#musicbrainz

/

      • brianfreud
        ok
      • 2007-11-21 32506, 2007

      • warp
        mo mo mo
      • 2007-11-21 32507, 2007

      • MClemo
        ah, ok. I guess we are fine for my edits now, because I did use the two ARs for "K" & "M" and not one for "K&M"
      • 2007-11-21 32509, 2007

      • CatCat
        been palying twighlight princess..
      • 2007-11-21 32513, 2007

      • CatCat
        warp warp warp!
      • 2007-11-21 32526, 2007

      • warp
        CatCat: so, a twilight princess boss then, this morning?
      • 2007-11-21 32531, 2007

      • CatCat
        yes!
      • 2007-11-21 32533, 2007

      • brianfreud
        ok, question is, should http://musicbrainz.org/release/377f13bb-17d3-4352… be VA or "Katia & Marielle Labèque" for release artist?
      • 2007-11-21 32533, 2007

      • CatCat
        the first one
      • 2007-11-21 32539, 2007

      • warp
        CatCat: wooh!
      • 2007-11-21 32548, 2007

      • warp
        CatCat: on gamecube?
      • 2007-11-21 32556, 2007

      • CatCat
        ja!
      • 2007-11-21 32514, 2007

      • warp
        CatCat: yay! much better than the wii version (my opinion ;).
      • 2007-11-21 32528, 2007

      • CatCat
        brianfreud: id use "Gershwin" as the artist :O
      • 2007-11-21 32543, 2007

      • warp looks at the link.
      • 2007-11-21 32506, 2007

      • MClemo
        CatCat: but Grainger is composer for track 2
      • 2007-11-21 32525, 2007

      • CatCat
        ?Fantasy on George Gershwin's "Porgy and Bess" / Percy Grainger <-- looks likek a variation on his theme
      • 2007-11-21 32539, 2007

      • CatCat
        why not use "addiionaly composer/rearanger"
      • 2007-11-21 32509, 2007

      • CatCat
        defintily shouldnt be on performers, you see the over has his name on top
      • 2007-11-21 32522, 2007

      • MClemo
        I guess that would have been ok too. god is this CSG business complicated
      • 2007-11-21 32527, 2007

      • warp would also say gershwin
      • 2007-11-21 32530, 2007

      • CatCat
        why not even album artist gershwin and first track gerswhin and second grainger
      • 2007-11-21 32553, 2007

      • CatCat doesnt really think its as complicated as peop l say itis :)
      • 2007-11-21 32534, 2007

      • warp makes a mental note of who to turn too when he'll enter his classical discs.
      • 2007-11-21 32537, 2007

      • warp
        CatCat: :P
      • 2007-11-21 32544, 2007

      • brianfreud
        I don't think it really is complicated either. I think these little catcorner exceptions, like "recital exception" make it WAY more complicated if you hit a cat corner though
      • 2007-11-21 32544, 2007

      • CatCat
        no problem
      • 2007-11-21 32501, 2007

      • CatCat
        unes you have oen of this brianfreudian type confusing messes
      • 2007-11-21 32530, 2007

      • CatCat
        "this is a confusing mess!" <- max laghton, Sanitarium
      • 2007-11-21 32532, 2007

      • brianfreud
        hahaha... this one wasn't even mine :D
      • 2007-11-21 32541, 2007

      • CatCat
        i know, i was MBslanign you..
      • 2007-11-21 32555, 2007

      • CatCat
        typing lik mo, shakign your head like inhouseuk
      • 2007-11-21 32500, 2007

      • CatCat
        slang*
      • 2007-11-21 32511, 2007

      • warp
        hm
      • 2007-11-21 32518, 2007

      • CatCat
        its a bout time he got one
      • 2007-11-21 32526, 2007

      • warp
        lol
      • 2007-11-21 32534, 2007

      • CatCat
      • 2007-11-21 32536, 2007

      • brianfreud
        hmmm, do I find enough funky things that my mere nick now implies confusingness? :D
      • 2007-11-21 32541, 2007

      • symphonick
        I'd still like to know why a duo don't need to be an artist in mb?
      • 2007-11-21 32543, 2007

      • CatCat
        indeed
      • 2007-11-21 32547, 2007

      • warp slightly jealous.
      • 2007-11-21 32548, 2007

      • symphonick
        doesn't
      • 2007-11-21 32550, 2007

      • CatCat
        you are the mastor of uh, that
      • 2007-11-21 32505, 2007

      • brianfreud is now the master of chaos!
      • 2007-11-21 32506, 2007

      • CatCat
        warp: its ok :)
      • 2007-11-21 32512, 2007

      • CatCat
        noo!! thats ruaok!
      • 2007-11-21 32521, 2007

      • MClemo
        you asshats
      • 2007-11-21 32521, 2007

      • warp
        symphonick: oh, they can be.
      • 2007-11-21 32526, 2007

      • CatCat
        the mayhem and caos co-ordinator
      • 2007-11-21 32531, 2007

      • brianfreud
        nono.... he's the master of mayhem AND chaos!
      • 2007-11-21 32534, 2007

      • warp
        symphonick: lots of so-called collaboration artists in MB.
      • 2007-11-21 32545, 2007

      • CatCat
        -> co-ordinator <-
      • 2007-11-21 32505, 2007

      • warp
        symphonick: some are proper groups, some only worked together on a single track. it is quite common.
      • 2007-11-21 32526, 2007

      • symphonick
        gah... I think I'm going loopy
      • 2007-11-21 32552, 2007

      • CatCat
        at-least you're not warped....
      • 2007-11-21 32559, 2007

      • warp
        >_<
      • 2007-11-21 32500, 2007

      • CatCat
        ok that was a cheap shot :P
      • 2007-11-21 32507, 2007

      • warp
        haha
      • 2007-11-21 32520, 2007

      • warp
        /nick loopy
      • 2007-11-21 32536, 2007

      • MClemo
      • 2007-11-21 32539, 2007

      • MClemo
        "typing like mo"
      • 2007-11-21 32525, 2007

      • nikki wants to play twilight princess :/
      • 2007-11-21 32510, 2007

      • brianfreud
        so MClemo, did mo manage to dewarpify this brianfreud?
      • 2007-11-21 32502, 2007

      • CatCat
        x_X
      • 2007-11-21 32505, 2007

      • MClemo
        brianfreud: Waga waga klepto!
      • 2007-11-21 32559, 2007

      • CatCat
        been a while since hes done 'at
      • 2007-11-21 32506, 2007

      • brianfreud
        lol, haven't see that one in a long time
      • 2007-11-21 32513, 2007

      • Muzzz wants to moose moar
      • 2007-11-21 32534, 2007

      • CatCat
        morrre
      • 2007-11-21 32509, 2007

      • brianfreud
        needs moar thingyness
      • 2007-11-21 32532, 2007

      • MClemo
        A-bomb looks useful too
      • 2007-11-21 32537, 2007

      • warp hippo's a bit.
      • 2007-11-21 32542, 2007

      • CatCat
        bogus, ok everyone, are you gonna moveit to gerswin or should I?
      • 2007-11-21 32546, 2007

      • symphonick
        Please, one more time guys: a (piano) duo performs on a release; why AR only as separate performers?
      • 2007-11-21 32559, 2007

      • CatCat
        BECAUSE ITS CLASSICAL
      • 2007-11-21 32510, 2007

      • symphonick
        :-)
      • 2007-11-21 32513, 2007

      • brianfreud
        because 1 person (normally) plays 1 piano
      • 2007-11-21 32528, 2007

      • CatCat
        .(and bicaus i say soo) [sic]
      • 2007-11-21 32531, 2007

      • brianfreud
        2 people (normally) play 2 pianos... and I assume in this case it is 2 pianos...
      • 2007-11-21 32553, 2007

      • CatCat
        brianfreud: thats also a good point
      • 2007-11-21 32506, 2007

      • Muzzz
      • 2007-11-21 32508, 2007

      • MClemo
        it would be just weird if they'd use three
      • 2007-11-21 32510, 2007

      • symphonick
        well, 1 person plays one violin, 1 other plays another, 1 persons plays a viola and a fourth a cello...
      • 2007-11-21 32530, 2007

      • brianfreud
        MClemo, could be one of those works for 4 or 6 or 8 hands
      • 2007-11-21 32539, 2007

      • warp
        symphonick: do they exist as a group? do they mostly perform together as a duo?
      • 2007-11-21 32545, 2007

      • brianfreud
        some of those are for a single piano
      • 2007-11-21 32557, 2007

      • symphonick
      • 2007-11-21 32520, 2007

      • brianfreud
        the bio implies they still are two people, even if they normally play together
      • 2007-11-21 32516, 2007

      • symphonick
        The bio implies they still are two people... :-) What's the alternative?
      • 2007-11-21 32525, 2007

      • brianfreud
        siamese twins?
      • 2007-11-21 32526, 2007

      • nikki giggles
      • 2007-11-21 32511, 2007

      • MClemo
        schizophrenia?
      • 2007-11-21 32533, 2007

      • symphonick
        How many pianos could they play then?
      • 2007-11-21 32505, 2007

      • symphonick
        cloning?
      • 2007-11-21 32533, 2007

      • brianfreud
        Katia seems to play with other duos/groups, apart from Marielle
      • 2007-11-21 32548, 2007

      • brianfreud
        "n 2001 Katia Labèque and Viktoria Mullova formed an new exciting duo, which has enjoyed international acclaim..."
      • 2007-11-21 32549, 2007

      • MClemo
        poor Marielle
      • 2007-11-21 32502, 2007

      • nikki
        I think I would have gone with one performer per instrument too (i.e. two pianos = two performers, duo playing on one piano = one performer), but what do I know :)
      • 2007-11-21 32525, 2007

      • brianfreud mentally replaces "piano" with something easy... "flute"
      • 2007-11-21 32504, 2007

      • nikki
        I've never seen two people play on the same flute together :o
      • 2007-11-21 32512, 2007

      • brianfreud
        exactly :)
      • 2007-11-21 32526, 2007

      • symphonick
        I've seen two people play the same cello :-)
      • 2007-11-21 32531, 2007

      • brianfreud stops thinking like FauxFaux
      • 2007-11-21 32540, 2007

      • nikki
        that's different ;)
      • 2007-11-21 32551, 2007

      • brianfreud
        ;)
      • 2007-11-21 32529, 2007

      • symphonick
        Why?
      • 2007-11-21 32536, 2007

      • nikki
        cellos are bigger
      • 2007-11-21 32547, 2007

      • nikki
        hmm
      • 2007-11-21 32548, 2007

      • brianfreud
        and bigger is not always better
      • 2007-11-21 32514, 2007

      • nikki
        but what happens if someone plays two instruments simultaneously? like I can play hot cross buns on two recorders at the same time :D
      • 2007-11-21 32546, 2007

      • symphonick
        Wait, I'll contact Sony Music... ;-)
      • 2007-11-21 32553, 2007

      • brianfreud
        must be an interesting trick to pull off the fingerings on each at the same time
      • 2007-11-21 32525, 2007

      • brianfreud
        My left hand is so used to the lower half, relearning to play the upper holes with it would be confusing
      • 2007-11-21 32535, 2007

      • nikki
        I always wished I knew a better tune that only used one hand...
      • 2007-11-21 32550, 2007

      • brianfreud
        heart and soul?
      • 2007-11-21 32529, 2007

      • nikki has never heard of it
      • 2007-11-21 32533, 2007

      • brianfreud
      • 2007-11-21 32526, 2007

      • demonhunter joined the channel
      • 2007-11-21 32533, 2007

      • nikki giggles to herself
      • 2007-11-21 32505, 2007

      • nikki
        my family always got annoyed because I would keep playing christmas carols on my recorder in the car in the middle of summer
      • 2007-11-21 32522, 2007

      • SerialNumber joined the channel
      • 2007-11-21 32538, 2007

      • MClemo
        I used to do that too
      • 2007-11-21 32544, 2007

      • MClemo
        it really freaks people out
      • 2007-11-21 32559, 2007

      • nikki
        which? play two recorders or play christmas carols? :)
      • 2007-11-21 32507, 2007

      • MClemo
        christmas carols
      • 2007-11-21 32510, 2007

      • nikki
        ah
      • 2007-11-21 32539, 2007

      • nikki
        ahh, I miss playing recorders
      • 2007-11-21 32540, 2007

      • brianfreud
        silent night....
      • 2007-11-21 32520, 2007

      • brianfreud
        my school elementary used to make everyone learn the recorder... and each christmas, they'd have the entire school play silent night on the recorder, all at once
      • 2007-11-21 32531, 2007

      • brianfreud
        sounded horrifyingly bad
      • 2007-11-21 32550, 2007

      • symphonick tries to comprehend the terror
      • 2007-11-21 32550, 2007

      • nikki
        D:
      • 2007-11-21 32552, 2007

      • nikki wonders where her recorders are anyway
      • 2007-11-21 32507, 2007

      • brianfreud
        ok, I've been thinking in French or something too much recently... "school elementary"???
      • 2007-11-21 32524, 2007

      • MClemo
        nikki: cassette recorder?
      • 2007-11-21 32551, 2007

      • brianfreud
      • 2007-11-21 32520, 2007

      • MClemo
        aha!
      • 2007-11-21 32521, 2007

      • symphonick
        "Blockflöte"?
      • 2007-11-21 32547, 2007

      • warp
        wow, what a weird name.
      • 2007-11-21 32551, 2007

      • MClemo
        I was forced to play that thing in my first year elementary
      • 2007-11-21 32534, 2007

      • brianfreud
        meh, made switching to the sax easy
      • 2007-11-21 32545, 2007

      • MClemo
        never practised and all the girls were so good at playing so I stood really out
      • 2007-11-21 32548, 2007

      • MClemo
        horrible
      • 2007-11-21 32520, 2007

      • symphonick
        I have to admit to having played those things too... still have a plastic Yamaha baroque recorder lying in the bookshelf...
      • 2007-11-21 32548, 2007

      • brianfreud
        did anyone here NOT play the recorder at some point?
      • 2007-11-21 32544, 2007

      • MClemo
        I guess it's a parent thing. when your kid gets to school it has to play recorder
      • 2007-11-21 32556, 2007

      • MClemo
        at least for my family. all kids played one year, no success at all, then quit
      • 2007-11-21 32500, 2007

      • brianfreud
        well, what other instrument is as cheap as $10?
      • 2007-11-21 32508, 2007

      • MClemo
        right
      • 2007-11-21 32520, 2007

      • symphonick
        Kazoo? Nose-flute?