#musicbrainz

/

      • MClemo
      • 2007-11-13 31718, 2007

      • juhae
        and viewing the spectrums
      • 2007-11-13 31726, 2007

      • FauxFaux
        Hydrogen audio says just looking at the spectra for >20khz or <16khz immediately spots nonmp3s.
      • 2007-11-13 31732, 2007

      • FauxFaux
        Can obviously be faked, though. :)
      • 2007-11-13 31745, 2007

      • Russss
      • 2007-11-13 31752, 2007

      • Russss
        heh
      • 2007-11-13 31708, 2007

      • juhae
        Heh, cheers guys
      • 2007-11-13 31743, 2007

      • Russss
        I swear there was another one though
      • 2007-11-13 31716, 2007

      • `duckman joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31720, 2007

      • MClemo
        that Tau Analyzer I have used myself
      • 2007-11-13 31723, 2007

      • MClemo
        works quite good
      • 2007-11-13 31742, 2007

      • MClemo
        I think AUCDtect is the same only for wavs
      • 2007-11-13 31727, 2007

      • hangy joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31729, 2007

      • stochasticism has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31711, 2007

      • CatCat
        nikki: yeh, but i dont need that, it only needs to open up the browser to get the toc, thats all the interface really neded
      • 2007-11-13 31712, 2007

      • nikki
        hmm, it only gives an url at the moment...
      • 2007-11-13 31717, 2007

      • CatCat
        yes
      • 2007-11-13 31720, 2007

      • nikki will poke it later
      • 2007-11-13 31724, 2007

      • CatCat
        thats what i nead :D
      • 2007-11-13 31723, 2007

      • Igor_6667 has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31744, 2007

      • SerialNumber
        SerialNumber has joined #MusicBrainz
      • 2007-11-13 31744, 2007

      • Igor_6667 joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31735, 2007

      • UserErr0r joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31727, 2007

      • stochasticism joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31703, 2007

      • SerialNumber^ has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31721, 2007

      • CyberSnooP has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31724, 2007

      • CatCat
      • 2007-11-13 31712, 2007

      • stochasticism has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31725, 2007

      • metafollic has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31756, 2007

      • `duckman has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31748, 2007

      • symphonick joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31752, 2007

      • FauxFaux
        CatCat: \o/
      • 2007-11-13 31715, 2007

      • brianfreud has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31720, 2007

      • brianfreud joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31702, 2007

      • aCiD2 joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31751, 2007

      • BrianG joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31719, 2007

      • CatCat
        o_O
      • 2007-11-13 31727, 2007

      • CatCat
        FauxFaux: /o\
      • 2007-11-13 31737, 2007

      • SerialNumber^
        SerialNumber^ has joined #MusicBrainz
      • 2007-11-13 31728, 2007

      • CatCat points people towards http://www.pop.nu/en/index.asp
      • 2007-11-13 31739, 2007

      • CatCat
        very interesting site
      • 2007-11-13 31749, 2007

      • BrianG
        what is it?
      • 2007-11-13 31755, 2007

      • BrianG
        i looked but not sure i follow
      • 2007-11-13 31704, 2007

      • SerialNumber has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31706, 2007

      • LotR
        it's a 'these are my records' type thing, no?
      • 2007-11-13 31725, 2007

      • BrianG
        ah
      • 2007-11-13 31758, 2007

      • BrianG
      • 2007-11-13 31703, 2007

      • MBChatLogger
        I hate the evil empire
      • 2007-11-13 31703, 2007

      • juhae
        Type mismatch
      • 2007-11-13 31706, 2007

      • juhae
        /en/numbers.asp, line 76
      • 2007-11-13 31707, 2007

      • juhae
        :p
      • 2007-11-13 31709, 2007

      • BrianG
        so sexy
      • 2007-11-13 31704, 2007

      • LotR
        hrm, someone at rateyourmusic sucks. not giving pj 5 stars is heresy!
      • 2007-11-13 31706, 2007

      • CatCat
        but the thing is, you can add your own very simply
      • 2007-11-13 31717, 2007

      • CatCat
        catalogue number and everything
      • 2007-11-13 31723, 2007

      • BrianG
        rym too
      • 2007-11-13 31724, 2007

      • CatCat
        differnt versions of the same
      • 2007-11-13 31723, 2007

      • CatCat
        you are not limited to releases only on amazon
      • 2007-11-13 31711, 2007

      • BrianG
        rym too :)
      • 2007-11-13 31718, 2007

      • Bad_Seed joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31704, 2007

      • Igor_6667 has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31746, 2007

      • bplat1 joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31723, 2007

      • robevans
        can musicbrainz be used to test if an mp3 is copyrighted / legal?
      • 2007-11-13 31714, 2007

      • warp
        robevans: afaik, more or less everything is copyrighted.
      • 2007-11-13 31740, 2007

      • warp
        robevans: in my country, an mp3 cannot be legal in itself. only the act of distributing it to other persons is illegal.
      • 2007-11-13 31748, 2007

      • warp
        erm, cannot be illegal in itself.
      • 2007-11-13 31707, 2007

      • robevans
        warp, hrm. Maybe I can restate the question.
      • 2007-11-13 31718, 2007

      • warp
        sorry if i'm nitpicking :)
      • 2007-11-13 31739, 2007

      • robevans
        I want to let people upload mp3s to a server but I want to validate that the songs are not pirated.
      • 2007-11-13 31725, 2007

      • warp
        anyway, for any given release or track in musicbrainz, you _can_ link to a creativecommons license. so for those, you can programmatically figure out that their authors allow the work to be used in certain ways.
      • 2007-11-13 31726, 2007

      • robevans
        I was thinking there might be a service that would be able to compare a signature of track to a database of known songs.
      • 2007-11-13 31758, 2007

      • robevans
        Obviously, this approach has holes in it but we have to try. ;-)
      • 2007-11-13 31704, 2007

      • robevans
        Thoughts?
      • 2007-11-13 31709, 2007

      • warp
        but, ofcourse authors could allow their music to be used with some other liberal copyright license, and we have no way to record that currently.
      • 2007-11-13 31742, 2007

      • warp
        and obviously, not everything which has a CC license currently has a CC license link.
      • 2007-11-13 31742, 2007

      • warp
        i don't think musicbrainz would be much help atm, but perhaps you can talk to ruaok to see if you think it would be useful for musicbrainz to move in such a direction.
      • 2007-11-13 31750, 2007

      • xlotlu
        umm, this a bug.. PBCC: http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=7814364.. or that's the way the change is supposed to look like?
      • 2007-11-13 31747, 2007

      • SerialNumber
        SerialNumber has joined #MusicBrainz
      • 2007-11-13 31748, 2007

      • inhouseuk
        that's the way those edits display. You can click the [info] link to determine what object it is attached to.
      • 2007-11-13 31743, 2007

      • xlotlu
        well, shouldn't've cancelled it then :)
      • 2007-11-13 31704, 2007

      • SerialNumber^ has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31756, 2007

      • Shepard` joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31726, 2007

      • Shepard has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31727, 2007

      • Shepard`
        Shepard` is now known as Shepard
      • 2007-11-13 31721, 2007

      • hangy has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31709, 2007

      • pae joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31712, 2007

      • pae
        hello
      • 2007-11-13 31719, 2007

      • pae
        does picard support shn files?
      • 2007-11-13 31754, 2007

      • xlotlu
        there's no such thing as a release alias?
      • 2007-11-13 31710, 2007

      • Shepard
        xlotlu: nope
      • 2007-11-13 31752, 2007

      • MClemo
        pae: but you can transcode to a format that is supported ;)
      • 2007-11-13 31712, 2007

      • pae
        MClemo: I know :)
      • 2007-11-13 31715, 2007

      • BrianG
        shortenn isn't even an audio codec
      • 2007-11-13 31710, 2007

      • Shepard` joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31744, 2007

      • Kerensky97 joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31750, 2007

      • Shepard has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31751, 2007

      • Shepard`
        Shepard` is now known as Shepard
      • 2007-11-13 31737, 2007

      • Knio has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31709, 2007

      • SerialNumber^
        SerialNumber^ has joined #MusicBrainz
      • 2007-11-13 31719, 2007

      • deadchip has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31754, 2007

      • Knio joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31734, 2007

      • SerialNumber has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31750, 2007

      • Muzzz mooooooses
      • 2007-11-13 31742, 2007

      • Shepard` joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31724, 2007

      • Shepard has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31724, 2007

      • Shepard`
        Shepard` is now known as Shepard
      • 2007-11-13 31730, 2007

      • bplat1
        bplat1 is now known as bplatt_
      • 2007-11-13 31718, 2007

      • pae has left the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31748, 2007

      • Aankhen`` has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31730, 2007

      • _julian__ joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31748, 2007

      • SerialNumber
        SerialNumber has joined #MusicBrainz
      • 2007-11-13 31741, 2007

      • dalen joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31757, 2007

      • SerialNumber^ has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31714, 2007

      • _julian_ has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31730, 2007

      • demonhunter joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31755, 2007

      • BrianG
        w00t.. one member away from 50 on th e MB facebook group
      • 2007-11-13 31754, 2007

      • CatCat
        ëë facebook
      • 2007-11-13 31732, 2007

      • FauxFaux
        Eeew, facebook!
      • 2007-11-13 31701, 2007

      • BrianG
        yeah.. eww.. people are gross!
      • 2007-11-13 31700, 2007

      • aCiD2
        Yehaw, faceboooook
      • 2007-11-13 31725, 2007

      • Muzzz
        BrianG: link me, I'll join :P
      • 2007-11-13 31725, 2007

      • BrianG
      • 2007-11-13 31754, 2007

      • Muzzz
        Yay 50 members
      • 2007-11-13 31707, 2007

      • CatCat
        FauxFaux \o/
      • 2007-11-13 31710, 2007

      • CatCat
        ponis
      • 2007-11-13 31724, 2007

      • FauxFaux
        Someone else made me sign-into facebook, bastards.
      • 2007-11-13 31730, 2007

      • CatCat
        eeew
      • 2007-11-13 31737, 2007

      • CatCat
        dakars
      • 2007-11-13 31757, 2007

      • CatCat
        i need teh nights
      • 2007-11-13 31704, 2007

      • CatCat
        natta
      • 2007-11-13 31705, 2007

      • BrianG
        i'm poking the Muzzz
      • 2007-11-13 31709, 2007

      • Muzzz
        :O
      • 2007-11-13 31703, 2007

      • symphonick has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31706, 2007

      • Muzzz
        Some random French guy whom I don't know has tried adding me. Oh my.
      • 2007-11-13 31727, 2007

      • sylvinus joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31704, 2007

      • CatCat
      • 2007-11-13 31729, 2007

      • demonhunter has quit
      • 2007-11-13 31741, 2007

      • FauxFaux ponders doing stuff to 'Daft Punk' - 'Face to Face (feat. Todd Edwards)' from 'Discovery' [2001-02-26].
      • 2007-11-13 31705, 2007

      • brianfreud
        I'm confused... how are flac and ttc codecs, but shn isn't?
      • 2007-11-13 31725, 2007

      • brianfreud
        *tta, not ttc
      • 2007-11-13 31722, 2007

      • Igor_6667 joined the channel
      • 2007-11-13 31710, 2007

      • FauxFaux
        Never heard of it, is it a container like ogg?
      • 2007-11-13 31726, 2007

      • FauxFaux
        Oh, shn as in shorten, no idea. ¬_¬
      • 2007-11-13 31700, 2007

      • brianfreud
        yeah, I was wondering from [15:10] <BrianG> shortenn isn't even an audio codec
      • 2007-11-13 31737, 2007

      • FauxFaux
        He lies! Geddim!
      • 2007-11-13 31741, 2007

      • brianfreud
        lol
      • 2007-11-13 31747, 2007

      • BrianG
        it's not a media format it's a storage format
      • 2007-11-13 31722, 2007

      • BrianG
        it could only play in some media players due to a hack
      • 2007-11-13 31752, 2007

      • brianfreud
        what's it a storage format for then? Always thought shn was "just another lossless codec", like flac, tta, etc
      • 2007-11-13 31703, 2007

      • BrianG
        .zip .rar