20:14 PM
hawke_1
actually was productive, I think.
2013-05-16 13654, 2013
20:14 PM
LordSputnik
is this to do with your track numbering proposal thingy?
2013-05-16 13658, 2013
20:14 PM
hawke_1
yeah
2013-05-16 13603, 2013
20:15 PM
hawke_1
new RFC just out for that one too.
2013-05-16 13608, 2013
20:15 PM
LordSputnik
ahh ok
2013-05-16 13630, 2013
20:15 PM
hawke_1
(changes based on discussion)
2013-05-16 13654, 2013
20:16 PM
LordSputnik
I think recording def is mostly done
2013-05-16 13606, 2013
20:17 PM
LordSputnik
lixobix isn't happy yet, but I think most other people are
2013-05-16 13611, 2013
20:18 PM
hawke_1
at this point I am pretty sick of that thread, and I have been satisfied with pretty much every iteration since the start of this month (or thereabouts)
2013-05-16 13620, 2013
20:18 PM
LordSputnik
hawke_1: I know the feeling :P
2013-05-16 13630, 2013
20:18 PM
LordSputnik
I don't know anyone who isn't sick of the thread :P
2013-05-16 13638, 2013
20:18 PM
reosarevok
I'm not!
2013-05-16 13638, 2013
20:18 PM
LordSputnik
it must hold the record for the longest ever discussion on style
2013-05-16 13642, 2013
20:18 PM
reosarevok
(because I didn't read it :p)
2013-05-16 13647, 2013
20:18 PM
hawke_1
certainly has to be up there.
2013-05-16 13658, 2013
20:18 PM
reosarevok
And it's not even for a style guideline
2013-05-16 13600, 2013
20:19 PM
reosarevok
The irony
2013-05-16 13611, 2013
20:19 PM
LordSputnik
well
2013-05-16 13631, 2013
20:19 PM
LordSputnik
I mean, the thread is counted in nabble as the same one as the style guideline
2013-05-16 13638, 2013
20:19 PM
LordSputnik
so it has about 450 posts
2013-05-16 13600, 2013
20:20 PM
LordSputnik
which is quite impressive considering only 5 people are posting regularly :P
2013-05-16 13611, 2013
20:20 PM
Cook880 joined the channel
2013-05-16 13620, 2013
20:21 PM
hawke_1
Once it got past whether the EM waves generated by a moving magnet were technically sound, I gave up.
2013-05-16 13637, 2013
20:22 PM
LordSputnik
reosarevok: :D
2013-05-16 13655, 2013
20:25 PM
hawke_1
2013-05-16 13621, 2013
20:31 PM
SultS joined the channel
2013-05-16 13651, 2013
20:38 PM
luks_ joined the channel
2013-05-16 13626, 2013
20:45 PM
MordredKLB joined the channel
2013-05-16 13646, 2013
20:46 PM
MordredKLB
hey guys, i reported the medium-list count bug and was told there was some discussion going on here about it
2013-05-16 13609, 2013
20:47 PM
kepstin-work
MordredKLB: in the #musicbrainz-devel channel, but yes :)
2013-05-16 13615, 2013
20:47 PM
MordredKLB
aha
2013-05-16 13642, 2013
20:49 PM
STalKer-Y joined the channel
2013-05-16 13654, 2013
20:49 PM
nikki_ joined the channel
2013-05-16 13603, 2013
20:57 PM
mb-chat-logger joined the channel
2013-05-16 13650, 2013
20:59 PM
LordSputnik
hawke_1: ty for that link ;)
2013-05-16 13605, 2013
21:00 PM
LordSputnik
now i just have to remember my forum login :P
2013-05-16 13654, 2013
21:03 PM
hawke_1
LordSputnik: does waveplot have a webservice? would it be hard to expose the DR number on that so that a userscript could look it up?
2013-05-16 13613, 2013
21:04 PM
LordSputnik
hawke_1: not at the moment, but it's something I'm interested in adding
2013-05-16 13632, 2013
21:06 PM
ijabz joined the channel
2013-05-16 13640, 2013
21:13 PM
LordSputnik
hawke_1: didn't you do that with the wiki link last time round too? :P
2013-05-16 13652, 2013
21:13 PM
hawke_1
LordSputnik: yeah, like i said: copy/paste. :-/
2013-05-16 13654, 2013
21:16 PM
jcazevedo joined the channel
2013-05-16 13638, 2013
21:17 PM
STalKer-X joined the channel
2013-05-16 13613, 2013
21:20 PM
drsaunde joined the channel
2013-05-16 13647, 2013
21:33 PM
drsaunde loves long weekends
2013-05-16 13644, 2013
21:34 PM
hawke_1
Can anyone remember any releases that skip track numbers?
2013-05-16 13651, 2013
21:34 PM
hawke_1
I know there are some out there…
2013-05-16 13608, 2013
21:35 PM
hawke_1
there was one that was numbered like powers of two or something.
2013-05-16 13619, 2013
21:40 PM
SultS
2013-05-16 13609, 2013
21:41 PM
hawke_1
That’s the one.
2013-05-16 13635, 2013
21:41 PM
hawke_1
Thank you.
2013-05-16 13626, 2013
21:43 PM
LordSputnik
is that a musical release? 0o
2013-05-16 13631, 2013
21:43 PM
LordSputnik
or spoken?
2013-05-16 13639, 2013
21:43 PM
hawke_1
Music
2013-05-16 13647, 2013
21:43 PM
hawke_1
“(Music from the Film and Inspired By the Book)”
2013-05-16 13622, 2013
21:51 PM
Cook879 joined the channel
2013-05-16 13640, 2013
22:02 PM
reosarevok isn't even going to ask wtf http://musicbrainz.org/edit/22131802
2013-05-16 13622, 2013
22:18 PM
Cook879 joined the channel
2013-05-16 13641, 2013
22:34 PM
Cook880 joined the channel
2013-05-16 13623, 2013
22:37 PM
ijabz joined the channel
2013-05-16 13638, 2013
22:39 PM
hawke_1
Who is Tom Crocker, and what’s with his sudden/recent/intense participation in mb-style?
2013-05-16 13606, 2013
22:40 PM
LordSputnik
hawke_1: he's a new editor
2013-05-16 13609, 2013
22:40 PM
LordSputnik
apparently
2013-05-16 13611, 2013
22:40 PM
LordSputnik
why? :P
2013-05-16 13618, 2013
22:40 PM
LordSputnik
he seems to make sense, which is more than some people :P
2013-05-16 13624, 2013
22:40 PM
hawke_1
Just curious. He’s …yeah, that. :-D
2013-05-16 13621, 2013
22:41 PM
hawke_1
I read his response to the track numbering RFC, and was pleased to see actual useful constructive helpful questions that hadn’t been asked before.
2013-05-16 13606, 2013
22:42 PM
reosarevok
WHAT YOU MEAN YOU DON'T SUCK!
2013-05-16 13615, 2013
22:42 PM
reosarevok
YOUR PROPOSAL IS STUPID!
2013-05-16 13623, 2013
22:42 PM
reosarevok
LET'S NUMBER ALL THE TRACKS 42!
2013-05-16 13640, 2013
22:42 PM
ianweller
uh oh, reo's getting shouty again
2013-05-16 13659, 2013
22:42 PM
reosarevok
:p
2013-05-16 13601, 2013
22:43 PM
hawke_1
reosarevok: well, we’re autoeditors, let’s get started!
2013-05-16 13605, 2013
22:43 PM
reosarevok
I mean
2013-05-16 13606, 2013
22:43 PM
reosarevok
:P!
2013-05-16 13610, 2013
22:43 PM
peaveyman joined the channel
2013-05-16 13610, 2013
22:43 PM
hawke_1
reosarevok: it should only take us…what, 30 years or so?
2013-05-16 13626, 2013
22:43 PM
hawke_1
well, assuming that no one reverts any in that time
2013-05-16 13644, 2013
22:43 PM
reosarevok
:(
2013-05-16 13649, 2013
22:43 PM
reosarevok
I'm out of onion!
2013-05-16 13651, 2013
22:43 PM
reosarevok
Noooooooo
2013-05-16 13610, 2013
22:44 PM
reosarevok
Now I can't make tasty sandwiches for my crazy 42-adding session!
2013-05-16 13624, 2013
22:44 PM
reosarevok
Guess it'll have to stay like it is
2013-05-16 13620, 2013
22:47 PM
hawke_1
Oh well.
2013-05-16 13637, 2013
23:08 PM
ianmcorvidae
I wonder how long it'd take to write a script to generate all the edits so I could just do UPDATE TRACK SET number = '42'; :P
2013-05-16 13646, 2013
23:08 PM
ianmcorvidae
er UPDATE track
2013-05-16 13647, 2013
23:08 PM
ianmcorvidae
but
2013-05-16 13619, 2013
23:09 PM
ianmcorvidae
I guess it'd be entirely 'edit medium' edits :P
2013-05-16 13644, 2013
23:09 PM
drsaunde
c'mon now ian...no distractions..get those areas added
2013-05-16 13650, 2013
23:09 PM
ianmcorvidae
:P
2013-05-16 13632, 2013
23:12 PM
LordSputnik
2013-05-16 13620, 2013
23:13 PM
Lotheric_
2013-05-16 13634, 2013
23:13 PM
Lotheric_
couln't resist :)
2013-05-16 13642, 2013
23:13 PM
LordSputnik
Lotheric_: I linked first! :P
2013-05-16 13659, 2013
23:15 PM
Lotheric_
LordSputnik: you are bold to tackle artists like The Beatles
2013-05-16 13610, 2013
23:16 PM
Lotheric_ edit more obscure bands
2013-05-16 13611, 2013
23:16 PM
LordSputnik
Lotheric_: it's what I do :P
2013-05-16 13627, 2013
23:17 PM
LordSputnik
they'll be a lot tidier over the next few weeks when I can use the new rec. guideline :)
2013-05-16 13631, 2013
23:18 PM
Lotheric
Is there a beta guideline wiki sometwhere ?
2013-05-16 13614, 2013
23:19 PM
LordSputnik
what do you mean?
2013-05-16 13627, 2013
23:19 PM
LordSputnik
for recordings?
2013-05-16 13633, 2013
23:19 PM
Lotheric
a draft, someone prolly put a draft of the guideline on their user page or something
2013-05-16 13635, 2013
23:19 PM
Lotheric
yeah
2013-05-16 13636, 2013
23:19 PM
LordSputnik
2013-05-16 13639, 2013
23:19 PM
Lotheric
I'd like to take a look
2013-05-16 13644, 2013
23:19 PM
Lotheric
thanks
2013-05-16 13653, 2013
23:19 PM
LordSputnik
it's passed and just waiting for a few dependencies
2013-05-16 13659, 2013
23:19 PM
Lotheric
ok
2013-05-16 13635, 2013
23:23 PM
Lotheric
What do you mean by that : "Audio recordings of the same performance from different sources will always have different audio." ?
2013-05-16 13648, 2013
23:23 PM
Lotheric
source as in CD, vinyl ?
2013-05-16 13651, 2013
23:23 PM
LordSputnik
if you record a performance with two devices
2013-05-16 13657, 2013
23:23 PM
LordSputnik
eg. a mobile phone and an ipod
2013-05-16 13657, 2013
23:23 PM
Lotheric
ah ok
2013-05-16 13659, 2013
23:23 PM
demosdemon joined the channel
2013-05-16 13600, 2013
23:24 PM
Lotheric
I see
2013-05-16 13603, 2013
23:24 PM
LordSputnik
:)
2013-05-16 13639, 2013
23:24 PM
Lotheric
well, it looks good
2013-05-16 13624, 2013
23:25 PM
reosarevok
Two bootlegs of the same show is the obvious example
2013-05-16 13650, 2013
23:25 PM
Lotheric
clean and dirty versions, separate ?
2013-05-16 13659, 2013
23:25 PM
Lotheric
censored vs. uncensored
2013-05-16 13616, 2013
23:26 PM
LordSputnik
yeah, that's the radio edit bit :)
2013-05-16 13629, 2013
23:26 PM
LordSputnik
2013-05-16 13643, 2013
23:26 PM
LordSputnik
"and/or by censoring some of the content"
2013-05-16 13651, 2013
23:26 PM
Lotheric
but sometimes it's not just beeps (editing), it's new lyrics altogether i.e 2 live crew
2013-05-16 13608, 2013
23:27 PM
LordSputnik
that'd make it a different mix
2013-05-16 13614, 2013
23:27 PM
LordSputnik
so still separate
2013-05-16 13618, 2013
23:27 PM
Lotheric
of the same recording ?
2013-05-16 13624, 2013
23:27 PM
Lotheric
ok that's what I thought
2013-05-16 13639, 2013
23:27 PM
LordSputnik
generally, use common sense and it'll be right
2013-05-16 13643, 2013
23:27 PM
LordSputnik
(mostly)
2013-05-16 13634, 2013
23:36 PM
hawke_1
LordSputnik: I’d keep ’em separate, it seems like an edit to me.
2013-05-16 13653, 2013
23:36 PM
LordSputnik
yeah probably
2013-05-16 13646, 2013
23:41 PM
Kabaka joined the channel
2013-05-16 13655, 2013
23:47 PM
Lotheric
:)
2013-05-16 13614, 2013
23:48 PM
Kabaka joined the channel
2013-05-16 13617, 2013
23:48 PM
Lotheric
I'm fetching acousID
2013-05-16 13634, 2013
23:51 PM
drsaunde
is stereo/mono going to be the same or separate?
2013-05-16 13615, 2013
23:55 PM
reosarevok
separate
2013-05-16 13636, 2013
23:55 PM
reosarevok
Channels are separate "except when downmixing" or something like that
