#musicbrainz

luks: is there a way to find out which files it hasn't submitted fingerprints for?

luks: you might want to change your vote on http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=14422571

won't it fail anyway, with a stunning 15 No votes?

yes, but it's better if we can close it now

'cause the fewer edits there are, the easier it is to see which ones we can approve and which will just fail

flamingspinach: what about the doubly stunning 34 no votes from the previous link? :D

then we should track down KeithIrwin and cooperaa too, no?

I already sent cooperaa an email

(wasn't going to comment and spam everyone ;))

meh

reosarevok: haha whoa

now I'll send this keith guy one too

unless he's in here

why would you vote yes on that...

actually why would you even make that edit... too bad there's no edit summary to tell us :P

flamingspinach: are you not going to add to all the no votes then? :P

that just seems opportunistic :P

aww

I feel guilty about not voting no on the unsung bad edits that doubtless slip by all the time...

this edit freeze does have the benefit that it made people (other than me) start voting on edits :P

I guess I'm only in the second layer of ruaok's onion (as described at https://jhemerly.wordpress.com/robert-kaye-inte... ) so I don't have much of an opinion on most edits, so I don't usually vote...

flamingspinach: yeah. It's a shame that NGS is going to launch such an amount of work and recording merges upon us that nobody will have the willpower to vote on them :(

I read that as "so I don't have much of an onion on most edits"

lol

that too is a true statement

We could end world hunger

although the world would be much smellier

Oh, but you see

They'd be cut already!

That's why we would have much of an onion, not a full onion

:D

they'd probably still hurt my eyes

Pasta with onions, rice with onions, potatoes with onions, bread with onions

Well, I actually haven't tried cereals with onions

haha

Probably for the best

hmm

it's been a long time since I had red onios

onions too

I always get white ones

aww

White onions are boring

I wonder if I've even seen red ones here...

How could I submit tag name corrections (and other metadata) corrections to the database? Is getting an account and using picard sufficient?

alex-hu: at the moment you can't edit (we're in the middle of closing all edits so we can do a big upgrade)

Normally, you don't even need Picard, as long as you have an account

but yes, you just need an account and then you can edit on the website

You need time, willingness and sources

Especially sources

:)

What do you mean by sources? Original rips?

Nope

Something that proves the changes

(be it scans, URLs, whatever. some kind of proof)

link to discogs listing of album, amazon, scan of cd back cover showing tracklist, or artist's official discography entry for the album is normally what is used

to show that your correction is in fact correct

usually not hard to come by

aah, ok; no problem with that ;-)

there is some kind of plugin for picard which uploads your tags as an add release edit

the add cluster as release one

yup, that one

orly?

nice

the limit was increased a few weeks back

Yeah

But will it work in NGS?

i wish there was a plugin to do a straight up discogs release import

nikki: really? why?

sounds like a good idea - we have freedb stubs, why not discogs stubs?

for good quality releases it's such a waste of time having to copy and paste the data over manually

even with a track parser

yeah

exactly

'cause the limit broken a few things which submit a bunch of data using get :)

I think for ngs we'd just need picard to display a box with a copyable tracklist

and discogs has way better metadata than freedb

anything has better metadata than freedb :P

exactly

yeah, no kidding

also would be nice if it auto-linked releases to url's in 'add release' edit notes

if they're recognized

it'd be better to be able to add the relationships when adding a release

half the time it's an amazon or discogs url, why do I have to go and add a relationship manually if i already noted it in the edit note as proof

I mean... I could link to amazon saying "it doesn't appear to be this version", I wouldn't want it to automatically add an amazon relationship ;)

Do I instruct picard about genres somehow (I'm aware that they're not stored on the server; from faq), or is it assumed that I should continue tagging my music after tagging it with picard?

nikki: true

nikki: but at least it could say "hey, you had these url's in the edit note; do you want me to auto-link it now"

and default to no

alex-hu: genre stuff is kinda iffy and very very ill-defined, so picard doesn't do anything with genres for you by default

"by default"; does it mean, I could still use picard to add such tags?

alex-hu: but there's a plugin for picard that will use folksonomy tags from last.fm and/or musicbrainz and populate your 'genre' field with the most popular tags

iirc

alex-hu: yeah, with that plugin you could

basically

hmm; ok. I'll do it manually then ;-)

alex-hu: yeah, everybody has their own conventions of how they want to use the genre filed, so it's kinda left wide open

I just don't use it, I don't see any conceivable use for the genre tag

yeah i don't use it either

it's way too limiting

maybe, it's a good idea -- to forgo the tag in the file; thank you, that's how I'll do it

*genre tag*

alex-hu: i mean if you actually need them, you can still tag them in itunes or your preferred music player.

I think, if I ever need them, they'll be added in through some metadata.xml file in the directory or such.

but for myself, it's both "how do I tag this mix of electro/dubstep/folk", and "damn, this genre is so precise it's useless for finding related stuff"

if i were to use it, I would probably go with "top 3 genre tags from last.fm for this artist"

well, something like ambient + noise or dark ambient + noise is quite useful

but even that fails when you have an artist whose albums are in different genres

yeah i guess i'm just used to mentally organizing it by artist name, instead of genre

So, is there some application that I could use to submit my changes adjustments in batch, after I finished tagging the collection?

alex-hu: genre changes?

no, minor title changes

right now the only way to submit edits is through the website

for instance, http://musicbrainz.org/release/ddeb0348-b94a-41... has all caps in track 9, but on the cover it's "Rsaa"

well capitalization changes are auto-edits

ie, they do not require voting

so that you can fix and it will immediately show up when you reload the release in picard

normally the flow is 1) make edits/add release on website; 2) use picard to tag your files with data form website

once you've tagged the files with picard, they store the MBID in track metadata

so if there are changes to the data on the website, if you re-run the files through picard, they will pick up any changes from website.

does MBID change from adjustments to the work?

nope

mbid is permanent

aah, I see; that's great then