#musicbrainz

/

0:11 AM
Shepard has quit

2007-11-21 32507, 2007

0:14 AM
Compressed joined the channel

2007-11-21 32525, 2007

0:19 AM
brianfreud

hmmm, odd - seems the merged release lost the toc on merge??? http://musicbrainz.org/release/4c4fa0e1-0593-43e8…

2007-11-21 32518, 2007

0:29 AM
SerialNumber^ joined the channel

2007-11-21 32550, 2007

0:45 AM
SerialNumber has quit

2007-11-21 32531, 2007

0:57 AM
pankkake has quit

2007-11-21 32501, 2007

0:59 AM
drsaunde has quit

2007-11-21 32545, 2007

0:59 AM
pankkake

pankkake has joined #MusicBrainz

2007-11-21 32539, 2007

1:02 AM
aCiD2 has quit

2007-11-21 32557, 2007

1:10 AM
yllona has quit

2007-11-21 32525, 2007

1:14 AM
dholmes

Can we get a "Tag" search on the left sidebar? That would be great.

2007-11-21 32535, 2007

1:14 AM
UncleRem1s joined the channel

2007-11-21 32502, 2007

1:19 AM
UncleRemus has quit

2007-11-21 32509, 2007

1:33 AM
drsaunde joined the channel

2007-11-21 32549, 2007

1:49 AM
Rondom has quit

2007-11-21 32522, 2007

2:01 AM
Kerensky97 has left the channel

2007-11-21 32536, 2007

2:01 AM
MrQwerty`

MrQwerty` is now known as MrQwerty

2007-11-21 32506, 2007

2:31 AM
SerialNumber joined the channel

2007-11-21 32538, 2007

2:48 AM
SerialNumber^ has quit

2007-11-21 32556, 2007

2:54 AM
UserErr0r joined the channel

2007-11-21 32510, 2007

3:12 AM
JanC joined the channel

2007-11-21 32553, 2007

3:37 AM
SerialNumber^ joined the channel

2007-11-21 32543, 2007

3:47 AM
Knio1 joined the channel

2007-11-21 32528, 2007

3:48 AM
Knio has quit

2007-11-21 32529, 2007

3:48 AM
Knio1

Knio1 is now known as Knio

2007-11-21 32515, 2007

3:55 AM
SerialNumber has quit

2007-11-21 32506, 2007

4:20 AM
brianfreud has quit

2007-11-21 32515, 2007

4:20 AM
brianfreud joined the channel

2007-11-21 32521, 2007

4:29 AM
Amblin joined the channel

2007-11-21 32555, 2007

4:41 AM
Amblin- has quit

2007-11-21 32500, 2007

5:42 AM
xlotlu has quit

2007-11-21 32509, 2007

5:42 AM
xlotlu joined the channel

2007-11-21 32518, 2007

5:46 AM
Shepard joined the channel

2007-11-21 32540, 2007

6:38 AM
`Spike has quit

2007-11-21 32545, 2007

6:51 AM
`Spike joined the channel

2007-11-21 32552, 2007

7:02 AM
Dhraakellian joined the channel

2007-11-21 32557, 2007

7:07 AM
SerialNumber joined the channel

2007-11-21 32530, 2007

7:08 AM
HairMetalAddict has quit

2007-11-21 32552, 2007

7:08 AM
HairMetalAddict joined the channel

2007-11-21 32532, 2007

7:25 AM
SerialNumber^ has quit

2007-11-21 32541, 2007

7:42 AM
craayzie_ joined the channel

2007-11-21 32555, 2007

7:44 AM
SerialNumber^ joined the channel

2007-11-21 32555, 2007

7:59 AM
craayzie has quit

2007-11-21 32511, 2007

8:00 AM
Aankhen`` joined the channel

2007-11-21 32534, 2007

8:01 AM
SerialNumber has quit

2007-11-21 32520, 2007

8:07 AM
Dhraakellian has left the channel

2007-11-21 32526, 2007

8:11 AM
craayzie_ has quit

2007-11-21 32505, 2007

8:34 AM
rpedro joined the channel

2007-11-21 32537, 2007

8:41 AM
symphonick joined the channel

2007-11-21 32519, 2007

8:51 AM
bplatt has left the channel

2007-11-21 32546, 2007

9:17 AM
bplatt_ joined the channel

2007-11-21 32547, 2007

9:17 AM
SerialNumber joined the channel

2007-11-21 32500, 2007

9:34 AM
SerialNumber^ has quit

2007-11-21 32512, 2007

9:52 AM
Igor_6667 has quit

2007-11-21 32511, 2007

10:06 AM
symphonick

What AR do I use for "Re-Issue production"? "Additional"?

2007-11-21 32530, 2007

10:07 AM
drsaunde

yah...i'd go with that

2007-11-21 32500, 2007

10:09 AM
symphonick

& likewise for remastered "additional mastering" I suppose?

2007-11-21 32546, 2007

10:21 AM
mudcrow joined the channel

2007-11-21 32540, 2007

10:30 AM
drsaunde

yeah

2007-11-21 32557, 2007

10:44 AM
SerialNumber^ joined the channel

2007-11-21 32515, 2007

11:02 AM
SerialNumber has quit

2007-11-21 32532, 2007

11:07 AM
rtv has quit

2007-11-21 32551, 2007

11:08 AM
rtv joined the channel

2007-11-21 32535, 2007

11:17 AM
HairMetalAddict has quit

2007-11-21 32519, 2007

11:18 AM
HairMetalAddict joined the channel

2007-11-21 32528, 2007

11:20 AM
mudcrow

juhae http://musicbrainz.org/show/artist/?artistid=3413… are you sure that Deadline are an Austrian band?

2007-11-21 32546, 2007

11:20 AM
mudcrow

http://musicbrainz.org/release/33ac3635-c4ae-4f09… has a track of the same name.

2007-11-21 32530, 2007

11:23 AM
juhae

Hmm, could be the same then

2007-11-21 32554, 2007

11:23 AM
juhae

I have that EP and I assumed all the bands are from Austria as there's no mention of different nationalities anywhere

2007-11-21 32519, 2007

11:24 AM
juhae

Honestly though, Kurwa Aparata is the only Austrian band with 100% in that compilation

2007-11-21 32527, 2007

11:24 AM
juhae

(despite the polish name)

2007-11-21 32538, 2007

11:27 AM
mudcrow

as far as I can tell, theres the 80s punk band Deadline from USA & the 90s punk band Deadline from UK who are signed to a German label, which maybe why I see loads of refs to a German band

2007-11-21 32516, 2007

11:28 AM
mudcrow

http://www.vinylgeneration.co.uk/scumville.php the new scumville, although not as good

2007-11-21 32520, 2007

11:36 AM
dalen joined the channel

2007-11-21 32559, 2007

11:48 AM
juhae

i'll have to double-check that compilation ep when i get back home

2007-11-21 32512, 2007

11:49 AM
juhae

just in case if there's some sort of additional info

2007-11-21 32552, 2007

11:49 AM
juhae

prolly the same though

2007-11-21 32538, 2007

12:02 PM
Stonekeeper joined the channel

2007-11-21 32514, 2007

12:09 PM
Alphasee has quit

2007-11-21 32513, 2007

12:11 PM
Stonekeeper has left the channel

2007-11-21 32516, 2007

13:06 PM
SerialNumber joined the channel

2007-11-21 32547, 2007

13:23 PM
SerialNumber^ has quit

2007-11-21 32511, 2007

13:28 PM
symphonick has quit

2007-11-21 32535, 2007

14:14 PM
foolip joined the channel

2007-11-21 32518, 2007

14:30 PM
luks joined the channel

2007-11-21 32541, 2007

14:30 PM
SerialNumber^ joined the channel

2007-11-21 32535, 2007

14:46 PM
Igor_6667 joined the channel

2007-11-21 32530, 2007

14:47 PM
SerialNumber has quit

2007-11-21 32545, 2007

14:49 PM
dalen has quit

2007-11-21 32516, 2007

14:53 PM
CatCat

nikki: re http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=3035280 i google/wikipediaetet it http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dideba_zetsit_kurthe…

2007-11-21 32521, 2007

14:54 PM
CatCat was buzy

2007-11-21 32542, 2007

14:54 PM
CatCat

i beat the boss after waking up \o/

2007-11-21 32556, 2007

14:54 PM
CatCat

nothing liek beating a boss first thing in the morning

2007-11-21 32513, 2007

15:01 PM
Shepard

that'd be an awesome start into the day :)

2007-11-21 32510, 2007

15:04 PM
warp

CatCat: congrats :), which boss?

2007-11-21 32513, 2007

15:08 PM
nikki

ah

2007-11-21 32517, 2007

15:08 PM
nikki goes to fix it then ;)

2007-11-21 32517, 2007

15:36 PM
SerialNumber joined the channel

2007-11-21 32516, 2007

15:43 PM
Kerensky97 joined the channel

2007-11-21 32548, 2007

15:53 PM
SerialNumber^ has quit

2007-11-21 32515, 2007

15:58 PM
symphonick joined the channel

2007-11-21 32550, 2007

16:02 PM
foolip has quit

2007-11-21 32509, 2007

16:13 PM
luks has quit

2007-11-21 32508, 2007

16:19 PM
brianfreud has quit

2007-11-21 32525, 2007

16:19 PM
brianfreud joined the channel

2007-11-21 32529, 2007

16:42 PM
symphonick

Someone into soundtracks? "Alexander Nevskiy" by Prokofiev, CSG or not?

2007-11-21 32533, 2007

16:42 PM
symphonick

http://musicbrainz.org/show/release/?releaseid=26…

2007-11-21 32539, 2007

17:00 PM
bplatt_

symphonic: Are you asking if it should be classical-style composer-as-artist, or full CSG?

2007-11-21 32517, 2007

17:01 PM
bplatt_

At first glance, it looks about right for Soundtrack Style with composer as artist.

2007-11-21 32513, 2007

17:02 PM
bplatt_

There's also a cantata which should be full CSG. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Nevsky_(Pr…

2007-11-21 32517, 2007

17:04 PM
brianfreud

symphonick: I don't know the work, but this looks like Prokofiev composed it for the score, not as a stand alone classical work?

2007-11-21 32536, 2007

17:04 PM
symphonick

Yeah, full or not.

2007-11-21 32519, 2007

17:06 PM
brianfreud

I'd agree with bplatt on the artist, though be it CSG or soundtrack, either uses composer as artist, so it's a non-issue there

2007-11-21 32555, 2007

17:07 PM
bplatt_

This is the film score, so I'd say not full CSG.

2007-11-21 32521, 2007

17:08 PM
brianfreud

If it wasn't written to be stand-alone, I'd think there's not an issue of work/movements and such for CSG treatment

2007-11-21 32534, 2007

17:08 PM
symphonick

Ok, thanks bplatt_ & brianfreud - thought I'd check - haven't done much soundtracks...

2007-11-21 32519, 2007

17:10 PM
bplatt_

This version should be full CSG: http://musicbrainz.org/release/cd6257fa-1010-48d5…

2007-11-21 32553, 2007

17:10 PM
bplatt_

(and a couple others)

2007-11-21 32507, 2007

17:13 PM
brianfreud

hmm, the example I was going to give seems to never have been entered, but here you can see a similar tracklist for an English-speaking composer (Metropolis) http://www.gorila.sk/product/47813

2007-11-21 32548, 2007

17:13 PM
symphonick

bplatt_, hmm, there's no performers on that one

2007-11-21 32554, 2007

17:13 PM
brianfreud

(or perhaps German - latin script, anyhow)

2007-11-21 32556, 2007

17:14 PM
bplatt_

symphonick: indeed - there's not enough there to allow us to identify it.

2007-11-21 32515, 2007

17:15 PM
symphonick

Why no edit history?

2007-11-21 32535, 2007

17:15 PM
brianfreud

yes, it would appear there was the original score, then a rearrangement for standalone performance: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Nevsky_(Pr…

2007-11-21 32535, 2007

17:15 PM
bplatt_

Suspect it pre-dates edit notes.

2007-11-21 32559, 2007

17:15 PM
bplatt_ thought he said that :-)

2007-11-21 32516, 2007

17:16 PM
brianfreud

lol

2007-11-21 32547, 2007

17:16 PM
brianfreud

didn't see your wiki link, was searching for Metropolis at the time :)

2007-11-21 32556, 2007

17:16 PM
bplatt_

ah

2007-11-21 32545, 2007

17:17 PM
symphonick

There's a swedish saying that goes approx "Repetition is the mother of knowledge" :-)

2007-11-21 32554, 2007

17:17 PM
brianfreud

we have some of the rescorings in the database, but no recordings of the original Huppertz score

2007-11-21 32547, 2007

17:19 PM
symphonick

Shall we kill http://musicbrainz.org/release/cd6257fa-1010-48d5…

2007-11-21 32526, 2007

17:20 PM
bplatt_

It *does* have a discid, which would make me reluctant to simply drop it without a little research.

2007-11-21 32554, 2007

17:20 PM
bplatt_

I could do a bit of digging later on - can't really look at it right now.

2007-11-21 32508, 2007

17:21 PM
symphonick

Sure.

2007-11-21 32531, 2007

17:22 PM
brianfreud

hmmm, is there any way to search for a toc in freedb?

2007-11-21 32523, 2007

17:23 PM
brianfreud

ah, http://www.freedb.org/freedb_discid_check.php

2007-11-21 32537, 2007

17:23 PM
brianfreud

oh, that's disc id, not cd toc

2007-11-21 32551, 2007

17:23 PM
bplatt_

53097207 is the disc ID

2007-11-21 32502, 2007

17:24 PM
bplatt_

(If you're looking for the same thing as me!)

2007-11-21 32525, 2007

17:24 PM
bplatt_

The Prokofiev release is classical/53097207

2007-11-21 32532, 2007

17:24 PM
dalen joined the channel

2007-11-21 32557, 2007

17:25 PM
brianfreud

hmm, nothing too useful in freedb, or via google for that discid

2007-11-21 32528, 2007

17:26 PM
brianfreud

I would be willing to bet, though, that this was originally a freedb import

2007-11-21 32523, 2007

17:27 PM
brianfreud

*s/note

2007-11-21 32524, 2007

17:27 PM
brianfreud

not

2007-11-21 32556, 2007

17:27 PM
brianfreud

the typos look like they happened separate from freedb ("Russian", not "Russia", etc)

2007-11-21 32531, 2007

17:29 PM
SerialNumber^ joined the channel

2007-11-21 32500, 2007

17:31 PM
brianfreud

and that particular series of typos for that track title only appears anywhere online at http://www.musiknews.de/album-view-41422/---alexa… - which is also useless. I'd agree with a remove, given there is nothing useful at all here.

2007-11-21 32556, 2007

17:33 PM
bplatt_

I'm tending towards that too.