This isn't directly related to musicbrainz since I don't think that a release can contain more than one CD and instead the titles get changed to something like This Album (Disc 1) and This Album (Disc 2) with two release IDs for it. But, if it was to support multi-disc albums, then would it make sense to have a disc artist for such an album?
2007-04-15 10533, 2007
BrianG
?
2007-04-15 10548, 2007
BrianG
are all the tracks by the same artist?
2007-04-15 10501, 2007
errorlevel
I don't know. But, I can imagine an album that has Disc 1 as being a regular album disc and then a Disc 2 that has remixes of the stuff on Disc 1 but by different artists. It seems like it would make sense to change the Artist for Disc 2 to Various Artists.
2007-04-15 10544, 2007
BrianG
no leave the artist name
2007-04-15 10558, 2007
BrianG
as the disc artist
2007-04-15 10509, 2007
errorlevel
Okay. I wonder if there have ever been any multi-disc releases that had one disc by one artist and the other disc by another. Perhaps something like a split album with two discs.
2007-04-15 10508, 2007
warp
errorlevel: probably.
2007-04-15 10531, 2007
warp
errorlevel: there's lots of vinyl releases with one side by one artist and the other by another artist :)
2007-04-15 10508, 2007
errorlevel
The last stuff on records that I ever had were the little records that were included with kids books that were essentially an etched page that you took out of the book. =)
2007-04-15 10520, 2007
errorlevel
So, they were a bit before my time.
2007-04-15 10538, 2007
warp
peculiar.
2007-04-15 10551, 2007
warp
most of the records i purchase were manufactured this century atleast :)
2007-04-15 10525, 2007
errorlevel
Well, I don't have a record player, either. So that plays (pun-intended) into it. =)
Shepard: But what if a release is considered to contain multiple discs rather than just have a disc to release mapping? Would it make sense then to give the disc an artist property as well as give the release an artist property?
2007-04-15 10541, 2007
errorlevel
Shepard: That's the question I have.
2007-04-15 10518, 2007
SenRepus
hi shep
2007-04-15 10528, 2007
SenRepus
now im stuck arguing with the guy who imported that messy german aggro
2007-04-15 10530, 2007
srotta
errorlevel: I'd say yes - we already define that, for example, release type of each disc on a multi-disc release is decided independently.
2007-04-15 10552, 2007
srotta
errorlevel: Having a disc artist would be a logical extension.
2007-04-15 10525, 2007
srotta
Plus, I do have (at least) one release that has three discs where the third disc is by a separate artist.
2007-04-15 10541, 2007
errorlevel
=) Thanks.
2007-04-15 10555, 2007
BrianG
i hate boxed sets taht are just repackaged releases that are sold seperately
2007-04-15 10525, 2007
SenRepus
just another example of capitalism
2007-04-15 10558, 2007
srotta
Well, no different from compilations, really. It just takes the compiling one level up.
2007-04-15 10522, 2007
BrianG
s/up/down
2007-04-15 10538, 2007
BrianG
you have the loose yourself singe, call it that
2007-04-15 10539, 2007
BrianG
heh
2007-04-15 10510, 2007
MrQwerty has quit
2007-04-15 10530, 2007
Aankhen`` joined the channel
2007-04-15 10523, 2007
SenRepus
gurt, thank you for the yesses
2007-04-15 10537, 2007
BrianG
np
2007-04-15 10541, 2007
BrianG
its 420, dudes
2007-04-15 10538, 2007
SenRepus
its 325 here
2007-04-15 10503, 2007
Aankhen``
1:21 here.
2007-04-15 10543, 2007
SenRepus turns his clock back 4 minutes
2007-04-15 10556, 2007
Amblin- has quit
2007-04-15 10537, 2007
yoasif has quit
2007-04-15 10534, 2007
BrianG
is it me or does the http:// not dissapear anymore when clicking on the URL field when adding ARs?
2007-04-15 10527, 2007
BrianG
nevermind
2007-04-15 10534, 2007
BrianG
my junks pretty unresponsive today
2007-04-15 10532, 2007
SenRepus
im off to a funeral. bye
2007-04-15 10540, 2007
Aankhen``
Aankhen`` is now known as Aankhen
2007-04-15 10556, 2007
Aankhen
Aankhen is now known as Aankhen``
2007-04-15 10557, 2007
MrQwerty joined the channel
2007-04-15 10505, 2007
intgr
Heh... "There is a reason some music is free... will we pay to make it stop?"
2007-04-15 10505, 2007
BigMcLargeHuge has quit
2007-04-15 10544, 2007
Atahualpa joined the channel
2007-04-15 10542, 2007
catgroove
good night all
2007-04-15 10544, 2007
catgroove
catgroove is now known as nightgroove
2007-04-15 10550, 2007
Atahualpa has left the channel
2007-04-15 10500, 2007
stochasticism has quit
2007-04-15 10504, 2007
mudcrow joined the channel
2007-04-15 10556, 2007
nightgroove is asleep http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/CollaborationOfTheMonth
2007-04-15 10559, 2007
HairMetalAddict has quit
2007-04-15 10508, 2007
HairMetalAddict joined the channel
2007-04-15 10545, 2007
yoasif joined the channel
2007-04-15 10507, 2007
yoasif has quit
2007-04-15 10550, 2007
yoasif joined the channel
2007-04-15 10500, 2007
yoasif has quit
2007-04-15 10511, 2007
yoasif joined the channel
2007-04-15 10549, 2007
Synchro has quit
2007-04-15 10542, 2007
Synchro joined the channel
2007-04-15 10523, 2007
coopera[a] joined the channel
2007-04-15 10549, 2007
coopera[a] pukes as Stevie Wonder comes on shuffle
2007-04-15 10502, 2007
coopera[a]
coopera[a] is now known as cooperaa
2007-04-15 10511, 2007
SenRepus
hi cooperaa
2007-04-15 10517, 2007
SenRepus
im on page 16 >.<
2007-04-15 10550, 2007
cooperaa
jeepers!
2007-04-15 10512, 2007
cooperaa
keep up the good work
2007-04-15 10521, 2007
cooperaa
I couldn't do that stuff... got tedious :)
2007-04-15 10524, 2007
SenRepus
we took off 11 pages yesterday though
2007-04-15 10533, 2007
cooperaa
I might've done 2 pages...
2007-04-15 10500, 2007
cooperaa
I'll do another Add Release blitz :)
2007-04-15 10559, 2007
SenRepus
make sure you get the asins right >,<
2007-04-15 10550, 2007
SenRepus
actually, scratch that
2007-04-15 10501, 2007
SenRepus
try to get them wrong, see if its even possibe. i couldnt do it. if you add any, i mean
