#musicbrainz

reosarevok, how would you go about adding the composers to track3 https://www.creighton-griffiths.co.uk/acatalog/... >> the release is here

next question https://musicbrainz.org/artist/beb9f7d1-60d9-49... and https://musicbrainz.org/artist/ba5308f3-1326-40... are shown as the same https://www.discogs.com/artist/2990779-Maurizio...

so do they get merged or not on the strength of that entry

the editor that put the first one in has made a lot of mistakes....

Oh god.

MajorLurker: I feel this might be the kind of case that does merit "Various Artists" on track

Or you could just list them all, I guess :D

And probably merge, yes

If it was a more common credit I'd wonder if it's some made up Scholzy thing, but for only one appearance (and Google doesn't give much more) it's very possible the comp makers just butchered his name

...kind of case that does merit "Various Artists" on track

NOooooooooooooooooooooo

reosarevok, rather than various artists we should have something like "what the hell were they thinking"

CatQuest: there's a reason it's not completely blocked, and this seems like that reason :D

MajorLurker: hahahaha

reosarevok: sight. i *know* . i just haet it

I am tempted just to leave the recording artist there to be honest... I spent half the day chasing that particular editors stuff around..... and he does not seem to want to answer questions

if that is a regular thing you shoudl report them .

I was a new editor once.....

no i meant ,if they contintue to not reply to questions and requests

it's prefectly fine to be new and make mistakes :)

yeah maybe so......

trouble is quite a few of his release he seems to be the only person in the world that has them cause ya can't find them on the www

hm, well that doesnt *have* to be suspicious

I mean I have a few budget classical releases bought at the shop in the 90*'s i doubht you'd find those on the internet

no not at all... but cover pics would help a lot!

yeps!

idk, try saying it agai nand againt to them

if they won't reply then possibly they used a throwaway email adress

yep put it on a about 4 or 5 releases now.....

so thne maybe freso or reo can tunr of theri ability to edit until they reconfirm an email adress

or something...

trouble is there are a lot of apparent typos that I would like to deal with....most of the classical stuff I just do

e.g. https://musicbrainz.org/edit/70620433

i noticed you went through some typo things ;)

tracks 4. 5 7 9 and 11

yea. typoes

and that dude has quite a presence on the web but can only find a front cover for that release

I fixed a lot of the classical releases he had entered... but there are still a couple that I just go ...... huh>

like https://musicbrainz.org/release/9bb46fac-506c-4...

track 5 that is not the right composer

oh yea, that's probably he only had "bossi" and didn't know wich boss it was :D

maybe I should not be so bossy ha... there were a few like that as I went through

hell i know i probably made soem error like that myself. back in the day.. this was before the internet was so.. well you could find everything

oooh added *themselves* aahh now i see

god gavd people born in 1991 being like peopel and not little children. still weird ot me

i fixed the Bossi!

Now fix the employii!

haha.... I'm retired you know lol

from lurking?

nah lurking will continue....even after death ha

actually there are 2 Bossi's related to that recording ... one transcribed the other, if I have it right.... oh well Enrico was the composer....

ok reosarevok how do I make something a transcription of something else???

"Giga" Opus 73 (1905) by Enrico Bossi (1861-1925), transcribed to organ by Renzo Bossi in 1934, from the Siciliana e giga, Op. 73 for Flute and Orchestra.

You add a second work with an arranger and link it as arrangement of, I guess :)

oh well I'll give it a go

oh wow two bissi, no wonder they guy had no idea what to pick :D

bossi*

he still picked the wrong one lol

true :D

reosarevok, could you check this https://musicbrainz.org/work/830efa1a-ea4b-4023... to see if it's ok

more than one Daquin too and I don't think the electropop selection is correct either!

oh dear.... and Rubinstein..... oh well... it is sort of fixed now!

!m MajorLurker

You're doing good work, MajorLurker!

ha keeps the old brain active... although there was another release that had a wrong artist and I put an annotation on but can't find it just at the moment

oh wait more than one Wely as well

The work seems fine to me, I changed the disambig a bit for consistency with the stuff I do (I think it's clearer that way that it's not just any arrangement for organ)

!m MajorLurker

You're doing good work, MajorLurker!

reosarevok, that's why I asked you to check... all good as far as I am concerned! :)

CatQuest, is there a quick way to find releases I have made annotations on?

MajorLurker: https://musicbrainz.org/search/edits?auto_edit_...

Is the only option I can think

(that includes any annotation change though, including when you removed them or edited them a bit)

well that's quick!! thanks!

it's the top one I was looking for....

track 7 artist is not correct!

I think I'll change it to this https://musicbrainz.org/artist/b7dbd0c3-9c63-4b... :)

For https://musicbrainz.org/release/b96b3a26-d982-4... I'm going to just change it to VA

you mean the release artist? sure I thought that. I have asked if they all appear on the cover but no reply yet

Even if the cover did list every pianist, it would still be unlikely to be all featured enough to deserve release credit

Yeah, I saw you asked :)

If a cover gets uploaded and shows that, say, a couple of them are prominently displayed, we could change it again

might be a big CD ")

Various Artist will look better

ok I can't find any Warwick associated with Venite.....

Me neither, maybe it's a typo?

Just add a new artist I guess, disambig "wrote Venite" or whatever

or maybe just make it [unknown] for now?

If you have reason to think it's not even the right name, maybe :)

I guess if we ever find the right name it can be merged away, will add a new one

there is a tune Warwick .... but I cannot find a composer