#musicbrainz

i hate compilations of stuff which was released previously.

I love VA comps. I collect them

I don't expect PicardQT to match each track in a VA album back to its original album,

because I will never in my life own all those cds from 1959

if I want it, I can move it

CDs from 1959? ;)

reissued ;)

:)

what's so wrong about asking someone who wants a Top 40 hits album to move the tracks by hand out of the albums too?

and the same holds true in reverse

but theres 1000's of official compilations cataloguing that era, why add bootlegs that contain tracks that are widely availble on 1000's ot other releases

*/that's NO reason I meant to say

because those releases aren't as widely available as the torrent is

that's exactly my point

so?

like I say

all those silly compilations, maybe 10 people on earth own

let them ID the tracks, then manually move them back together

thousands of people "own" these torrents

BrianFreud: it isn't that easy

mudcrow: apparantly enough people prefer this particular bootleg compilation.

just like I take the VA compilation and manually move it apart

lol

so it doesn't get tagged that way

So Cooperaa, if the 5 or 6 of us talking right now were to decide on our top 10 tracks and create a "Best of MB IRC April21" compilation, that would be worthy of entry?

exactly coop

(and chances are someone was doing that do be a douche)

like someone who ruined the Trivium charts with bogus track names

"Everybody, NP now and send them to me!"

BrianFreud: if it's useful to you, sure

as long as its categorized that way

PlaylistBrainz :)

Is the XML WebService having problems right now? Or, is the database down?

no, I don't think they should be compilations

database is down/dying errorlevel

Oh, okay.

I don't think we can handle them currently

but I think they would be good to have

On the plus side, at least this is helping me test out the error-handling code in my application. =)

hell, doesn't stop us now...

lol

Live vs. Compilation is such an overloaded single choice field...

BrianFreud: they could be like torrents, if someone doesn't tag against the release in 6 months, kill it or something

although, then we're deleting history :P

idunno, pretty complex issue

haha

actually, that's what I was just thinking is kind of the standard imho

the alternative times should probably be accepted as valid bootlegs, but if they are, where do you draw the line between whats an acceptable bootleg and millions of homebrew comps

"will this release even exist 6 months from now"

a torrent'd bootleg of a concert, definately

its a very good point

some homebrew? maybe, maybe not

some torrents last several years on a single tracker though

its quite amazing

WinXPGold.torrent... Win2003.torrent...

lol

cooperaa: hm, really?

warp: yup

yes, some rare ones

like "Top500Songsof1900-2000"

but "Homebrew mix from random canadian guy #88"?

ya, I wouldn't say they are rare... they are the most popular that survive

whenever I download a bootleg. I always consider its value for entering into MB. The number consideration is are these tracks widely available on official releases, if yes, it dont get entered

how many will actually exist though?

http://thepiratebay.org/tor/3496583/BillBoard_T... added almost a year ago

my brother for example, is one who grabs those

3 months later, he's deleted 99% of the tracks, as he got tired of em

brrrr

yeah, but see cooperaa, that's one we decided NOT to list

lol

http://thepiratebay.org/tor/3245499/Billboard_1... added october 7, 2004

still active

they're the same people who keep every single track in their Winamp/ITunes playlist on shuffle cooperaa

cooperaa: impressive.

BrianFreud: I don't care who plays them

I have all those billboard lists in iTunes, what's your point?

luks, ping

I keep every track in itunes, and on shuffle

no, I mean every single track on their computer all in one big list

on shuffle

some days I like to take a trip back to 1950

so they delete the ones they're tired of

BrianFreud: that's stupid, who cares how people listen to music

I'm not talking about how they listen to it

I listen on shuffle most of the time

and some times I like to listen to albums on shuffle

doesnt bother me how people listen to music, as long as they enjoy it

I'm talking about whether the "release" will still exist anywhere 6 months later

sometimes I like to listen to a particular genre

BrianFreud: yes, the release existing is important

I started adding genre to my collection, then it seemed pointless as everything was listed as punk

see, those types of releases I just think are ones that won't still exist

but like several releases in the db now, you'll never see a physical copy because they are owned privately or maybe only 100 copies were made

a bootleg of a concert will

a billboard top list will

a random homebrew won't

a random homebrew won't

billboard top lists are copyrighted, which was a major reason for removing them

yes, I remember that mudcrow ...

side note: are they still copyrighted if it's a released (CD) set?

although how you can copyright a list of things is beyond me

I know I've seen CD releases of entire Billboard lists...

how can they copyright something based on sales numbers?

mudcrow: exactly what I was thinking

BrianFreud: I've seen lists, but they are like 10 songs for each year

you can't copyright a fact

you CAN copyright a collection of facts, though

Ewww! Gross!

but they are americans, americans seem to think you can own anything, like gracenote

that's what the original cddb did when they went private

hahaha

hm

cooperaa - I've seen 10, 20, 50 disc sets which are entire year sets

iirc database laws in europe are more strict as to what can be copyrighted and what can't.

yeah

in the US, a fact can not be copyrighted

a collection of inter-related facts can be

hence cddb nesessitating freedb

and musicbrainz

thought the mb db was in the cc?

(not sure) but I thought MB was PD

problem was that noone ever thought to put the cddb database into the creative commons, then the company went IPO

PD is scary, not every country has that concept. in those countries it ends up being not distributable at all.

yeah... cc is a much better license

cc has its problems, but its decent.

it needs more tla's.

and PUIDs

hell, and TRMs

yay, there's one!

and even discIDs

lol

and i don't even know it means.

not a clue what TRM or PUID stand for :P

what does GNO stand for?

I kept hearing it in my business class :P

gnu is not a (something)

girls night out?

Gnomes Not Ohms

GNO, or GNP?

warp: I've seen that but couldn't find something that related to biz

do they list trm and puid?