#musicbrainz

/

      • Mxx
        "recording" would be same as linking tracks to 'earliest release'?
      • 2011-03-23 08221, 2011

      • reosarevok
        That's part of it, yeah
      • 2011-03-23 08225, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Instead of having 10 tracks linked
      • 2011-03-23 08229, 2011

      • reosarevok
        We'd have one recording
      • 2011-03-23 08235, 2011

      • reosarevok
        And all the ARs would go there
      • 2011-03-23 08249, 2011

      • reosarevok
        (well, most of them… some would go on works, which are a level over that)
      • 2011-03-23 08219, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Which means you only have to add once who sang in the track, and it will be used in all the appearances of that track
      • 2011-03-23 08222, 2011

      • reosarevok
        For example
      • 2011-03-23 08243, 2011

      • nomike__ joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08223, 2011

      • Mxx
        so it's artist > works > recording > track ?
      • 2011-03-23 08226, 2011

      • reosarevok
      • 2011-03-23 08232, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Kinda, yeah
      • 2011-03-23 08238, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Not exactly, but kinda
      • 2011-03-23 08244, 2011

      • Mxx
        alrighty, i'll need ot read that
      • 2011-03-23 08253, 2011

      • Mxx
        but speaking of that, i'm late for work.. :)
      • 2011-03-23 08255, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Mxx: the recording examples are kinda crappy, as there is discussion of remixes being different works instead (I'm not sure if an agreement was reached already)
      • 2011-03-23 08258, 2011

      • reosarevok
        heh
      • 2011-03-23 08202, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Don't lose your work!
      • 2011-03-23 08204, 2011

      • reosarevok
        :)
      • 2011-03-23 08232, 2011

      • Mxx
        i won't. boss doesn't mind
      • 2011-03-23 08222, 2011

      • Mxx
        just feels wrong when all the other peons have to be in the office by 9 but i come in 'whenever' :p
      • 2011-03-23 08210, 2011

      • jonsen
        oh i know that :)
      • 2011-03-23 08228, 2011

      • caller_6 joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08246, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08211, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08231, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08206, 2011

      • jonsen joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08224, 2011

      • Krystof joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08211, 2011

      • ppawel joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08259, 2011

      • hawke__ joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08206, 2011

      • lugo joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08244, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08226, 2011

      • _Dave joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08204, 2011

      • antgel_ joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08205, 2011

      • Krystof joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08202, 2011

      • outsidecontext has left the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08234, 2011

      • PasNox joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08206, 2011

      • ruaok joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08251, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08252, 2011

      • Mineo joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08219, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08226, 2011

      • kaiarneg joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08205, 2011

      • ruaok joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08209, 2011

      • ppawel joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08255, 2011

      • Muz joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08206, 2011

      • chrisb` joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08233, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08214, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08210, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08236, 2011

      • Freso joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08203, 2011

      • caller_6 is re-reading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_metal_umlaut
      • 2011-03-23 08238, 2011

      • nikki
        öḧ ÿëäḧ?
      • 2011-03-23 08214, 2011

      • caller_6
        It's like "Sound of Music"... it should be a once-a-year treat
      • 2011-03-23 08224, 2011

      • Tecfan
        ïnẗërësẗïng rëäd
      • 2011-03-23 08231, 2011

      • nikki
        bah. the one below the letter isn't on this keyboard
      • 2011-03-23 08205, 2011

      • Tecfan
        here's a fix
      • 2011-03-23 08207, 2011

      • Tecfan
        o
      • 2011-03-23 08210, 2011

      • Tecfan
      • 2011-03-23 08231, 2011

      • nikki
        meh :P
      • 2011-03-23 08208, 2011

      • caller_6
        nikki: ocharles says that Artist Credits don't have sortnames. For individual "name variants" that makes sense. The Artist's main sortname should work.
      • 2011-03-23 08256, 2011

      • caller_6
        but what about collaborations? How will those be sorted?
      • 2011-03-23 08217, 2011

      • nikki
        artist a's sortname joinphrase artist b's sortname?
      • 2011-03-23 08202, 2011

      • caller_6
        automatically generated?
      • 2011-03-23 08246, 2011

      • nikki
        I don't think we do it right now, but in theory we could (and so could picard)
      • 2011-03-23 08207, 2011

      • caller_6
        I suppose taking it from artist "a" is better than nothing.
      • 2011-03-23 08219, 2011

      • caller_6
        thanks
      • 2011-03-23 08217, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08252, 2011

      • hawke__ joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08258, 2011

      • reosarevok joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08240, 2011

      • Krystof joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08254, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08243, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08216, 2011

      • nomike__ joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08248, 2011

      • _bibi joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08220, 2011

      • hawke__
        nikki: Is there even a sensible way to handle collaboration sortnames?
      • 2011-03-23 08234, 2011

      • nikki
        probably not :P
      • 2011-03-23 08240, 2011

      • hawke__
        nikki: I’m honestly not sure that there’s much use to sortnames at all, really.
      • 2011-03-23 08259, 2011

      • nikki hates sortnames as they're currently implemented
      • 2011-03-23 08201, 2011

      • hawke__
        Other than making things look somewhat prettier when presenting a list, I guess.
      • 2011-03-23 08216, 2011

      • hawke__
        Hasn’t searching more-or-less obsoleted the sortname?
      • 2011-03-23 08229, 2011

      • nikki
        no, I like being able to find things in my music player too
      • 2011-03-23 08252, 2011

      • nikki
        they would be really useful for chinese and japanese, but for japanese at least, everything's just sorted even more strangely than before
      • 2011-03-23 08208, 2011

      • hawke__
        Don’t most music players allow searching within the playlist or library or what-have-you?
      • 2011-03-23 08226, 2011

      • nikki
        assuming you remember exactly which characters the artist uses, and can type them
      • 2011-03-23 08214, 2011

      • hawke__
        Ah, for Japanese true.
      • 2011-03-23 08219, 2011

      • nikki
        and not all players...
      • 2011-03-23 08232, 2011

      • nikki
        my sansa fuze doesn't have a way to search
      • 2011-03-23 08235, 2011

      • hawke__
        Though sorting by latin transliteration isn’t exactly helpful there either.
      • 2011-03-23 08241, 2011

      • hawke__
        is it?
      • 2011-03-23 08226, 2011

      • nikki
        well, to some extent it helps, since even I don't know unicode order for all of the han characters
      • 2011-03-23 08253, 2011

      • nikki
        but like I said, it's strange
      • 2011-03-23 08240, 2011

      • nikki
        I'm used to japanese names being sorted using japanese sort order, or romanised versions sorted using normal english order
      • 2011-03-23 08259, 2011

      • hawke__
        Right.
      • 2011-03-23 08233, 2011

      • gnu_andrew
        wow MB users are morbidly quick at times: http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=14240899
      • 2011-03-23 08219, 2011

      • nikki
        you mean you haven't heard about someone dying and immediately rushed to mb to try and add it before anyone else does?
      • 2011-03-23 08230, 2011

      • nikki hasn't yet succeeded :P
      • 2011-03-23 08254, 2011

      • caller_6 knows somebody who writes obits for a large newspaper. He has a huge back-catalog of interviews that he's done for the purpose. /Usually/ the subject doesn't guess why he/she is being interviewed. Other times, well... awkward.
      • 2011-03-23 08208, 2011

      • gnu_andrew
        nikki, that's what I was doing... much too slow though
      • 2011-03-23 08221, 2011

      • nikki
        :)
      • 2011-03-23 08245, 2011

      • nikki
        I heard about it around the same time the edit was entered
      • 2011-03-23 08211, 2011

      • nikki
        I can't quite tell though, 'cause the server time is messed up and I don't remember what time it is really
      • 2011-03-23 08246, 2011

      • gnu_andrew
        yeah I wasn't sure what timezone the edit was in
      • 2011-03-23 08207, 2011

      • gnu_andrew
        I was out, just came home and saw the news
      • 2011-03-23 08229, 2011

      • gnu_andrew
        failed miserably on Jacko too though and I was here for that one
      • 2011-03-23 08213, 2011

      • nikki
        I was randomly listening to the radio in german while eating lunch (at 3pm :P) and it was about the only thing I *did* understand
      • 2011-03-23 08209, 2011

      • reosarevok
        I failed miserably on a Spanish flamenco singer
      • 2011-03-23 08215, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Was beaten to it by a Canadian
      • 2011-03-23 08220, 2011

      • nikki
        tsk tsk
      • 2011-03-23 08226, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Now that was weird
      • 2011-03-23 08205, 2011

      • DarkAudit joined the channel
      • 2011-03-23 08240, 2011

      • KRSCuan
        I don't think I've ever hunted for that kind of edit…
      • 2011-03-23 08224, 2011

      • KRSCuan
        Though I've managed to announce a Eurovision Song Contest Winner on Wikipedia before anyone else could.
      • 2011-03-23 08228, 2011

      • KRSCuan
        >___>
      • 2011-03-23 08214, 2011

      • hawke__
        Regarding the Elizabeth Taylor edit, I do wonder why it’s necessary to have the birth/death years in the comment.
      • 2011-03-23 08208, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Is there a reason for having a comment at all
      • 2011-03-23 08209, 2011

      • reosarevok
        ?
      • 2011-03-23 08222, 2011

      • reosarevok
        (I haven't checked if there are more Elizabeth Taylors)
      • 2011-03-23 08223, 2011

      • hawke__
        Also, I freaking hate it when autoeditors put in an autoedit after someone else already has one pending.
      • 2011-03-23 08225, 2011

      • hawke__
        There are.
      • 2011-03-23 08252, 2011

      • nikki
        hawke__: comment on the edit then (and if there's still one open, ask them to revert their changes)
      • 2011-03-23 08223, 2011

      • nikki
        after all, auto-editors can just approve the open edit
      • 2011-03-23 08210, 2011

      • hawke__
        This is why I don’t like autoedits/editors.
      • 2011-03-23 08228, 2011

      • nikki
        without them, mb would be open edit hell
      • 2011-03-23 08249, 2011

      • hawke__
        Much as I’d like to be one, as of course I would *never* abuse my power. ;-)
      • 2011-03-23 08254, 2011

      • hawke__
        “would be”?
      • 2011-03-23 08208, 2011

      • nikki
        worse than it already is :P
      • 2011-03-23 08209, 2011

      • hawke__
        There’s not much harm in having open edits anyway.
      • 2011-03-23 08253, 2011

      • nikki
        the more open edits there are, the fewer people ever see... and if nobody sees them, they might as well just apply when they're entered instead of applying two weeks later :P
      • 2011-03-23 08227, 2011

      • gnu_andrew
      • 2011-03-23 08235, 2011

      • gnu_andrew
        reosarevok, but I think having the years is overkill
      • 2011-03-23 08215, 2011

      • reosarevok
        I think that comment is fairly useless, actually
      • 2011-03-23 08222, 2011

      • hawke__
      • 2011-03-23 08232, 2011

      • reosarevok
        I mean, I kinda know who Elizabeth Taylor is, but had no idea she's a Dame
      • 2011-03-23 08233, 2011

      • reosarevok
        :p
      • 2011-03-23 08256, 2011

      • nikki
        holy crap. 71,105 edits in the last fortnight
      • 2011-03-23 08208, 2011

      • reosarevok
        hawke_: a fairly Korean comment
      • 2011-03-23 08227, 2011

      • reosarevok
        What is it replying to?
      • 2011-03-23 08239, 2011

      • gnu_andrew
        hawke_, the thing is to not auto-edit requires remembering to untick the autoediting checkbox for the edit. I guess sometimes people just forget.
      • 2011-03-23 08224, 2011

      • hawke__
      • 2011-03-23 08236, 2011

      • nikki
        it's more about noticing that it's highlighted and therefore has pending edits
      • 2011-03-23 08203, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Oh, that makes more sense. Voted
      • 2011-03-23 08226, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Hmm
      • 2011-03-23 08232, 2011

      • hawke__
        gnu_andrew: I’m a bit surprised that the autoedit checkbox doesn’t default to off.
      • 2011-03-23 08236, 2011

      • gnu_andrew
        hawke_, ah no you beat me to it
      • 2011-03-23 08250, 2011

      • reosarevok
      • 2011-03-23 08255, 2011

      • reosarevok
        Actually
      • 2011-03-23 08201, 2011

      • reosarevok
        This artist is empty!
      • 2011-03-23 08220, 2011

      • gnu_andrew
        in some cases it isn't obvious there is stuff pending or easy to get at the edits
      • 2011-03-23 08206, 2011

      • reosarevok
        (the only AR she had was actually for the 50's Broadway artist, it seems)
      • 2011-03-23 08250, 2011

      • hawke__
        reosarevok: that’s really funny…so she probably doesn’t even belong in Musicbrainz?