#musicbrainz

/

      • SerialNumber
        I'd personally say so, BrianFreud.
      • 2007-06-02 15301, 2007

      • SerialNumber
        Having said that as the only comment of the night, I shall vanish again, good night.
      • 2007-06-02 15322, 2007

      • inhouseuk has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15332, 2007

      • inhouseuk__ joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15336, 2007

      • inhouseuk__
        inhouseuk__ is now known as inhouseuk
      • 2007-06-02 15331, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        drsaunde: You around?
      • 2007-06-02 15355, 2007

      • SenRepus
        SenRepus has joined #Musicbrainz
      • 2007-06-02 15328, 2007

      • Muz_
        :D
      • 2007-06-02 15335, 2007

      • Muz_ just met up with ruaok
      • 2007-06-02 15341, 2007

      • Muz_ is also drunk :D
      • 2007-06-02 15340, 2007

      • toxickore joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15304, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        Anyone who has been involved in the CotM, and thinks they know some of the background to all the confusion, I'd appreciate if you'd take a look at edit http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=6972116
      • 2007-06-02 15315, 2007

      • FauxFaux
        Muz_: :D
      • 2007-06-02 15324, 2007

      • Amblin has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15320, 2007

      • Amblin joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15327, 2007

      • phrontist has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15347, 2007

      • drsaunde
        brian: i am here now
      • 2007-06-02 15317, 2007

      • drsaunde has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15306, 2007

      • Muz_
        DO DOD DODODODOODDODODODDODDODODODODODODODODODODODODODODODDDODODODDODODOdODODODODODODODODODODODODODODODODODDODODODODODOODODODODODODOd
      • 2007-06-02 15318, 2007

      • inhouseuk has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15331, 2007

      • inhouseuk__ joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15335, 2007

      • inhouseuk__
        inhouseuk__ is now known as inhouseuk
      • 2007-06-02 15349, 2007

      • drsaunde joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15302, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        drsaunde: Since it's one you've worked on, plus some considerations re: CotM, wanted to give you a heads up on http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=6972116
      • 2007-06-02 15335, 2007

      • Knio1 joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15321, 2007

      • Knio has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15318, 2007

      • drsaunde
        Brian: I never worked on that one...but I found a link to a scan of the original Jamaican edition
      • 2007-06-02 15328, 2007

      • Jugdish
        brian: i'd using "background vocals" for "backing vocals"
      • 2007-06-02 15328, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        Jugdish: yeah, I ended up doing that
      • 2007-06-02 15338, 2007

      • Jugdish
        ok
      • 2007-06-02 15346, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        drsaunde: Was looking for that - what band name is on it?
      • 2007-06-02 15323, 2007

      • drsaunde
        Bob & wailers
      • 2007-06-02 15330, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        yeah
      • 2007-06-02 15347, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        To me, it looks like the name changed when scratch came on board, not in 74
      • 2007-06-02 15317, 2007

      • drsaunde
        same cover as the trojan version...confirmed with the same on the Upsetter record
      • 2007-06-02 15324, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        yeah
      • 2007-06-02 15329, 2007

      • BrianFreud
      • 2007-06-02 15343, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        Both of which would be the next 2 albums, which we also have as just "The Wailers"
      • 2007-06-02 15348, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        And African Herbsman, which came after those 2 (http://www.roots-archives.com/display_artwork/327…)
      • 2007-06-02 15316, 2007

      • BrianFreud
      • 2007-06-02 15330, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        go back to "The Wailers" - then you hit 1974, and Tosh and Wailer leave
      • 2007-06-02 15341, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        and it's back to "Bob Marley & The Wailers" until he dies
      • 2007-06-02 15334, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        So is it really TW1 --> BM&TW1 --> TW2 --> BM&TW2 --> TW3?
      • 2007-06-02 15352, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        rather than TW1 --> BM&TW --> TW2?
      • 2007-06-02 15304, 2007

      • Jugdish
        brian: what do you put for the release date of a live bootleg?
      • 2007-06-02 15314, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        pressed or circulating?
      • 2007-06-02 15338, 2007

      • drsaunde
        if that's confusing...check out Robert Cray vs. Robert Cray Band...go back and forth many more times than than
      • 2007-06-02 15339, 2007

      • drsaunde
        that
      • 2007-06-02 15343, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        lol
      • 2007-06-02 15317, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        well, problem is, we actually have divided TW (original) and BM&TW at 1974 - but it looks like they used BM&TW as early as 1970
      • 2007-06-02 15334, 2007

      • toxickore has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15300, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        I'd have to look to see if anything changed lineup wise in 1973 for those 2 middle TW releases
      • 2007-06-02 15302, 2007

      • Jugdish_ joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15353, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        yup - 1970, Scratch Perry starts being the producer, they change to BM&TW. 1973, Scratch Perry no longer the producer, (he's still working on BM solo releases though), they switch back to TW. 1974, Tosh and Wailer leave, it's back to BM&TW
      • 2007-06-02 15324, 2007

      • Jugdish_
        brian: not pressed
      • 2007-06-02 15332, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        no release event then
      • 2007-06-02 15318, 2007

      • Jugdish_
        :/
      • 2007-06-02 15322, 2007

      • drsaunde
        impossible to determine with any accuracy
      • 2007-06-02 15323, 2007

      • hawke_
        should (acoustic) be added to all acoustic tracks?
      • 2007-06-02 15340, 2007

      • drsaunde
        no..not if its all the tracks
      • 2007-06-02 15300, 2007

      • hawke_
        If it's one track on the album?
      • 2007-06-02 15307, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        I normally still leave it off, save it for track annotations
      • 2007-06-02 15351, 2007

      • drsaunde
        well...if that one track is labelled as such on the release i'd add it
      • 2007-06-02 15318, 2007

      • hawke_
        I'm particularly not a fan of (live) (acoustic) -- and even more so if it's not listed as such on the album
      • 2007-06-02 15323, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        well, en regards a circulating boot, it's just labeled whatever someone labeled it
      • 2007-06-02 15310, 2007

      • hawke_
      • 2007-06-02 15313, 2007

      • hawke_
        the last track
      • 2007-06-02 15344, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        there I'd leave it as it is
      • 2007-06-02 15349, 2007

      • hawke_
        why?
      • 2007-06-02 15354, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        official release
      • 2007-06-02 15309, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        I assume it says "(accoustic)" oin the liner
      • 2007-06-02 15313, 2007

      • hawke_
        no, it doesn't
      • 2007-06-02 15316, 2007

      • hawke_
        it doesn't even say (live)
      • 2007-06-02 15327, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        then byebye () :P
      • 2007-06-02 15335, 2007

      • hawke_
        both, or just acoustic?
      • 2007-06-02 15335, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        imho :P
      • 2007-06-02 15337, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        both
      • 2007-06-02 15349, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        but that's just my opinion
      • 2007-06-02 15302, 2007

      • hawke_
        imo too...
      • 2007-06-02 15310, 2007

      • hawke_
        but http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/LiveTrackStyle suggests otherwise, at least somewhat
      • 2007-06-02 15341, 2007

      • hawke_
        and both () were put in with the justification "According to Style Guide."
      • 2007-06-02 15346, 2007

      • hawke_
      • 2007-06-02 15339, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        LiveTrackStyle is only a proposal, and every time I've tried to use it on any official release, I get voted down due to Extraneous Track Info
      • 2007-06-02 15301, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        it's really only intended, from what I can gather, to give some way to ID filler tracks on pressed bootlegs
      • 2007-06-02 15353, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        and even there, some argue it ought to still be a track annotation
      • 2007-06-02 15351, 2007

      • hawke_
        ah, I missed that it was only "proposed"
      • 2007-06-02 15303, 2007

      • hawke_
        fixed
      • 2007-06-02 15323, 2007

      • hawke_
      • 2007-06-02 15316, 2007

      • Jugdish has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15317, 2007

      • Jugdish_
        Jugdish_ is now known as Jugdish
      • 2007-06-02 15341, 2007

      • Knio1
        Knio1 is now known as Knio
      • 2007-06-02 15311, 2007

      • MrQwerty
        What title would you give to this album by the band "Strata"?
      • 2007-06-02 15314, 2007

      • MrQwerty
      • 2007-06-02 15350, 2007

      • hawke_
        "Strata Presents the End of the World"
      • 2007-06-02 15351, 2007

      • MrQwerty
        I could see a case being made for "The End of the World", "Presents the End of the World", or even "Strata Presents the End of the World"
      • 2007-06-02 15321, 2007

      • Aankhen``
        !quit
      • 2007-06-02 15322, 2007

      • YAUB has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15346, 2007

      • hawke_
        I could also see "...Presents the end of the World"
      • 2007-06-02 15349, 2007

      • MrQwerty
        Yeah... argh, this is driving me crazy
      • 2007-06-02 15355, 2007

      • MrQwerty
        I keep going back and forth
      • 2007-06-02 15301, 2007

      • hawke_
        but in order of my preference: "Strata Presents the End of the World", "...Presents the end of the World", "Presents the End of the World",
      • 2007-06-02 15335, 2007

      • MrQwerty
      • 2007-06-02 15328, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        lol, next up for the Rockabye Baby series... Green Day, The Rolling Stones, and The Pixies :P
      • 2007-06-02 15304, 2007

      • hawke_
        hehe
      • 2007-06-02 15339, 2007

      • drsaunde
        eh..that's a bad precedent a release with very little info
      • 2007-06-02 15350, 2007

      • drsaunde
        I would say "Presents the End of the World"
      • 2007-06-02 15356, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        This guy must be making $ hand over fist... 16 releases in the last 10 months, with another next week, and 2 more before the end of the month
      • 2007-06-02 15359, 2007

      • MrQwerty
        Yeah I guess that's what I'll end up going with
      • 2007-06-02 15325, 2007

      • MrQwerty
        Thanks people
      • 2007-06-02 15322, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        Aankhen``: Is YAUB dead?
      • 2007-06-02 15335, 2007

      • eckdoug_ joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15308, 2007

      • Aankhen``
        BrianFreud: Having a little trouble with VMWare, give me a few minutes.
      • 2007-06-02 15346, 2007

      • chillware has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15320, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        np
      • 2007-06-02 15302, 2007

      • Aankhen`` has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15323, 2007

      • eckdoug_ has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15323, 2007

      • Aankhen`` joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15353, 2007

      • YAUB joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15307, 2007

      • Aankhen``
        BrianFreud: There you go. :-)
      • 2007-06-02 15339, 2007

      • Amblin- joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15332, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        lol, just finished :P
      • 2007-06-02 15338, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        used that one website instead
      • 2007-06-02 15342, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        thanks though :)
      • 2007-06-02 15356, 2007

      • Jugdish_ joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15331, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        Jugdish_: lol, just cleaned up the entire "Rockabye Baby" series :P
      • 2007-06-02 15352, 2007

      • BrianFreud
        that must be a sign of boredom
      • 2007-06-02 15327, 2007

      • Amblin has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15326, 2007

      • Jugdish has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15327, 2007

      • Jugdish_
        Jugdish_ is now known as Jugdish
      • 2007-06-02 15335, 2007

      • SenRepus has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15323, 2007

      • muz mooses
      • 2007-06-02 15324, 2007

      • cooperaa joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15328, 2007

      • cooperaa has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15356, 2007

      • Aankhen``
        !calc 3000 / 5
      • 2007-06-02 15356, 2007

      • YAUB
        Aankhen``: 600
      • 2007-06-02 15356, 2007

      • Amblin-
        Google calculator: <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/600" class=l>600 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia</a>
      • 2007-06-02 15316, 2007

      • Aankhen`` stares at Amblin-.
      • 2007-06-02 15333, 2007

      • muz
        Oh god
      • 2007-06-02 15343, 2007

      • muz
        Meeting rob again tomorrow and getting drunk again D:
      • 2007-06-02 15318, 2007

      • YAUB has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15309, 2007

      • Aankh|Clone joined the channel
      • 2007-06-02 15304, 2007

      • Aankhen`` has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15304, 2007

      • UserError has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15304, 2007

      • HairMetalAddict has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15304, 2007

      • sdbrady has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15304, 2007

      • rpedro has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15304, 2007

      • muz has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15304, 2007

      • HiFructose has quit
      • 2007-06-02 15308, 2007

      • Aankh|Clone
        Aankh|Clone is now known as Aankhen``
      • 2007-06-02 15308, 2007

      • UserError joined the channel