://musicbrainz.org/edit/73703622
2020-10-09 28358, 2020
cheezmo2
Sorry, I meant recording_comment
2020-10-09 28308, 2020
gioele joined the channel
2020-10-09 28339, 2020
d4rkie joined the channel
2020-10-09 28332, 2020
D4RK-PH0ENiX has quit
2020-10-09 28340, 2020
gioele has quit
2020-10-09 28319, 2020
Lotheric joined the channel
2020-10-09 28306, 2020
evelyn
how can I set a track length for this release correctly?
it's about 10 minutes of silence follewed by a short chorus...
2020-10-09 28334, 2020
levine
Set track durations from the disc ID again
2020-10-09 28300, 2020
evelyn
ah, nice! TIL
2020-10-09 28348, 2020
evelyn
and it's automatically set! thanks!
2020-10-09 28322, 2020
cheezmo2
Seeing evelyn and levine is making me cross eyed.
2020-10-09 28325, 2020
levine
:D Can't you colour our nicks differently?
2020-10-09 28314, 2020
Glassjoe joined the channel
2020-10-09 28318, 2020
cheezmo2
I can barely figure out IRC so, no. :-)
2020-10-09 28355, 2020
levine
Heh, gotcha. It's a client specific thing, but yeah, I couldn't live without it at this point. If two people have the same colour and same length name and talk to each other, uuuh
