I disagree, how do you know it's the normal edition and not some non-normal one which just hasn't been marked properly?
2013-11-01 30532, 2013
simukis_
well, how'd you know that non-properly marked one is not the same normal but a duplicate, for example?
2013-11-01 30548, 2013
nikki
er?
2013-11-01 30512, 2013
simukis_
s/is not the/is the/
2013-11-01 30516, 2013
simukis_
ugh.
2013-11-01 30533, 2013
nikki
I still don't understand what you mean :/
2013-11-01 30500, 2013
simukis_
Well, I'd usually asume that the release which is not disambiguated is the normal-est one hence not some special release. Therefore, by looking at the list of releases which includes a non-disambiguated release, and yet another release which is disambiguated as Normal… I would want to either merge those (if they are dupes) or disambiguate the non-disambiguated one and remove disambiguation from the normal release.
2013-11-01 30527, 2013
nikki
we shouldn't have to make assumptions though
2013-11-01 30555, 2013
simukis_ finished uploading covers and booklet scans for albums in that specific release group. He's now going to hide back into his cave.
2013-11-01 30556, 2013
hawke_
I don’t understand how you can classify a single release as “normal” in most cases
2013-11-01 30511, 2013
hawke_
given how many albums have been reissued over the years, all of them are “normal”
2013-11-01 30520, 2013
nikki
if you have "ltd A", "ltd B" and no comment, you cannot know without doing research whether the no comment one is "ltd C" or "normal"
2013-11-01 30516, 2013
simukis_
I got urge to create a meme image with “Disambiguate all the releases” subtitle…
2013-11-01 30558, 2013
nikki
hawke_: it's not really to do with reissuing, it's to do with multiple editions released on the same day
2013-11-01 30506, 2013
nikki
which japan is apparently obsessed with :P
2013-11-01 30525, 2013
nikki
I've forgotten how many editions is the most I've found so far, but it's definitely in double figures
reosarevok: Huh. I could've sworn I added rob [at mb] to the CC for that mail.
2013-11-01 30526, 2013
Freso
Ah well.
2013-11-01 30516, 2013
reosarevok
You'd swear wrongly :)
2013-11-01 30523, 2013
reosarevok
But whatever, stuff happens :)
2013-11-01 30533, 2013
reosarevok
If you feel like stealing the ticket from me and doing it, feel free
2013-11-01 30541, 2013
reosarevok
If not I'll get to it later today or tomorrow I expect
2013-11-01 30552, 2013
reosarevok is fixing bad classical adds for now
2013-11-01 30504, 2013
Freso
Yeah. It's just that I recall actively adding rob@ and setting him to CC for that mail.
2013-11-01 30517, 2013
reosarevok
(instead of fixing bad classical ads, which would be much funnier)
2013-11-01 30534, 2013
Freso
Maybe I hit BCC and it got buried in Rob's inbox? Maybe Thunderbird messed up? Maybe something else happen? We'll never know.
2013-11-01 30551, 2013
reosarevok
Maybe you accidentally a whole platypus!
2013-11-01 30509, 2013
Freso
No, I *did* CC him!
2013-11-01 30526, 2013
Freso
That's the headers from the mail in my "outbox".
2013-11-01 30556, 2013
Freso
Maybe the CC headers get stripped from the forum software?
2013-11-01 30505, 2013
Freso
s/forum/mailing list/
2013-11-01 30509, 2013
Freso
s/from/by/
2013-11-01 30531, 2013
Freso
So I wouldn't be swearing wrong. :)
2013-11-01 30550, 2013
nikki
maybe you faked the headers just now!
2013-11-01 30538, 2013
Freso
Yeah, because I've never admitted to be in the wrong before...
2013-11-01 30510, 2013
reosarevok
:D
2013-11-01 30514, 2013
nikki
well you have to admit it sometimes, or people get suspicious :P
2013-11-01 30516, 2013
reosarevok shrugs
2013-11-01 30524, 2013
nikki is just teasing, you know :P
2013-11-01 30531, 2013
reosarevok
The mail that reached me didn't seem to include it, but who knows, heh
2013-11-01 30535, 2013
Freso
Nooo. :o
2013-11-01 30544, 2013
Freso would've never had guessed!
2013-11-01 30555, 2013
reosarevok
After that time when kuno somehow managed to accidentally post as me, I believe anything from our lists :p
2013-11-01 30522, 2013
hcmiya joined the channel
2013-11-01 30513, 2013
Freso
reosarevok: Like I said, the mailing list software probably strips out the CC from the mail headers. Since you don't read the rob [at mb] inbox (or, do you..?) it's unlikely that you will see it. I also didn't see the CC header in the mail I received back from the mail list, but I didn't check for it before now.
2013-11-01 30532, 2013
murk_ joined the channel
2013-11-01 30556, 2013
bricas
if a live version of a track is listed under a different name because it has a different arrangement, the recording is still just a "live" version of the work?
2013-11-01 30551, 2013
CallerNo6
bricas, unless the arrangement has been deemed a separate work, which is more common in classical.
2013-11-01 30523, 2013
CallerNo6
... and related to that, if the arrangement is considered a new work, the work-arranger AR is used. if not, the recording-arranger AR is used.
CallerNo6 wouldn't create a new work unless the new arrangement has lyrics/composition credits that don't apply to the original.
2013-11-01 30558, 2013
reosarevok
So, I *might* add a new "later version" work, but I might also not do it - unsure
2013-11-01 30510, 2013
CallerNo6 also wouldn't vote "no" if somebody who knows more about this specific case /did/ create a new work.
2013-11-01 30518, 2013
bricas
AFAIK it's only been performed live, btw.
2013-11-01 30505, 2013
xandora|mac joined the channel
2013-11-01 30524, 2013
LordSputnik joined the channel
2013-11-01 30516, 2013
nikki
Freso: you wanted to +1 that part-of thing, right? :P
2013-11-01 30549, 2013
Freso
nikki: No?
2013-11-01 30506, 2013
nikki
hehe
2013-11-01 30515, 2013
Freso
;)
2013-11-01 30546, 2013
Freso had already sent his +1 for it :p
2013-11-01 30552, 2013
ListMyCDs joined the channel
2013-11-01 30502, 2013
nikki
it didn't arrive here until two minutes after I asked
2013-11-01 30512, 2013
Freso
I think you asked as I sent it.
2013-11-01 30550, 2013
Freso
So by the time I checked back here, it was already off in the cyberwebs.
2013-11-01 30502, 2013
kepstin-laptop joined the channel
2013-11-01 30527, 2013
ListMyCDs
reosarevok: thanks for adding "has primary concert venue at"-relationship
2013-11-01 30546, 2013
reosarevok
Heh, the actual adding was nikki :)
2013-11-01 30555, 2013
nikki whistles innocently
2013-11-01 30503, 2013
ListMyCDs
well thanks to both of you then
2013-11-01 30538, 2013
reosarevok
np :)
2013-11-01 30514, 2013
xandora
So... What label is this album on? o.O -> "2013 Lindseystomp Music LLC, under exclusive licence to Decca Records a division of Universal Music Operations Limited"
2013-11-01 30546, 2013
reosarevok
Decca
2013-11-01 30520, 2013
reosarevok
And you can add a "licensor" relationship to Lindseystomp Music LLC
2013-11-01 30524, 2013
reosarevok
(I think :) )
2013-11-01 30519, 2013
xandora
...it's 8:20am here. I think that'll go in the 'too hard, do later' pile
2013-11-01 30527, 2013
Freso
xandora: Congratulations! It is now later. Time to get it done! :D
2013-11-01 30542, 2013
santiissopasse joined the channel
2013-11-01 30541, 2013
CallerNo6
ACs broken on beta?
2013-11-01 30545, 2013
CallerNo6 looks for a ticket
2013-11-01 30512, 2013
CallerNo6
(not "broken" broken, but displaying w/out join phrase)
2013-11-01 30528, 2013
nikki
where?
2013-11-01 30515, 2013
CallerNo6
in the tracklist
2013-11-01 30539, 2013
CallerNo6
in the editor, it looks fine, but on the release page it's just two artists munged together.
